Discussion NRL SuperCoach Discussion

Connoisseur

Leadership Group
Joined
3 Jul 2017
Messages
38,960
Likes
126,628
AFL Club
Port Adelaide
Score: 993
Rd Rank: 64416
Overall Rank: 30435 (from 18956)

Current side before trades:
1592346138385.png


Trade options involve:
1. Out: R Papenhuyzen, Z Lomax, In: J Tedesco, H Tabuai- Fidow
$235,700 remaining salary allowing W Kennedy to E Yeo next week.

2. Out: Z Lomax, E Marsters, In: B Morris and L Mitchell
$60,900 remaining salary hopefully allowing S Drinkwater and Kennedy to N Cleary and H Tabuai-Fidow next week.

3. Out: E Marsters, L Leilau, In: L Mitchell and C McInnes
$100 short of trading Hess instead of Leilau.
$40,600 remaining salary allowing Z Lomax and W Kennedy to I Yeo and H Tabuai-Fidow next week.

4. Out: C Hess, R Paperhuyzen, In: C McInnes and L Mitchell
$72,400 remaining salary to be used for W Kennedy to H Tabuai-Fidow thus allowing E Marsters to L Mitchell/I Yeo.

5. Out: T Rudolf, E Marsters, In: A Fonua-Blake and L Mitchell
$7000 remaining salary to be used for Z Lomax to H Tabuai-Fidow and hopefuly W Kennedy/S Drinkwater to E Yeo/N Cleary
 
Joined
16 Dec 2018
Messages
1,356
Likes
3,746
AFL Club
GWS Giants
Score: 993
Rd Rank: 64416
Overall Rank: 30435 (from 18956)

Current side before trades:
View attachment 17832


Trade options involve:
1. Out: R Papenhuyzen, Z Lomax, In: J Tedesco, H Tabuai- Fidow
$235,700 remaining salary allowing W Kennedy to E Yeo next week.

2. Out: Z Lomax, E Marsters, In: B Morris and L Mitchell
$60,900 remaining salary hopefully allowing S Drinkwater and Kennedy to N Cleary and H Tabuai-Fidow next week.

3. Out: E Marsters, L Leilau, In: L Mitchell and C McInnes
$100 short of trading Hess instead of Leilau.
$40,600 remaining salary allowing Z Lomax and W Kennedy to I Yeo and H Tabuai-Fidow next week.

4. Out: C Hess, R Paperhuyzen, In: C McInnes and L Mitchell
$72,400 remaining salary to be used for W Kennedy to H Tabuai-Fidow thus allowing E Marsters to L Mitchell/I Yeo.

5. Out: T Rudolf, E Marsters, In: A Fonua-Blake and L Mitchell
$7000 remaining salary to be used for Z Lomax to H Tabuai-Fidow and hopefuly W Kennedy/S Drinkwater to E Yeo/N Cleary
Teddy is probably a must. I'd much rather trade Marsters instead of Lonax in trade one. Another move could be selling Jai Arrow to a POD like TPJ from the Broncs or Liam Martin who passed the eye test.
 

Connoisseur

Leadership Group
Joined
3 Jul 2017
Messages
38,960
Likes
126,628
AFL Club
Port Adelaide
Teddy is probably a must. I'd much rather trade Marsters instead of Lonax in trade one. Another move could be selling Jai Arrow to a POD like TPJ from the Broncs or Liam Martin who passed the eye test.
If I was to trade Arrow it would be to Matterson/McInnes and would prefer to trade Hess and Leiliua before Arrow. As for trading Lomax in Option 1 I have sufficient cash to trade Kennedy instead.
 
Joined
29 Nov 2019
Messages
5,623
Likes
20,191
AFL Club
Brisbane
Can you just get a nuff, Musgrove or HTF instead?
? I've got Musgrove, and HTF is on the cards for next week. The reason being Tino played a great game last week, 2ppm, he's set for a good price rise with a negative BE. Fidows rise comes after next round.
 
Joined
29 Nov 2019
Messages
5,623
Likes
20,191
AFL Club
Brisbane
Score: 993
Rd Rank: 64416
Overall Rank: 30435 (from 18956)

Current side before trades:
View attachment 17832


Trade options involve:
1. Out: R Papenhuyzen, Z Lomax, In: J Tedesco, H Tabuai- Fidow
$235,700 remaining salary allowing W Kennedy to E Yeo next week.

2. Out: Z Lomax, E Marsters, In: B Morris and L Mitchell
$60,900 remaining salary hopefully allowing S Drinkwater and Kennedy to N Cleary and H Tabuai-Fidow next week.

