News Herald Sun SuperCoach Articles

Joined
1 Feb 2014
Messages
1,995
Likes
6,950
AFL Club
Hawthorn
AFL KFC SuperCoach: Which draftees could be rolled gold in 2021?

Which young guns have already made an impact at their new clubs? See how the top picks are tracking and if they are in the mix for Round 1.

Jordan Pinto and Dan Batten

December 28, 2020 - 8:47AM

News Corp Australia Sports Newsroom

With the national draft over and the next generation of AFL stars welcomed by their new clubs, it no longer matters what pick they were taken, it is all about what they do next.

For some, next will be right away, while others will need to bide their time.

From first-round picks to rookie draft gold, DAN BATTEN and JORDAN PINTO look at the players most-likely to have an immediate impact at your club and in KFC SuperCoach in 2021.

ADELAIDE

JAMES ROWE

SC price: $117,300 Fwd

SC Average (SANFL 2020): 96

R1 likelihood: Very likely

After booting 35 goals in 2019, Rowe booted 38 majors in the minor rounds this year to win the Ken Farmer Medal as the SANFL’s leading goalkicker – the first 18 coming without a miss. There’s, arguably, no player from the 2020 draft class more ready for the AFL than Rowe, who boasts uncanny goal sense and elite footy IQ. And it looks like he will be needed, too, after Tyson Stengle’s last off-field incident.

SC verdict: A KFC SuperCoach lock. Rowe averaged 96 points per game as a small-forward in the SANFL and is close to basement price.

RILEY THILTHORPE

SC price: $202,800 Fwd/Ruck

SC Average (SANFL 2020): 96

R1 likelihood: 50/50

The Crows will want to put their highest-ever pick on show in 2021 and, after having a big impact at senior level over the past two years, Thilthorpe is ready. His hands are terrific in the air and even better on the ground and his ability to ruck as an extra midfielder makes him, almost immediately, Reilly O’Brien’s No. 2. If he can prove his groin problem is no longer an issue, the big pre-season question could become which tall-forward makes way?

SC verdict: Given the starting price, he might not be making money as quickly as some of the other KFC SuperCoach cash cows – especially in the role.

SAM BERRY

SC price: $117,300 Mid

SC Average (NAB League): 104

R1 likelihood: 50/50

As a bottom-ager in the NAB League in 2019, Berry showcased his strength at the contest and his willingness to tackle – and do it hard. The 181cm midfielder, who had 18 tackles and 17 contested possessions against Geelong in his fourth game for the year, also has great hands and elite endurance. If a spot opens up in the midfield, look for Berry to have an instant impact.

SC verdict: Berry finished with 220 KFC SuperCoach points on that day against the Falcons and is one to keep an eye on.

LUKE PEDLAR

SC price: $162,300 Mid

SC Average (SANFL U18): 128

R1 likelihood: 50/50

Given the rebuilding nature of Adelaide’s list, every player drafted is a chance to see senior action in 2021. Pedlar is a tough, contested bull who breaks tackles but he’s also clever around goal and boasts a penetrating left-foot and would immediately add to the Crows’ midfield mix.

SC verdict: Another Crow with a KFC SuperCoach-friendly game, Pedlar posted scores of 155, 71, 140 and 148 in his only four SANFL under-18 games in 2020.

BRISBANE LIONS

BLAKE COLEMAN

SC price: $117,300

SC average: 66 (NAB League, 2019)

Round 1 likelihood: Unlikely

It will tough for any draftee to walk into a side brimming with young talent on every line but Coleman has some tricks that may see him called upon at some stage in his debut season. A similar player to his brother, Brisbane forward Keidean, who broke in for four matches in his first year in 2020, Coleman’s speed and goalkicking nous can add something to the Lions’ forward mix.

SC verdict: While Keidean managed to average 62 KFC SuperCoach points from four matches, buying young small forwards always comes with an element of risk.

CARLTON

COREY DURDIN

SC price: $117,300 Mid/Fwd

SC Average (SANFL 2020): 55

R1 likelihood: 50/50

With the addition of Zac Williams and Adam Saad, Carlton’s best-22 looks pretty solid for next season. But if spot does open up, the speedy small forward who made his SANFL league debut at 17 is more than ready. Durdin, who won the Kevin Sheehan Medal as the best player at the under-16 national carnival in 2018, is clever, know where the goals are and has plenty of class.

SC verdict: The 55-point of average in the SANFL this year is misleading given his final two injury-affected scores of 20 and four. There’s a bit of Caleb Daniel and Dayne Zorko in the way he plays – and maybe his future KFC SuperCoach scoring too.

LUKE PARKS

SC price: $117,400 Def

SC Average (SANFL 2020): 73

R1 likelihood: Unlikely

The 19-year-old, who played six games for the Swans’ NEAFL team in 2019, is strong defensively, competitive and is outstanding in the air – all traits which will appeal to David Teague. But the Blues look pretty well balanced in defence for next season so, while he’s physically ready, the 189cm Parks may have to bide his time.

SC verdict: Might not be at the front of the queue at Carlton but every mature-age draftee is an automatic addition to the pre-season watch list.
 
Joined
1 Feb 2014
Messages
1,995
Likes
6,950
AFL Club
Hawthorn
COLLINGWOOD

FINLAY MACRAE

SC price: $126,300, MID, FWD

SC average: 83 (NAB League, 2019)

Round 1 likelihood: 50/50

Macrae has shades of his half-brother, Western Bulldoogs star Jack with his composure and consistency. His ball-use and versatility mean he can play just about anywhere, and this will work in his favour as he pushes for a debut in 2021.

SC verdict: Macrae and KFC SuperCoach go together like bacon and eggs. Expect him to follow a similar trajectory to his older brother in his first few seasons. For those playing along at home, Jack averaged 61.4 from 13 matches in his maiden season.

OLIVER HENRY

SC price: $135,300, FWD

SC average: 67 (NAB League, 2019)

Round 1 likelihood: Unlikely

Renowned for his marking prowess, Henry’s strength is Collingwood’s major weakness up forward. The 188-centimetre high-flyer, who is the brother of Geelong defender Jack Henry, can add something special to an at times uninspiring forward make-up, which lost Jaidyn Stephenson during the trade period. In saying that, an immediately call-up would be a tough ask.

SC verdict: A similar player to North Melbourne’s Curtis Taylor, Henry is likely to be an inconsistent scorer if he does break in at senior level. But we will take any playing forward rookie we can get.

REEF McINNES

SC price: $117,300, MID

SC average: 84 (NAB League, 2019)

Round 1 likelihood: 50/50

McInnes is an exciting and versatile talent with plenty of scope for improvement. Standing 193cm, McInnes can play up forward or as a lockdown defender but his best position is as a quick inside midfielder. His array of weapons and ability to play anywhere should earn him an AFL promotion at some point in 2021.

SC verdict: Posted scores of 122, 132 and 159 across a three-game stretch as an inside midfielder as a bottom-ager. A name we are going to get familiar with in SuperCoach circles.

CALEB POULTER

SC price: $117,300, MID/FWD

SC average: 130 (SANFL U18s, 2020)

Round 1 likelihood: Unlikely

The Magpies swooped on Poulter after their live trade on draft night with Greater Western Sydney and he looms as a player who could break in next year. Standing 192 centimetres, Poulter is damaging forward of centre with his booming left boot and contested ballwinning, averaging 25.2 disposals, 10.6 contested possessions and 0.8 goals from 12 matches at SANFL U18 level.

SC verdict: May not play right away but is one to put on your watch-list at that price with DPP considering he averaged a formidable 130 points in the SANFL U18s.

BEAU McCREERY

SC price: $117,300, FWD

SC average: 72 (SANFL, 2020)

Round 1 likelihood: 50/50

McCreery, a 186cm pressure forward with good goal sense, was among a host of SANFL mature-agers taken on draft night. The 19-year-old averaged 10.2 disposals, 3.9 tackles and booted 19 goals across 15 games for South Adelaide this season and will be another pressing his claim for a Round 1 berth at the Magpies.

SC verdict: Had mixed KFC SuperCoach returns this year, passing 90 points on five occasions but posting another five sub-50 scores. Likely to be more of a role player in his first season.

