Strategy Round 5: Trades

[Connoisseur]

Hey Con, when you see this (not urgent is not for tonights lockout) do you have stats on Darcy Moore when Howe is out?

https://twitter.com/i/web/status/1278567587933085696

2019 Howe missed RD15-RD17-
D Moore:

 

[Juzzo]

Fyfe to McCluggage
Noble to Ridley

oh wow - these are some desperate trades, hey? Trigger pulled!!!

Good luck, go Team 5!

 

[Kidult]

Hmm might just grab Hill+Young/Williamson and still look to upgrade next week.

 

[The Experiment]

Stewart to Williamson for me tonight

now to sit back and digest the carnage

 

[blue dreamer]

https://twitter.com/i/web/status/1278567587933085696

2019 Howe missed RD15-RD17-
D Moore:
View attachment 18426 View attachment 18423
View attachment 18425
View attachment 18424

Thanks for the speed Con, I like it with the exception of the obviously injury affected round 17.

 

[The Myth]

Was going to save my second trade.

But after carnage: Noble to Hill.

 

[Schods25]

I like the idea of a thread for trade history every 5 rounds, be interesting to see people's good and bad moves over the course of a season.

My history to date:
RD 2:
King > Bennell o
T.Green > Simpkin +
Roberton > SPS +
Brayshaw > Bewley +

RD 3:
MacPherson > Pittonet +
English > Howe - (injury affected)

RD 4:
Houston > Haynes +
Pickett > Rivers o

RD 5: To be determined...

Edit: key: + (win), o (neutral) or - (loss)

RD 2:
Brayshaw to Vandermeer
Roberton to Howe
Zerk-Thatcher to Noble
T.Green to McHenry

RD 3:
B.Smith to Stewart
Cavarra to Sturt

RD 4:
Sturt to Rivers

RD 5
Howe to Daniel
Stewart to Crisp

Side is
DEF: Docherty, Daniel, Crisp, Sicily, Starcevich, Rivers (Noble, BJ Williams)
MID: Neale, Cripps, Mitchell, Oliver, Coniglio, Rowell, Brown, McInerney (Pickett, Vandermeer, McHenry)
RUC: Grundy, Gawn (Conroy)
FWD: Greenwood, Whitfield, Dev Smith, Taylor, Budarick, King (Brander, Davis)

Noble and Brander 1 up, 1 down next week hopefully

 

[blue dreamer]

https://twitter.com/i/web/status/1278567587933085696

2019 Howe missed RD15-RD17-
D Moore:
View attachment 18426 View attachment 18423
View attachment 18425
View attachment 18424

Thanks for the speed Con, I like it with the exception of the obviously injury affected round 17.

I note that they were his only two tons also, may be worth a sneaky look and has a low BE this week.

 

[blue dreamer]

Ryder to Hayden locked in, second trade waiting for tomorrows final team drops but need to make sure I keep enough cash to get Whitfield next week.

 

[PlaymakerX]

Damn the SC gods are really testing us this week!

Need a Howe replacement ASAP. Already have Lloyd and Docherty.

Skipping on:
• Maynard
• Daniel
• Laird

Tossing up between:
• Sicily
• Ridley
• Haynes
• Hill

Thoughts?

 

[Tamuhawk]

So much carnage

Option 1: Double down & Hold Fyfe
OUT: Naismith & Noble
IN: Williamson & Hill

Option 2: 1 up & 1 down & Hold Fyfe
OUT: Naismith & Noble
IN: Ridley & Hill

Option 3: Trade Fyfe and go for broke
OUT: Fyfe & Naismith
IN: Sicily & Ridley

 

[PlaymakerX]

So much carnage

Option 1: Double down & Hold Fyfe
OUT: Naismith & Noble
IN: Williamson & Hill

Option 2: 1 up & 1 down & Hold Fyfe
OUT: Naismith & Noble
IN: Ridley & Hill

Option 3: Trade Fyfe and go for broke
OUT: Fyfe & Naismith
IN: Sicily & Ridley

Option 2

 

[Kidult]

So much carnage

Option 1: Double down & Hold Fyfe
OUT: Naismith & Noble
IN: Williamson & Hill

Option 2: 1 up & 1 down & Hold Fyfe
OUT: Naismith & Noble
IN: Ridley & Hill

Option 3: Trade Fyfe and go for broke
OUT: Fyfe & Naismith
IN: Sicily & Ridley

Go for option 3 and get points on the board.

 

[The Experiment]

So much carnage

Option 1: Double down & Hold Fyfe
OUT: Naismith & Noble
IN: Williamson & Hill

Option 2: 1 up & 1 down & Hold Fyfe
OUT: Naismith & Noble
IN: Ridley & Hill

Option 3: Trade Fyfe and go for broke
OUT: Fyfe & Naismith
IN: Sicily & Ridley

I personally like option 1 mate

I am a Ridley owner, however I feel he has been outperforming and possibly wont keep it up.

Williamson and Hill look like two solid best 22 rookies (injury concerns aside) so would grab them now

 

[Mr_Arrogance]

So much carnage

Option 1: Double down & Hold Fyfe
OUT: Naismith & Noble
IN: Williamson & Hill

Option 2: 1 up & 1 down & Hold Fyfe
OUT: Naismith & Noble
IN: Ridley & Hill

Option 3: Trade Fyfe and go for broke
OUT: Fyfe & Naismith
IN: Sicily & Ridley

If you were going to do option 3 and go for broke I would like to see Fyfe traded for an A grade 110+ player, so with your planned players I vote for option 2 although I'm not a big Ridley fan at his current price

 

[IDIG]

So much carnage

Option 1: Double down & Hold Fyfe
OUT: Naismith & Noble
IN: Williamson & Hill

Option 2: 1 up & 1 down & Hold Fyfe
OUT: Naismith & Noble
IN: Ridley & Hill

Option 3: Trade Fyfe and go for broke
OUT: Fyfe & Naismith
IN: Sicily & Ridley

Very close to doing option 1 myself but will most likely do something similar to option 3 instead. My team is cooked so gonna YOLO it and hope for the best.

 

[The Experiment]

Very close to doing option 1 myself but will most likely do something similar to option 3 instead. My team is cooked so gonna YOLO it and hope for the best.

I was under the impression this was your standard trading MO

 

[Leroy]

Hmm how was that team drop huh?

If Rivers, Pickett and Sturt are named I could escape this week without a donut. Otherwise I've got one trade to avoid potentially 3

Guess Fyfe is going to stay then

 

[BomberSam]

Pitto

 

[IDIG]

I was under the impression this was your standard trading MO

Fair call. Rarely works but that won’t stop me