The biggest difference with the Geelong v Adelaide cancellation is that we knew beforehand how SC would handle the issue and could make decisions based around that. The fact that we are well in to the current round throws up the issue of what do do. Obviously everyone who has Whitfield would want best 18, but is that fair to those without him? While it's bad luck for Whitfield owners we have all had players go down early in a game and have had to wear it. Can't please everyone in this situation. I still think they may hold off until a decision is made of when Ess v Melb game can go ahead.