ESSENDON

NIK COX

SC price: $175,800 Def-Fwd

SC Average (NAB League 2019): 75

R1 likelihood: 50/50

The Bombers’ top-pick may be slightly built – and not yet ready to hold down the key-position he’s been earmarked for – but his skill, versatility and running ability for a 202cm big man will have him in the mix for senior action in 2021.

SC verdict: Despite his early-season chances, Cox is unlikely to be a big KFC SuperCoach scorer in his first year.

ARCHIE PERKINS

SC price: $171,300 Mid-Fwd

SC Average (NAB League 2019): 82

R1 likelihood: 50/50

In time, the explosive Perkins is likely to become Essendon’s most dynamic – and most-damaging – midfielders. But the 188cm Perkins can have an impact forward of centre and it’s this ability, along with his athleticism and aerial power, which could add another layer to Ben Rutten’s side from the get go.

SC verdict: It may not be this year at the price – or in the role – but Perkins is a likely KFC SuperCoach favourite of the future.

FREMANTLE

HEATH CHAPMAN

SC price: $148,800, DEF

SC average: 132 (WAFL Colts, 2019)

Round 1 likelihood: Unlikely

Fremantle are well stocked for key position defenders with Alex Pearce and Joel Hamling set to return but Chapman has the talent and attacking flare that could see him get a look-in. The intercept defender, who will likely start his career as a third tall, dominated in the WAFL Colts for West Perth tallying 22.4 touches, 10.6 intercept possessions and 4.6 intercept marks across eight matches. He also proved he could mix it with senior bodies in his a WAFL seniors call-up this year.

SC verdict: Keep an eye on him for future seasons but he is unlikely to get consistent opportunities in 2021 with Fremantle’s bevy of tall defenders.

NATHAN O’DRISCOLL

SC price: $117,300, MID

SC average: 132 (WAFL Colts, 2019)

Round 1 likelihood: Unlikely

O’Driscoll is a taller midfield option who has shown his wares at WAFL level, elevated for five games in 2020. While the Dockers have a difficult midfield to break into, O’Driscoll’s high level speed and endurance mix along with his frame may see him given an opportunity next year.

SC verdict: Job security is the prime concern here as he should be a solid scorer if he gets a run, highlighted by his 101 points outing in a WAFL senior game for Perth in 2020.

JOSH TREACY

SC price: $102,400, RUCK/FWD

SC average: 90 (NAB League, 2019)

Round 1 likelihood: Unlikely

A hardworking key forward from the Bendigo Pioneers, Treacy was rewarded for his dedication to the cause throughout the NAB League shutdown by becoming a Docker through the rookie draft. Already an imposing figure at 194cm and 94kg, Treacy is a competitive beast by nature and covers the ground well, suggesting he could be a player to cover the loss of Jesse Hogan sooner than first thought.

SC verdict: KFC SuperCoaches will be hoping Treacy stays in the reserves as the cheapest RUCK/FWD loophole option available. He might just break coaches’ hearts in 2021.
 
Joined
1 Feb 2014
Messages
1,995
Likes
6,950
AFL Club
Hawthorn
GEELONG

NICK STEVENS

SC price: $117,300 Def

SC Average (NAB League 2019): 72

R1 likelihood: Unlikely

Despite their willingness to throw the kids straight in recently, the Cats going with an athletic midfielder, who hasn’t played a lot of footy in the past two years, and a ruckman for the future, means Stevens appears the draftee most likely to see senior action in 2021. He’s shown some real dash and class off halfback and makes great decisions by foot and, at 191cm, can play a variety of roles.

SC verdict: His junior KFC SuperCoach numbers don’t scream pick me, but Stevens has some nice attributes.

GOLD COAST

ELIJAH HOLLANDS

SC price: $180,300, MID/FWD

SC average: 78 (U18 Championships, 2019)

Round 1 likelihood: Nil

Hollands is set to sit out the first half of the season as he recovers from a serious knee injury but when he is ready to go, look out. One of the steals of the draft after sliding to Gold Coast’s selection at number seven, Hollands possesses game-breaking impact that few in the 2020 draft crop have, which should see him enter the selection frame once he builds up match fitness.

SC verdict: May just be the Caleb Serong of 2021 – from a cash generation perspective – when he enters the Suns line-up.

ALEX DAVIES

SC price: $102,400, MID

SC average: 55 (NEAFL, 2019)

Round 1 likelihood: 50/50

The Suns’ draft concessions handed them the academy product on a platter and Davies has the tools to make in impact in 2021. Davies, a 192cm clearance specialist who does his best work in traffic, was promoted to Gold Coast’s NEAFL side as a bottom-ager, playing seven matches. The only thing holding him back is injury, sitting out the second half of the 2020 season with an elbow blow.

SC verdict: A steal for the Suns but he may be an even bigger steal for KFC SuperCoaches at $102,400. The Suns’ midfield is jam-packed but Davies offers something different to their current make-up.

GREATER WESTERN SYDNEY

JACOB WEHR

SC price: $117,300 Def

SC Average (SANFL 2020): 75

R1 likelihood: Likely

The 22-year-old is a line breaker who makes great decisions and, more importantly, executes them, hitting the long target as often as he finds the short one, making him the ideal candidate to help fill the void left by Zac Williams.

SC verdict: A mature-ager who posted KFC SuperCoach scores of 96, 96 and 87 in the SANFL final series? Yes, please.

HAWTHORN

DENVER GRAINGER-BARRAS

SC price: $184,800, DEF

SC average: 75 (WAFL, 2020)

Round 1 likelihood: Very likely

Hawthorn’s shift towards youth indicates that Grainger-Barras is going to be playing a lot of senior footy in 2021. The intercept king enjoyed a full season at WAFL level for Swan Districts and thrived, averaging 10.3 disposals, 7.4 intercept possessions, 3.0 intercept marks and five spoils up against hardened opposition. Expect the key defender to be wearing a Hawthorn guernsey in Round 1.

SC verdict: A touch expensive but is the standout rookie defender at this stage. An average of 75 points in the WAFL bodes well for his scoring potential at AFL level.

SEAMUS MITCHELL

SC price: $117,300, FWD

SC average: 63 (NAB League, 2019)

Round 1 likelihood: Unlikely

Despite being somewhat of a bolter on draft night, Mitchell is viewed as a prospect who can play all over the ground thanks to his blistering speed. He is capable of earning an AFL call-up next year as a small forward, particularly at Hawthorn who will be playing the kids as much as possible.

SC verdict: Will provide excitement if he gets out on the park but is unlikely to be a solid scorer.

CONNOR DOWNIE

SC price: $117,300, MID

SC average: 82 (NAB League, 2019)

Round 1 likelihood: Likely

It will be a matter of when, not if, Downie debus in 2021. A running halfback/wingman with a penetrating kick and a ready-made frame, Downie is as dedicated as they come and will fit into an AFL environment seamlessly. After losing Isaac Smith during the trade period, a shuffling of the decks could see exciting youngster Will Day move up to the wing and Downie replace him across halfback.

SC verdict: Cheap, ready-made and part of a rebuilding side. Chuck him on your midfield bench for now.

MELBOURNE

BAILEY LAURIE

SC price: $117,300 Def/Fwd

SC Average (NAB League): 90

R1 likelihood: 50/50

The Dees need more speed and skill forward-of-centre, and Laurie brings both in spades. He has an outstanding footy IQ and can set up play from the midfield or put the finishing touches on inside-50 himself with equal effect.

SC verdict: Laurie starred in last year’s NAB League grand final, finishing with 17 disposals, two goals and 121 KFC SuperCoach points. He’s a player that doesn’t need a lot of the ball to score well and the dual-position status is a bonus.

JAKE BOWEY

SC price: $117,300 Mid/Fwd

SC Average (NAB League): 79

R1 likelihood: Unlikely

Every team would love Caleb Daniel’s poise and elite foot skills – but especially Melbourne. And that’s why Bowey, a 175cm midfielder from Sandringham, who is one of the best kicks of the 2020 draft class – and has drawn some comparison to Daniel – could feature at senior level in his debut season.