3. Out: E Marsters, L Leilau, In: L Mitchell and C McInnes
$100 short of trading Hess instead of Leilau.
$40,600 remaining salary allowing Z Lomax and W Kennedy to I Yeo and H Tabuai-Fidow next week.

4. Out: C Hess, R Paperhuyzen, In: C McInnes and L Mitchell
$72,400 remaining salary to be used for W Kennedy to H Tabuai-Fidow thus allowing E Marsters to L Mitchell/I Yeo.

5. Out: T Rudolf, E Marsters, In: A Fonua-Blake and L Mitchell
$7000 remaining salary to be used for Z Lomax to H Tabuai-Fidow and hopefuly W Kennedy/S Drinkwater to E Yeo/N Cleary
I also think Teddy is a must. And although people say Marsters may come right, it seems he's just not getting any ball. Lomax isnt getting much either, but I like him, he chases the ball everywhere on his half of the field, and he's going to get better at those jumps. I've kept Lomax and moved Marsters out.
 
Joined
11 Dec 2019
Messages
2,190
Likes
10,258
AFL Club
Gold Coast
Score: 993
Rd Rank: 64416
Overall Rank: 30435 (from 18956)

Current side before trades:
View attachment 17832


Trade options involve:
1. Out: R Papenhuyzen, Z Lomax, In: J Tedesco, H Tabuai- Fidow
$235,700 remaining salary allowing W Kennedy to E Yeo next week.

2. Out: Z Lomax, E Marsters, In: B Morris and L Mitchell
$60,900 remaining salary hopefully allowing S Drinkwater and Kennedy to N Cleary and H Tabuai-Fidow next week.

3. Out: E Marsters, L Leilau, In: L Mitchell and C McInnes
$100 short of trading Hess instead of Leilau.
$40,600 remaining salary allowing Z Lomax and W Kennedy to I Yeo and H Tabuai-Fidow next week.

4. Out: C Hess, R Paperhuyzen, In: C McInnes and L Mitchell
$72,400 remaining salary to be used for W Kennedy to H Tabuai-Fidow thus allowing E Marsters to L Mitchell/I Yeo.

5. Out: T Rudolf, E Marsters, In: A Fonua-Blake and L Mitchell
$7000 remaining salary to be used for Z Lomax to H Tabuai-Fidow and hopefuly W Kennedy/S Drinkwater to E Yeo/N Cleary
You have almost given yourself too much depth to the detriment of your starting 17. A few of these options are trading in players who may not be in the top few of their position, which is where you need to be targeting.

My recommendation would be:

Papenhuyzen to Tedesco. Marsters to Averillo. Your ctw is strong enough for this week. Next week Target HTF and Haas/Mciness/Yeo. Hopefully the cash bank should be enough to get two guns the following week - Collins, JTB, Hess, Lucy on the chopping block.
 

Connoisseur

Leadership Group
Joined
3 Jul 2017
Messages
38,960
Likes
126,628
AFL Club
Port Adelaide
Teddy is probably a must. I'd much rather trade Marsters instead of Lonax in trade one. Another move could be selling Jai Arrow to a POD like TPJ from the Broncs or Liam Martin who passed the eye test.
Any concerns about Tedesco’s upcoming fixture or would you regard him as matchup proof?
 
Joined
24 Feb 2020
Messages
4,897
Likes
13,335
AFL Club
Collingwood
Mi
Score: 993
Rd Rank: 64416
Overall Rank: 30435 (from 18956)

Current side before trades:
View attachment 17832


Trade options involve:
1. Out: R Papenhuyzen, Z Lomax, In: J Tedesco, H Tabuai- Fidow
$235,700 remaining salary allowing W Kennedy to E Yeo next week.

2. Out: Z Lomax, E Marsters, In: B Morris and L Mitchell
$60,900 remaining salary hopefully allowing S Drinkwater and Kennedy to N Cleary and H Tabuai-Fidow next week.

3. Out: E Marsters, L Leilau, In: L Mitchell and C McInnes
$100 short of trading Hess instead of Leilau.
$40,600 remaining salary allowing Z Lomax and W Kennedy to I Yeo and H Tabuai-Fidow next week.

4. Out: C Hess, R Paperhuyzen, In: C McInnes and L Mitchell
$72,400 remaining salary to be used for W Kennedy to H Tabuai-Fidow thus allowing E Marsters to L Mitchell/I Yeo.