SC verdict: Some big games and some poor ones – numbers wise, anyway – in his bottom-age year in the NAB League. He’s another rookie-price player with dual-position status, but his scores may be inconsistent if he gets a chance.
 
Joined
1 Feb 2014
Messages
1,995
Likes
6,950
AFL Club
Hawthorn
NORTH MELBOURNE

WILL PHILLIPS

SC price: $198,300, MID

SC average: 103 (NAB League, 2019)

Round 1 likelihood: Very likely

The 2020 draftee set to make the most immediate impact next year. Phillips is an ultra-consistent ball winner who averaged 22.1 disposals and 4.3 clearances for the Oakleigh Chargers alongside handy midfielders Matt Rowell and Noah Anderson at NAB league level in 2019. Don’t be surprised if the No. 3 draft pick starts at North Melbourne’s first centre-bounce next year.

SC verdict: We would have preferred if he drafted a touch later to bring his price down, but he will be given ample midfield opportunity at the struggling Roos and his job security is off the charts. Lock.

TOM POWELL

SC price: $153,300, MID

SC average: 154 (NAB League, 2019)

Round 1 likelihood: Very likely

Powell got leather poisoning this year, averaging a whopping 33.5 disposals, 14.6 contested possessions, 8.0 clearances and 3.6 tackles for Sturt in the SANFL U18s. While he did not play SANFL reserves or senior in 2020, there is no doubting his ball-winning capabilities, able to consistently win contested ball and make good decisions with ball in hand.

SC verdict: 154 KFC SuperCoach points per game, including two double tons, is absurd. Sign me up.

CONNOR MENADUE

SC price: $201,500, DEF

SC average: 62.5 (AFL, 2019)

Round 1 likelihood: Likely

Menadue was the big surprise of the rookie draft after the former Tiger was plucked from VFL club Werribee despite failing to take the field in 2020. The 24-year-old, who was delisted by Richmond at the end of the 2019 season, appears likely to have a more prominent role at his second club with less competition for spots.

SC verdict: The price is off-putting but he should surpass the 62.5 average he mustered from six games in 2019 and has 39 games of AFL experience under his belt. Remember, Brandon Zerk-Thatcher was considered a must-have in defence at $190,000 last year. He is one to keep in mind if cheaper rookie defenders don’t present themselves.

PORT ADELAIDE

LACHLAN JONES

SC price: $139,800 Def

SC Average (SANFL 2020): 65

R1 likelihood: Likely

Of all the teenagers drafted this year, Jones is the most Round 1-ready. The 184cm, 87kg ready-made defender, starred at SANFL League level this year, taking mark of the year and knocking around some of his more senior opponents. He’s quick, powerful and can play on talls or smalls and is a chance to force his way into a strong Port Adelaide best-22 right away.

SC verdict: A KFC SuperCoach lock if picked. Jones played 16 senior games this year and posted KFC SuperCoach scores of 107, 81 and 92 in the Eagles’ run to the flag in the major round. Oh, and he averaged 141 points per game in his final eight under-18 games in his bottom-age year of 2019.

RICHMOND

It would be difficult for any first-year player to break into the reigning premiers’ stacked line-up, and both of Richmond’s draft prospects loom as long-term propositions.

Tiger fans will be keeping a keen eye on father-son draftee Maurice Rioli Jnr while he has some X-Factor, he may require a pre-season or two before he is ready to step in at AFL level.

ST KILDA

TOM HIGHMORE

SC price: $117,300 Def

SC Average (SANFL 2020): 88

R1 likelihood: 50/50

The 22-year-old was the No. 1 ranked player in the SANFL for intercept marks in 2020 and kicked the footy at 83 per cent efficiency. Highmore, who starred at NEAFL level in 2019, has all the tools to follow a similar path to new teammate Callum Wilkie.

SC verdict: But Highmore could be an even better KFC SuperCoach scorer after going 112, 76, 103, 163, 108 and 146 in the opening six rounds before injury.

SYDNEY

LOGAN McDONALD

SC price: $193,800, FWD

SC average: 97 (WAFL, 2019)

Round 1 likelihood: Very likely

No draftee had a better 2020 campaign than McDonald, taking the WAFL by storm by booting 21 goals from nine matches, rewarded with a spot in the WAFL team of the year. McDonald is expected to accompany superstar Lance Franklin and potentially Sam Reid in Sydney’s forward arc as a third tall, the position he played for Perth. His standout performances at WAFL level will serve him well and extensive opportunities await him in 2021.

SC verdict: He recorded a promising 97-point average in the WAFL but things will be much tougher in the Swans forward line. Key forward rookies are never a good idea in KFC SuperCoach – no matter how talented they are.

BRAEDEN CAMPBELL

SC price: $189,300, MID/FWD

SC average: 123 (NAB League, 2019)

Round 1 likelihood: Likely

Campbell ability to impact games in the forward half will make him too irresistible for John Longmire to ignore. The Swans academy ace has a long and penetrating kick and electrifying speed, both of which be used through the middle and up forward. May leapfrog other young midfielders/forwards for a spot in the senior line-up in Round 1.

SC verdict: At that price you would want an indication that he will be getting reasonable midfield minutes, which is certainly a possibility. His high impact per possession play could make him an attractive option, registering 164 points from 22 touches in one NAB League as a bottom-ager.

ERROL GULDEN

SC price: $117,300, MID

SC average: 88 (NEAFL, 2019)

Round 1 likelihood: Unlikely

Another Swans Academy graduate, Gulden is a consistent performer who could enter selection calculations despite his small stature. The 175cm midfielder is a ball magnet with a good tank and even outshone Campbell during the Northern academy series this year against the Giants Academy.

SC verdict: An average of 88 points from three NEAFL games as a bottom-ager means he can’t be ignored. But will he get enough midfield time when he receives a call-up?

WEST COAST

Isiah Winder could find it hard to crack into the Eagles’ star-studded engine room. Picture: Paul Kane/Getty Images

ISIAH WINDER

SC price: $117,300 Def/Mid

SC Average (WAFL Colts): 137

R1 likelihood: Unlikely

The explosive midfielder-forward starred at Colts level this year, averaging 28 disposals through the midfield, before impressing against the bigger bodies in three senior matches. And, along with his x-factor, it’s why he’s the most-likely of the Eagles draftees to get a chance in 2021.

SC verdict: Some big numbers at Colts level, but he’s unlikely to play that pure midfield role early in his career.

WESTERN BULLDOGS

JAMARRA UGLE-HAGAN

SC price: $207,300, FWD

SC average: 84 (NAB League, 2019)

Round 1 likelihood: Unlikely

The number one pick will partner Bulldog talls Josh Bruce and Aaron Naughton next year in a forward line full of athleticism. Ugle-Hagan slotted 24 goals in nine games in a

remarkable bottom-age season for Oakleigh in 2019 and his blistering speed off the mark coupled with his phenomenal hands on the lead and in the air will trouble even the sturdiest AFL defenders.

SC verdict: The number one pick has been a worthy SuperCoach buy the past two seasons, but Ugle-Hagan isn’t a ball-winning midfielder – remember, even fully developed key forwards struggle to score well, let alone one who is 18. Best to enjoy his immense talent as a neutral observer for at least a couple of years before factoring him into your SC plans.
 
Joined
1 Feb 2014
Messages
1,995
Likes
6,950
AFL Club
Hawthorn
KFC SuperCoach AFL 2021 Rookie Bible: Early guide to top cheapies

Nailing your rookies is the key to success in KFC SuperCoach. Here’s the early mail on who to look at in 2021.

Al Paton



December 30, 2020 - 6:00AM

News Corp Australia Sports Newsroom



Fears of a KFC SuperCoach rookie shortage appear to be unfounded.

A few months out from Round 1, there is a healthy crop of cheapies to fill our benches and some on-field spots in our 2021 teams.

The unique nature of the 2020 season presents some new challenges for this year’s rookie class.

Some draftees have gone 12 months without playing any footy, and some would-be cheapies are a bit pricier than we would like after clubs trialled more players than they usually would in 2020 to cope with shorter turnarounds between games.

SUBSCRIBE TO SUPERCOACH PLUS TO ACCESS THE 2021 TEAM PICKER

For example, Hawthorn father-son pick Finn Maginness would have been on the radar as a bottom-priced cheapie this season after a year in the AFL system, but a debut in the second-last round has pushed his starting price out to $195,600.

But there are still some gold nuggets to be found, and a host of fresh faces ready to enter the system. And in some cases we might have to fork out a bit more of our salary cap to get the best cash cows.

Here’s our early pick of who to pick in your starting squad.

JAMES ROWE (ADEL) $117,300 FWD

Rowe was passed over in three successive drafts but the 21-year-old small forward made it impossible for recruiters to ignore him with 82 goals in the past two seasons for SANFL side Woodville-West Torrens, including five in this year’s preliminary final. When the Crows read out his name at pick 38, “we just exploded”, said his father — former Crow and radio host Stephen Rowe. Rowe Jr fills an obvious need at Adelaide and is ready to play straight away.

NAKIA COCKATOO (BRIS) $123,900 FWD/MID

The injury-cursed former Cat moves to Brisbane in the hope of rebooting his stalled AFL career. The exciting midfielder/forward hasn’t played since Round 3, 2018, but there is plenty of upside if Lions medicos an work their magic. The former No.10 draft pick scored 92 points in a game against Essendon in his second season on his way to a respectable rookie average of 63 for the year. That was back in 2016, but at his 2021 price and with DPP status we would happily take that next year.

TOM POWELL (NM) $153,300 MID

The phrase “ball magnet” gets thrown around a lot at draft time, but if ever there was a player who has earned it, it’s Powell. Likened to a young Tom Mitchell, the big-bodied midfielder averaged 33.5 disposals over two seasons in the SANFL under-18 comp and topped 200 KFC SuperCoach points twice, including an epic 47-disposal return against West Adelaide. Should thrive on silver service from Todd Goldstein.

WILL GOULD (SYD) $123,900 DEF

At times KFC SuperCoach players must have started wondering what Gould had done to get in John Longmire’s bad books. He was one of the most hyped rookies of the 2020 pre-season but failed to play a game all season despite the Swans rolling out a host of new faces. Remarkably, more than 43,000 KFC SuperCoach players still had Gould in their side at the end of the year. The good news is his price is still low for 2021, hopefully he can spent the summer shmoozing the coach.

LACHIE JONES (PA) $139,900 DEF

The Power’s top draft pick is 18 but looks 25 and could slot straight into the line-up of a top-four side after playing every game for Woodville-West Torrens at senior level last season, including picking up 18 disposals and five marks in the grand final. Likely to play across half-back, traditionally a good-scoring role in KFC SuperCoach.

WILL PHILLIPS (NM) $199,300 MID

The Roos thought enough of Phillips to bring Brent Harvey’s No.29 out of retirement — and dispatch the man himself to present it after the draft. Phillips was the best all-round midfielder in the draft class and should get early opportunities at AFL level. Unfortunately, going at pick 3 attracts a high price tag.

JACOB WEHR (GWS) $117,300 DEF

Mature-age draftee played alongside Jones in the Eagles’ SANFL premiership team. The 22-year-old will have to give up his job as a painter after being earmarked for an early AFL debut at the Giants. A creative defender, he is known for his accurate kicking.

ATU BOSENAVULAGI (NM) $175,500 FWD

Bosenavulagi may have looked like the steak knives in the Jaidyn Stephenson trade, but in fact the Roos had their eyes on him for months. That points to a role in the best 22 for the tough-as-nails forward, who is also capable of playing off half-back or through the midfield. Put him on the pre-season watch list.

CONNOR MENADUE (NM) $201,500 DEF

Former Tiger (39 games from 2015-19) was signed by VFL outfit Werribee for 2020 but never took the field thanks to COVID. North Melbourne recruiters see plenty of upside in the 24-year-old, who could make a wing his own in a new-look Kangaroos side.
 
Joined
1 Feb 2014
Messages
1,995
Likes
6,950
AFL Club
Hawthorn
ARCHIE PERKINS (ESS) $171,300 FWD/MID

You won’t miss Perkins when he hits the field for the Bombers. Long hair, rock star looks, an impressive rig for an 18-year-old and a habit of exploding out of stoppages charging towards goal make him one of the biggest X-factors of the 2020 draft class. “We see him as a boy who could potentially step up next year and play some footy for us,” Bombers list boss Adrian Dodoro said in December. “I think he’ll excite Essendon fans for a long, long time.”

DENVER GRAINGER-BARRAS (HAW) $194,900 DEF

Out Sicily, in Grainger-Barras? The (very) skinny key defender could be exposed early as the Hawks manage life after James Frawley and without James Sicily (knee) for most of 2021. Needs to put on some muscle but he played a full season against senior opposition in the WAFL and averaged three intercept marks per game. A bit pricey but it’s not unreasonable to think he could replicate Aaron Naughton’s debut year — he started at almost $170k, averaged about 60 and made $150k.

BRAEDEN CAMPBELL (SYD) $199,900 MID

Sydney showed last year it was prepared to blood their youth (Will Gould excepted) and Campbell could push for an early debut after being snapped up with pick 5 on draft night. The latest product of the Swans Academy (previous alumni include Isaac Heeney and Callum Mills) is a beautifully balanced midfielder who can win his own footy, tackle hard and cause damage on the outside with his booming left boot.

ERROL GULDEN (SYD) $117,300 MID

The “other” Swans Academy star, Gulden will also push for games early after playing for Sydney’s senior NEAFL side last year. Sydney matched a bid from Geelong at pick 32 for the 172cm midfield/forward noted for his pace, huge tank and footy smarts.

LIAM STOCKER (CARL) $196,500 DEF

Stocker — of the famed Liam Stocker trade in the first round of the 2018 draft — didn’t play a game last season, leaving Carlton’s Queensland hub for personal reasons. Given the club’s investment expect to see a lot more of him this year, which he starts with an affordable price tag if he can showcase the talent that delivered the Morrish Medal for the best player in the under-18 comp in his draft year.

ALEX DAVIES (GC) $102,400 MID

The AFL’s generous draft concessions to Gold Coast could deliver an even bigger gift to KFC SuperCoach players. Davies was tipped as a top-20 draft talent but the Suns got him for free as a pre-draft selection, resulting in a bargain basement price. The clearance specialist from Cairns is ready to play right away, the issue might be breaking into a suddenly strong Gold Coast midfield.

RILEY COLLIER-DAWKINS (RICH) $123,900 MID

“RCD” has been biding his time at the next level for the Tigers since being selected with pick 20 in the 2018 draft. But their faith in him was shown by a new two-year contract in October and the fact Richmond all but opted out of the 2020 draft. If they want to get a look at the next generation of talent that will take over from the likes of Trent Cotchin and Shane Edwards in coming years, the tall midfielder will be at the front of the queue.

DEVEN ROBERTSON (BRIS) $176,900 FWD/MID

Another popular rookie at the start of last year, the draft slider was a late inclusion for the Lions’ Round 1 team but lost his spot the next week and wasn’t seen again at senior level. His score of 47 in that game wasn’t amazing but there is plenty of potential if he gets more of a look-in, which is likely considering Brisbane had one of the best injury runs in the AFL last year.

JAMARRA UGLE-HAGAN (WB) $207,300 FWD

Ugle-Hagan is so good the Crows read out his name at pick 1 even though they knew he would never play for them. Young forwards aren’t usually great KFC SuperCoach picks and his price is definitely an issue, but keep an eye on his pre-season progress with talk he could debut early on a wing or across half-back. One thing is for sure, he’s going to be fun to watch.

LUKE VALENTE (FREM) $123,900 MID

There must have been some KFC SuperCoach players in the audience at a Dockers members forum in early December, where coach Justin Longmuir was grilled about the lack of senior opportunities for the 20-year-old midfielder. Longmuir said Valente had been a victim of circumstances in 2020 and fans could expect to see a senior debut in 2021. “We felt like he deserved an opportunity at AFL level this year but there was probably too many midfielders going well,” he said. “We’ve got strong confidence that Luke can become not only a very good AFL footballer, but we have high hopes for him to be someone who can influence others at the football club. He’s a person of high work ethic, high character and someone that’s going to really add to our group.”