5. Out: T Rudolf, E Marsters, In: A Fonua-Blake and L Mitchell
$7000 remaining salary to be used for Z Lomax to H Tabuai-Fidow and hopefuly W Kennedy/S Drinkwater to E Yeo/N Cleary
mitchell base is real low, reckon he is a trap. Agreed masters need to be moved. I got him but cannot move him on until next week. Have bought in cririghton this week for Lucy and cline for drink water.
 
Joined
24 Feb 2020
Messages
4,897
Likes
13,335
AFL Club
Collingwood
I also think Teddy is a must. And although people say Marsters may come right, it seems he's just not getting any ball. Lomax isnt getting much either, but I like him, he chases the ball everywhere on his half of the field, and he's going to get better at those jumps. I've kept Lomax and moved Marsters out.
Biggest mistake this year taking maarster over Yeo. Arhhhhh.
 

Connoisseur

Leadership Group
Joined
3 Jul 2017
Messages
38,960
Likes
126,628
AFL Club
Port Adelaide
You have almost given yourself too much depth to the detriment of your starting 17. A few of these options are trading in players who may not be in the top few of their position, which is where you need to be targeting.

My recommendation would be:

Papenhuyzen to Tedesco. Marsters to Averillo. Your ctw is strong enough for this week. Next week Target HTF and Haas/Mciness/Yeo. Hopefully the cash bank should be enough to get two guns the following week - Collins, JTB, Hess, Lucy on the chopping block.
Thanks. Using your recommendation for this week, I can then trade Drinkwater to HTF via Averillo and then Leiliua/Hess to McInnes next week. After that Collins/JFB can be traded to P Haas or vice versa (Haas then McInnes).
 
Joined
11 Dec 2019
Messages
2,190
Likes
10,258
AFL Club
Gold Coast
Thanks. Using your recommendation for this week, I can then trade Drinkwater to HTF via Averillo and then Leiliua/Hess to McInnes next week. After that Collins/JFB can be traded to P Haas or vice versa (Haas then McInnes).
Outstanding trades and should set you up well. But I’ll be praying Teddy doesn’t kill me (Turbo/Ponga owner).
 

Connoisseur

Leadership Group
Joined
3 Jul 2017
Messages
38,960
Likes
126,628
AFL Club
Port Adelaide
Outstanding trades and should set you up well. But I’ll be praying Teddy doesn’t kill me (Turbo/Ponga owner).
Thanks.

Will likely move D Brown to the bench pushing G Williams onfield this round and moving the R to C Hess/E Katoa. After all of the aforementioned trades and a CTW upgrade, Cleary will likely replace Brown via the downgrade of Averillo to a HFB/5/8 loop allowing G Williams to fill in for N Cleary and S Johnson during the latter half of the season.

Great selection of Turbo and Ponga. I’ve missed out on both their large scores- Grabbed Turbo the week after his 150+ and traded Ponga to Drinkwater for cash generation during his suspension, only for him to return with a massive score.
 

Connoisseur

Leadership Group
Joined
3 Jul 2017
Messages
38,960
Likes
126,628
AFL Club
Port Adelaide
Hey, I benefited from him last week, if everyone wants to jump on and he struggles for a week I haven't missed out!
Touche. Better directed to those considering him or have brought him in this round.

I expect Ponga to double Teddy‘s score and McInnes and Mitchell to register 100+ now.
 
Joined
29 Nov 2019
Messages
5,623
Likes
20,191
AFL Club
Brisbane
I've been thinking about my Tino trade, most are jumping on HTF now. What do you guys think?

Tino is looking at a $47k price rise after this round. HTF will rise next week. So was thinking of getting HTF next week and benefit from both those trades points & value wise. However taking note of what's been said about taking nu***, I'm now thinking HTF this week, and probably NOT bringing in Tino at all (I think Tino is brilliant and will make plenty this season), but bring in Sharks Hiroti next week + a keeper. So

1) This week: Tino, next week HTF, or
2) This week: HTF, next week Hiroti/nuff

TIA
 
Joined
16 Dec 2018
Messages
1,356
Likes
3,746
AFL Club
GWS Giants
I've been thinking about my Tino trade, most are jumping on HTF now. What do you guys think?

Tino is looking at a $47k price rise after this round. HTF will rise next week. So was thinking of getting HTF next week and benefit from both those trades points & value wise. However taking note of what's been said about taking nu***, I'm now thinking HTF this week, and probably NOT bringing in Tino at all (I think Tino is brilliant and will make plenty this season), but bring in Sharks Hiroti next week + a keeper. So

1) This week: Tino, next week HTF, or
2) This week: HTF, next week Hiroti/nuff

TIA
What about getting Coates next week?
 
Top