TOM HIGHMORE (STK) $117,300 DEF

The Saints’ No.45 draft pick is a 22-year-old who caught the eye of recruiters with his intercept marking for South Adelaide last year. The Canberran models his game on Nick Haynes and Tom Stewart — two big ticks there for KFC SuperCoach players — and his story sounds a lot like new teammate Callum Wilkie, who was drafted out of the SANFL to fill a role and hasn’t missed a game since his debut in Round 1, 2019.

COREY DURDIN (CARL) $117,300 FWD/MID

The Blues identified a need for a small forward and Durdin puts a big tick in that box. The 18-year-old played senior football in the SANFL last year after winning the Kevin Sheehan Medal as the best player in the national under-16 championships in 2018. He’ll be learning from one of the greats in Eddie Betts.

SAM BERRY (ADEL) $117,300 MID

A look at Berry’s stats from a game against the Geelong Falcons in 2019 are enough to get our attention: 20 disposals, 17 contested possessions, nine clearances, three goals, 18 tackles and 200-plus KFC SuperCoach points. Might not be there in Round 1 but mark him down for when the Crows give him a chance.

CONNOR DOWNIE (HAW) $117,300 MID

Downie slipped to pick 35 on draft night but could make an immediate impact if he breaks into the Hawks’ best 22, which he has the talent and frame to do. Mature beyond his years, Downie played mostly off the wing and half-back for the Eastern Ranges but also showed an impressive ability to hit the scoreboard, drifting forward to kick nine goals in 14 games in 2019.

JEREMY SHARP (GC) $141,900 MID

Matt Rowell and Noah Anderson made an instant impact, but teammate Sharp had a quieter start to his AFL career. The No.27 draft pick played two games in his debut season, scoring 32 and 34 KFC SuperCoach points. Another pre-season at the top level should give him the jump on first-year draftees next season, for not much extra cash.

MARK HUTCHINGS (WC) $157,600 MID

Hutchings is a tagger — normally the sort of player that KFC SuperCoach players hate. But when you see a price like that ($50k cheaper than Jamarra Ugle-Hagan!), you have to change your thinking about the Eagles veteran. Hutchings battled injury through 2020, playing just three games, but has signed a one-year rookie contract for next season. Don’t expect big scores but if he’s shaping as a senior regular he could be a surprise bench option.

JOSH TREACY (FREM) $102,400 RUC/FWD

Treacy is a key forward prospect from Cohuna in Northern Victoria, but his KFC SuperCoach value is as a cheap as chips bench ruckman with bonus dual-position eligibility. That gives you maximum flexibility with trades and a high number of games late in the round make him ideal for the vice-captain loophole — just watch out if he breaks into the senior team!

DYLAN ROBERTON (StK) $139,700 DEF

Roberton was a bargain last season when he started at $260,400. That didn’t work out - playing just one game for 26 points. But look at that 2021 price! We are paying only a few bucks more than most first-year draftees for a guy who has been in the system for a decade and averaged over 90 in a season twice. We didn’t need another reason to barrack for Robbo to get his health and career back on track, but we really got one.

JARMAN IMPEY (HAW) $212,800 FWD

Impey has never really been a KFC SuperCoach option but he’s available for close to rookie price after playing just games last year after returning from a knee injury. He averaged just 39 points a game, but next year we can expect a return a lot more like his 74 average in 2019. That might not seem a lot but with fewer bottom-priced rookies available in 2021 we might have to get used to paying a little bit more for a 25-year-old “rookie” you know is in his team’s best 22.
 
Joined
1 Feb 2014
Messages
1,995
Likes
6,950
AFL Club
Hawthorn
AFL 2021: Check out your club’s best 22 for this season
ADELAIDE

B: Luke Brown --- Daniel Talia --- Tom Doedee

HB: Will Hamill --- Fischer McAsey --- Brodie Smith

C: Wayne Milera --- Rory Sloane --- Lachlan Sholl

HF: Ben Keays --- Darcy Fogarty --- Tom Lynch

F: Shane McAdam --- Elliot Himmelberg --- James Rowe

R: Reilly O’Brien --- Matt Crouch --- Rory Laird

Int: Riley Thilthorpe --- Jackson Hately --- Andrew McPherson --- Harry Schoenberg

Who’s missing from last season?

Jake Kelly, Chayce Jones, Brad Crouch (St Kilda), Tyson Stengle, Kyle Hartigan (Hawthorn), Lachlan Murphy, David Mackay, Paul Seedsman

- SIMEON THOMAS-WILSON

BRISBANE

B: Grant Birchall --- Harris Andrews --- Ryan Lester

HB: Brandon Starcevich --- Marcus Adams --- Daniel Rich

C: Hugh McCluggage --- Dayne Zorko --- Mitch Robinson

HF: Daniel McStay --- Eric Hipwood --- Cam Rayner

F: Nakia Cockatoo --- Joe Daniher --- Charlie Cameron

R: Oscar McInerney --- Lachie Neale --- Jarrod Berry

Int: Lincoln McCarthy --- Zac Bailey --- Callum Ah Chee --- Jarryd Lyons

Who’s missing from last season?

Darcy Gardiner, Noah Answerth, Cameron Ellis-Yolmen

- REECE HOMFRAY

CARLTON

B: Lachie Plowman --- Liam Jones --- Caleb Marchbank

HB: Sam Docherty --- Jacob Weitering --- Adam Saad

C: Marc Murphy --- Ed Curnow --- Sam Walsh

HF: Jack Martin --- Charlie Curnow --- Jack Newnes

F: Zac Fisher --- Harry McKay --- Eddie Betts

R: Tom De Koning --- Patrick Cripps --- Zac Williams

Int: Sam Petrevski-Seton --- Mitch McGovern --- Will Setterfield --- Levi Casboult

Who’s missing from last season?

David Cuningham, Marc Pittonet, Tom Williamson, Michael Gibbons, Kade Simpson (retired)

- REBECCA WILLIAMS

COLLINGWOOD

B: Brayden Maynard --- Jordan Roughead --- Isaac Quaynor

HB: Jeremy Howe --- Darcy Moore --- Jack Crisp

C: Steele Sidebottom --- Taylor Adams --- Josh Daicos

HF: Will Hoskin-Elliott --- Brody Mihocek --- Jamie Elliott

F: Jordan De Goey --- Mason Cox --- Callum Brown

R: Brodie Grundy --- Scott Pendlebury --- Brayden Sier

Int: Will Kelly --- John Noble --- Chris Mayne --- Tyler Brown

Who’s missing from last season?

Tom Phillips (Hawthorn), Josh Thomas, Jaidyn Stephenson (North), Jack Madgen, Adam Treloar (WB), Darcy Cameron

- NICK SMART

ESSENDON

B: Matt Guelfi --- Michael Hurley --- Aaron Francis

HB: Mason Redman --- Brandon Zerk-Thatcher --- Jordan Ridley

C: Dyson Heppell --- Andrew McGrath --- Jye Caldwell

HF: Darcy Parish --- Jake Stringer --- Kyle Langford

F: Devon Smith --- Peter Wright --- Anthony McDonald-Tipungwuti

R: Sam Draper --- Dylan Shiel --- Zach Merrett

Int: David Zaharakis --- Patrick Ambrose --- Jayden Laverde --- Nick Hind

Who’s missing from last season?

Adam Saad, (Carlton), Will Snelling, Martin Gleeson, Jacob Townsend (Gold Coast), Brayden Ham, James Stewart, Shaun McKernan (St Kilda), Tom Cutler

- LIZ WALSH

FREMANTLE

B: Reece Conca --- Joel Hamling --- Griffin Logue

HB: Luke Ryan --- Alex Pearce --- Nathan Wilson

C: Adam Cerra --- Nat Fyfe --- Blake Acres

HF: Michael Walters --- Matt Taberner --- Liam Henry

F: Lachie Schulz --- Rory Lobb --- Sam Sturt

R: Sean Darcy --- Caleb Serong --- Andrew Brayshaw

Int: David Mundy --- Darcy Tucker --- Hayden Young --- James Aish

Who’s missing from last season?

Ethan Hughes, Taylin Duman, Brennan Cox, Brett Bewley, Stephen Hill, Mitch Crowden, Michael Frederick, Travis Colyer

- REBECCA WILLIAMS

GEELONG

B: Jack Henry --- Mark Blicavs --- Jed Bews

HB: Mark O’Connor --- Tom Stewart --- Jake Kolodjashnij

C: Sam Menegola --- Cam Guthrie --- Mitch Duncan

HF: Shaun Higgins --- Jeremy Cameron --- Isaac Smith

F: Gary Rohan --- Tom Hawkins --- Brandan Parfitt

R: Rhys Stanley --- Patrick Dangerfield --- Joel Selwood

Int: Jordan Clark --- Luke Dahlhaus --- Gryan Miers --- Zach Tuohy

Who’s missing from last season?

Esava Ratugolea, Tom Atkins, Gary Ablett (retired), Lachie Henderson, Harry Taylor (retired).

- JAY CLARK

GREATER WESTERN SYDNEY

B: Sam Taylor --- Phil Davis --- Adam Kennedy

HB: Lachie Whitfield --- Nick Haynes --- Lachie Ash

C: Josh Kelly --- Jacob Hopper --- Harry Perryman

HF: Harry Himmelberg --- Jake Riccardi --- Matt de Boer

F: Toby Greene --- Jeremy Finlayson --- Brent Daniels

R: Braydon Preuss --- Stephen Coniglio --- Tim Taranto

Int: Jesse Hogan --- Tom Green --- Callan Ward --- Daniel Lloyd

Who’s missing from last season?

Heath Shaw (retired), Jeremy Cameron (Geelong), Aidan Corr (North), Lachlan Keeffe, Zac Williams (Carlton), Shane Mumford, Jye Caldwell (Adelaide)

- SIMEON THOMAS-WILSON

GOLD COAST SUNS

B: Jack Bowes --- Sam Collins --- Jack Lukosius

HB: Oleg Markov --- Charlie Ballard --- Connor Budarick

C: Brandon Ellis --- Hugh Greenwood --- Rory Atkins

HF: Ben Ainsworth --- Sam Day --- David Swallow

F: Izak Rankine --- Ben King --- Alex Sexton

R: Jarrod Witts --- Matt Rowell --- Lachie Weller

Int: Wil Powell --- Noah Anderson --- Touk Miller --- Sam Flanders

Who’s missing from last season?

Jarrod Harbrow, Darcy MacPherson, Nick Holman, Pearce Hanley (retired)

- NICK SMART

HAWTHORN

B: Blake Hardwick --- Kyle Hartigan --- Denver Grainger-Barras

HB: Jack Scrimshaw --- Sam Frost --- Shaun Burgoyne

C: Will Day --- Tom Mitchell --- Tom Phillips

HF: Jarman Impey --- Jack Gunston --- Liam Shiels

F: Chad Wingard --- Jon Patton --- Luke Breust

Foll: Ben McEvoy --- James Worpel --- Jaeger O’Meara

Inter: Tim O’Brien --- Tom Scully --- Mitch Lewis --- Harry Morrison

Who’s missing from last season?

James Frawley (St Kilda), Ben Stratton (retired), Jonathon Ceglar, James Sicily (injured), Isaac Smith (Geelong)

- GLENN McFARLANE
 
Joined
1 Feb 2014
Messages
1,995
Likes
6,950
AFL Club
Hawthorn
MELBOURNE

B: Tom McDonald --- Jake Lever --- Neville Jetta

HB: Adam Tomlinson --- Steven May --- Michael Hibberd

C: Ed Langdon --- Jack Viney --- Angus Brayshaw

HF: Bayley Fritsch --- Sam Weideman --- James Harmes

F: Kysaiah Pickett --- Ben Brown --- Jake Melksham

R: Max Gawn --- Christian Petracca --- Clayton Oliver

Int: Jayden Hunt --- Christian Salem --- Luke Jackson --- Nathan Jones

Who’s missing from last season?

Aaron Vandenberg, Jay Lockhart, Trent Rivers, Mitch Hannan (WB), Charlie Spargo

- REECE HOMFRAY

NORTH MELBOURNE

B: Shaun Atley --- Ben McKay --- Aidan Corr

HB: Luke McDonald --- Robbie Tarrant --- Jack Ziebell

C: Trent Dumont --- Jed Anderson --- Jared Polec

HF: Jy Simpkin --- Nick Larkey --- Jaidyn Stephenson

F: Taryn Thomas --- Josh Walker --- Cameron Zurhaar

R: Todd Goldstein --- Ben Cunnington --- Luke Davies-Uniacke

Int: Bailey Scott --- Aaron Hall --- Curtis Taylor --- Lachie Young

Who’s missing from last season?

Shaun Higgins (Geelong), Jasper Pittard (delisted), Jamie Macmillan (retired), Jack Mahony, Ben Brown (Melbourne)

- JAY CLARK

How would you rate North Melbourne’s best 22?

PORT ADELAIDE

B: Tom Jonas --- Trent McKenzie --- Darcy Byrne-Jones

HB: Dan Houston --- Aliir Aliir --- Hamish Hartlett

C: Karl Amon --- Travis Boak --- Xavier Duursma

HF: Zak Butters --- Todd Marshall --- Connor Rozee

F: Orazio Fantasia --- Charlie Dixon --- Robbie Gray

R: Scott Lycett --- Ollie Wines --- Tom Rockliff

Int: Sam Powell-Pepper --- Ryan Burton --- Steven Motlop --- Mitch Georgiades

Who’s missing from last season?

Tom Clurey, Brad Ebert (retired), Justin Westhoff (retired), Kane Farrell

- MATT TURNER

RICHMOND

B: David Astbury --- Dylan Grimes --- Nick Vlastuin

HB: Jayden Short --- Noah Balta --- Bachar Houli

C: Kamdyn McIntosh --- Dion Prestia --- Marlion Pickett

HF: Kane Lambert --- Jack Riewoldt --- Shane Edwards

F: Jason Castagna --- Tom Lynch --- Shai Bolton

R: Toby Nankervis --- Dustin Martin --- Trent Cotchin

Int: Liam Baker --- Jack Graham --- Nathan Broad --- Daniel Rioli

Who’s missing from last season?

Josh Caddy, Jack Higgins (St Kilda)

ST KILDA

B: Jake Carlisle --- Dougal Howard --- Ben Paton

HB: Nick Coffield --- Callum Wilkie --- Hunter Clark

C: Bradley Hill --- Brad Crouch --- Dan Hannebery

HF: Dan Butler --- Tim Membrey --- Jade Gresham

F: Jack Billings --- Max King --- Josh Battle

R: Rowan Marshall --- Zak Jones --- Jack Steele

Int: Paddy Ryder --- Seb Ross --- Jack Higgins --- Jarryn Geary

Who’s missing from last season?

Ben Long, Dean Kent, Jack Lonie, Jack Sinclair

- LAUREN WOOD

SYDNEY

B: Harry Cunningham --- Dane Rampe --- Jake Lloyd

HB: Jordan Dawson --- Lewis Melican --- Callum Mills

C: Ollie Florent --- Josh Kennedy --- Dylan Stephens

HF: Nick Blakey --- Sam Reid --- Isaac Heeney

F: Tom Papley --- Lance Franklin --- Logan McDonald

R: Tom Hickey --- Luke Parker --- James Rowbottom

Int: Will Hayward --- Braeden Campbell --- Tom McCartin --- George Hewett

Who’s missing from last season?

Robbie Fox, Aliir Aliir (Port), Callum Sinclair, Ryan Clarke, Justin McInerney, Lewis Taylor, Jackson Thurlow

- MATT TURNER

WEST COAST EAGLES

B: Tom Barrass --- Brad Sheppard --- Tom Cole

HB: Shannon Hurn --- Jeremy McGovern --- Liam Duggan

C: Andrew Gaff --- Luke Shuey --- Dom Sheed

HF: Zac Langdon --- Jack Darling --- Jamie Cripps

F: Oscar Allen --- Josh Kennedy --- Liam Ryan

R: Nic Naitanui --- Tim Kelly --- Elliot Yeo

Int: Jackson Nelson --- Jack Redden --- Jake Waterman --- Alex Witherden

Who’s missing from last season?

Brendon Ah Chee, Josh Rotham

- LAUREN WOOD

WESTERN BULLDOGS
B: Easton Wood --- Alex Keath --- Hayden Crozier

HB: Jason Johannisen --- Zaine Cordy --- Caleb Daniel

C: Lachie Hunter --- Marcus Bontempelli --- Jackson Macrae

HF: Josh Dunkley --- Josh Bruce --- Mitch Hannan

F: Mitch Wallis --- Aaron Naughton --- Tom Liberatore

R: Stef Martin --- Adam Treloar --- Bailey Smith

Int: Tim English --- Ed Richards --- Bailey Williams --- Jamarra Ugle-Hagan

- JON RALPH

Who’s missing from last season?

Ryan Gardner, Patrick Lipinski, Toby McLean, Laitham Vandermeer
 
Joined
15 Mar 2019
Messages
15,036
Likes
57,925
AFL Club
Hawthorn
I'd argue at least 3 or 4 of those names for the Hawks are not best 22 any more, but I guess they were included based on more experience etc.

McEvoy over Ceglar is a good choice that I agree with, but I think Ceglar is still the preferred number 1 ruck. Both would probably make our best 22 realistically.

Jon Patton was a mistake of a trade that I wouldn't rate best 22, I would prefer to see others like Jeka/Moore/Brockman/Jiath get a game instead in the forward line - less likely to break down after 2 minutes. Probably a few others would be a better choice too, just listed some I have heard that have looked impressive in training sessions this year.
 
Joined
1 Feb 2014
Messages
1,995
Likes
6,950
AFL Club
Hawthorn
KFC SuperCoach AFL: Predicted top scorers at every club

Will the proven stars reign supreme or is the next generation ready to take over? Our experts predict the top scorers for KFC SuperCoach in 2021.

Tim Michell, The Phantom and Al Paton

16 min read

January 27, 2021 - 10:59AM

News Corp Australia Sports Newsroom

The official launch of the 2021 KFC SuperCoach AFL season is almost here.

With only hours remaining until Australian’s biggest fantasy game opens, Tim Michell, The Phantom and Al Paton cast their eye across every club and predict the top scorers for 2021.

ADELAIDE

Tim Michell’s predicted top 3

Rory Laird

Matt Crouch

Reilly O’Brien

Smoky:Rory Sloane

There aren’t many obvious candidates who could unseat the 2020 top-three from Adelaide. Crouch was the third-ranked Crow last season but finished 466 points clear of the next best, Brodie Smith. Rory Sloane only played 12 games and is a proven KFC SuperCoach performer, averaging 100+ in every season from 2012-2019 bar 2018 (96.6). Laird dominated as a midfielder in the second half of the campaign, averaging 121 in his last eight matches thanks to a combination of big possession and tackle numbers.

The Phantom’s predicted top 3

Matt Crouch

Rory Laird

Reilly O’Brien

Smoky:Jackson Hately

As good as Laird was in the midfield late last season - form which makes him a KFC SuperCoach lock in defence - if Crouch hits the ground running, he’ll take some catching. A fit Tom Doedee is a chance to feature near the top, while Hately could be in for a big spike with greater midfielder opportunity.

Al Paton’s predicted top 3

Reilly O’Brien

Matt Crouch

Rory Laird

Smoky: Rory Sloane

2020 top three

Reilly O’Brien 1806 points, avg 106.2

Rory Laird 1787 points, avg 105.1

Matt Crouch 1771 points, 110.7

BRISBANE

Tim Michell’s top 3

Lachie Neale

Jarrod Lyons

Oscar McInerney

Smoky: Jarrod Berry

How can you go past the Brownlow medallist? Neale’s average of 134 might drop slightly when quarters return to normal but even then Lyons is unlikely to catch him. Neale’s right-hand man always gets overlooked in KFC SuperCoach but has averaged 98.6 and 112.5 in the past two seasons. Jarrod Berry and Hugh McCluggage have top-three claims but Oscar McInerney is the bolter. The Big O averaged 93 from Round 9 onwards when he assumed the mantle of Brisbane’s No.1 ruckman.

The Phantom’s top 3

Lachie Neale

Hugh McCluggage

Jarryd Lyons

Smoky: Cam Rayner

Neale is the obvious No. 1 - and rightly so. But I think we will see greater consistency from McCluggage, who posted nine KFC SuperCoach tons with five scores of 80 or less last year, in 2021. The young star added 22 points to his average in his second year and 18 in his third, before breaking three figures, following a seven-point climb last season. I’m tipping he’s about to push 110. Speaking of taking the next step, that’s exactly what Rayner could do when he’s given midfield minutes.

Al Paton’s predicted top 3

Lachie Neale

Dayne Zorko

Jarryd Lyons

Smoky: Hugh McCluggage

2020

Lachie Neale 2284 points, avg 134.4

Jarryd Lyons 1913 points, avg 112.5

Hugh McCluggage 1726 points, avg 101.5

CARLTON

Tim Michell’s top 3

Patrick Cripps

Sam Walsh

Sam Docherty

Smoky:Jack Martin

Banged up and heavily tagged in games last season, Cripps could hardly have had more go wrong. The Blues co-captain battled to an average of 97.5 but never truly hit his straps. After posting averages of 119.4 and 117.1 in the previous two seasons, Cripps should reclaim his mantle as the topscoring Blue from Walsh. Zac Williams and Sam Docherty will vie for the title of Carlton’s value pick in defence. Jack Martin had four games of 107+ to Round 6 last season and could threaten the big three if he can dodge the soft-tissue problems that have troubled him in recent years.

The Phantom’s top 3

Sam Walsh

Patrick Cripps

Zac Williams

Smoky: Will Setterfield

After a tough year, Cripps will bounce back but will it be enough to reclaim his crown from Walsh? It’s a big call, but I don’t think so - not with the young star’s durability and all-round game, which is developing at a rapid rate. Williams and Docherty are hard to split but the former Giant’s ceiling as a full-time midfielder give him the edge. Don’t be surprised to see under-the-radar midfielder Setterfield pushing the big names, either, after the 22-year-old averaged 108 points in the final five games of last season.

Al Paton’s predicted top 3

Sam Walsh

Patrick Cripps

Sam Docherty

Smoky: Zac Williams

2020

Sam Walsh 1719 points, avg 101.1

Patrick Cripps 1657 points, avg 97.5

Ed Curnow 1622 points, avg 95.4
 
Joined
1 Feb 2014
Messages
1,995
Likes
6,950
AFL Club
Hawthorn
COLLINGWOOD

Tim Michell’s top 3

Brodie Grundy

Taylor Adams

Steele Sidebottom

Smoky: Jeremy Howe

By his own lofty standards, Brodie Grundy (average 120.6) had a down year in 2020. A congested fixture for the Magpies clearly didn’t help him and he was forced to share ruck duties with Darcy Cameron and Mason Cox at times. Despite this, Grundy still had one of the best KFC SuperCoach averages of the year and only went below 100 twice. Lock him in as the top Magpie again. Interceptors were a clear beneficiary of extra scaling in shorter quarters and it will be interesting to see if Jeremy Howe can maintain his career-best numbers when he returns. Sidebottom will be a popular starting pick as a forward and could spend more time on the inside with no Adam Treloar.

The Phantom’s top 3

Brodie Grundy

Taylor Adams

Scott Pendlebury

Smoky: Josh Daicos

Grundy appeared to struggle with hub life and the condensed fixture last year but the star big man still finished with the seventh-highest average in the competition. I’m predicting Grundy and Max Gawn to meet around the 130-point mark again this season. Adams averaged 14 more KFC SuperCoach points per game without Adam Treloar in the side last year and that’s on top of the +22 differential in 2018. Pendlebury missed a few games through injury in 2021 but he averaged 120 points in his final five matches and, despite his age, could still hold off the likes of Jack Crisp, Steele Sidebottom and Brayden Maynard.

Al Paton’s predicted top 3

Brodie Grundy

Taylor Adams

Steele Sidebottom

Smoky: Jeremy Howe

2020

Brodie Grundy 2051 points, avg 120.6

Taylor Adams 1863 points, avg 109.6

Brayden Maynard 1740 points, avg 102.4

ESSENDON

Tim Michell’s top 3

Zach Merrett

Andrew McGrath

Jordan Ridley

Smoky:Darcy Parish

Dylan Shiel seems the obvious contender to Zach Merrett’s standing as Essendon’s top KFC SuperCoach pick but Shiel has never really reached uber premium status. The players capable of doing that are two of the shining lights from a dismal campaign last year for the Bombers — Jordan Ridley and Andrew McGrath. McGrath’s role as an inside midfielder and average of five tackles a game gives me greater confidence he can average 105+ than Ridley. Although it should be noted Ridley is one of the best ball users in the AFL and efficiency equals KFC SuperCoach points in abundance. Parish just needs more time on the ball.

The Phantom’s top 3

Zach Merrett

Andrew McGrath

Jordan Ridley

Smoky: Sam Draper

Like Tim, I believe Andrew McGrath is the man who can push Merrett in the KFC SuperCoach standings at the Bombers. With more midfield responsibility, the 22-year-old increased his average from 73 to 95 last season. But, taking out the injury-affected 29 in Round 18, McGrath averaged 104 points from Round 7 onwards. Returning skipper Dyson Heppell could make a play for Ridley’s spot at No. 3, as could Devon Smith, depending on his role, which fluctuated last year.

Al Paton’s predicted top 3

Zach Merrett

Jordan Ridley

Andrew McGrath

Smoky: Sam Draper

2020

Zach Merrett 1849 points, avg 115.6

Jordan Ridley 1733 points, avg 101.9

Adam Saad 1665 points, avg 97.9

FREMANTLE

Tim Michell’s top 3

Andrew Brayshaw

Nat Fyfe

Luke Ryan

Smoky: Adam Cerra

Not picking Nat Fyfe to finish as the No.1 Docker? Have I gone mad? Possibly. But the prospect of more time in attack and only playing 49 games in the past three seasons have me worried. The Brayshaw breakout was one of the talking points of 2020 in KFC SuperCoach and only a lack of time on ground stopped him going closer to Fyfe’s average. Luke Ryan already played on from every kick in and defenders have an additional five metres to play with this year. That alone will ensure he’s one of the years top defenders. Cerra is going to be a star but he’s still a rung below that trio.

The Phantom’s top 3

Andrew Brayshaw

Nat Fyfe

Adam Cerra

Smoky: Caleb Serong

It started in 2020 and it’s only going to continue this year - the kids are taking over at the Dockers. Brayshaw is only improving as a full-time midfielder, and should - hopefully - spend even more time on the ground in 2021. Of course, if Fyfe plays 22 games in the midfield, he’ll be No. 1, but when was the last time that happened? Ryan was dominant last year but he could be one who loses a few points as scores even out with the return of 20-minute quarters. He’s still favourite to sit alongside Brayshaw and Fyfe but I loved Cerra’s third season in the competition in which he averaged 101 points from Round 9 onwards. That’s a big jump from his sop****re season average of 62.

Al Paton’s predicted top 3

Luke Ryan

Nat Fyfe

Andrew Brayshaw

Smoky: Adam Cerra

2020

Luke Ryan 1824 points, avg 107.3

Andrew Brayshaw 1722 points, avg 101.3

Nat Fyfe 1585 points, avg 113.2
 
Joined
1 Feb 2014
Messages
1,995
Likes
6,950
AFL Club
Hawthorn
GOLD COAST

Tim Michell’s top 3

Matthew Rowell

Hugh Greenwood

Touk Miller

Smoky:Jack Lukosius

Based on five games evidence, why wouldn’t you think Matthew Rowell could be the top-ranked Sun of 2021? Rowell was averaging 126 after four games before his season was ended by a shoulder injury. No Sun got close to that over the full season. Greenwood is a tackle machine and that will always help his scoring, while Miller flew under the radar but enjoyed a very strong 2020 season. I just wonder whether 105-106 is his ceiling though.

The Phantom’s top 3

Matthew Rowell

Hugh Greenwood

Touk Miller

Smoky: Noah Anderson

Rowell could be the No. 1 scorer in the competition in 2021, let alone at the Suns. Seriously. Greenwood is my clear No. 2 but Miller could be pushed out by any of Stuart Dew’s young stars, including Anderson, Jack Lukosius, Lachie Weller and Jack Bowes.

Al Paton’s predicted top 3

Matt Rowell

Hugh Greenwood

Jack Lukosius

Smoky: Noah Anderson

2020

Touk Miller 1801 points avg 105.9

Hugh Greenwood 1795 points avg 105.6

Jarrod Witts 1587 points avg 93.4

GEELONG

Tim Michell’s top 3

Patrick Dangerfield

Tom Stewart

Mitch Duncan

Smoky: Mark Blicavs

Dangerfield plays the perfect game for KFC SuperCoach and his high-impact style will always generate points. Spend time forward, go into the middle, win a clearance or two and rack up points at will. Tom Stewart would have finished closer to Dangerfield last year had he not missed three games, while Duncan was the fourth-ranked Cat of 2020 from 16 matches.

The Phantom’s top 3

Patrick Dangerfield

Tom Stewart

Sam Menegola

Smoky: Jeremy Cameron

It’s hard to go past Dangerfield as Geelong’s KFC SuperCoach king, even with the pre-season groin issues. But after that, it’s tight. Tom Stewart averaged 106 points per game if you ignore the injury-affected 18 in Round 4, while Menegola posted 12 KFC SuperCoach tons in a career-best season. Mitch Ducann, Tom Hawkins and recruit Jeremy Cameron are also a chance to slot in somewhere behind Dangerfield.

Al Paton’s predicted top 3

Patrick Dangerfield

Mitch Duncan

Tom Stewart

Smoky: Jeremy Cameron

2020

Patrick Dangerfield 1936 points, avg 113.9

Sam Menegola 1832 points, avg 107.8

Tom Hawkins 1799 points, avg 105.8

GWS

Tim Michell’s top 3

Tim Taranto

Josh Kelly

Lachie Whitfield

Smoky: Tom Green

With Josh Kelly and Lachie Whitfield missing a few games most seasons, Taranto is primed to take the torch as GWS’ premier midfielder. Taranto is only mid-price due to his average of 84 last season but he averaged 102.4 during GWS’ Grand Final season of 2019. Kelly will have the best average of any GWS player but his body is always a worry. Ditto Whitfield, although he did manage a full season last year. The reason his scoring suffered at times was his kicking efficiency was well down.

The Phantom’s top 3

Lachie Whitfield

Josh Kelly

Tom Green

Smoky: Brayden Preuss

I want to put Kelly at No. 1 but it’s hard to look past the 18 home-and-away matches he’s missed in the past three seasons. He still may be the highest-averaging Giant but Whitfield, who scored 105 more points than any other player, despite an injury-affect eight in Round 3, will be hard to catch for total points. A fit Tim Taranto and a more settled Stephen Coniglio are the next two obvious candidates but Green is my big call of the pre-season.

Al Paton’s predicted top 3

Lachie Whitfield

Josh Kelly

Tim Taranto

Smoky: Braydon Preuss

2020

Lachie Whitfield 1777 points, avg 104.5

Nick Haynes 1672 points, avg 98.4

Josh Kelly 1604 points, avg 114.6

HAWTHORN

Tim Michell’s top 3

Tom Mitchell

James Worpel

Jaeger O’Meara

Smoky:Jack Scrimshaw

Mitchell finished 499 points higher than any other Hawk in 2020 — even though his high-possession style wasn’t really suited to shorter quarters. James Worpel’s average dipped from 97 to 88.3 but it won’t be a shock to see him rebound in his fourth season and average 100+. That still won’t come close to Mitchell though who should be set for another 110+ campaign. Jack Scrimshaw is the potential bolter after taking on a more prominent intercept role when James Sicily was injured.

The Phantom’s top 3

Tom Mitchell

James Worpel

Chad Wingard

Smoky: Jack Scrimshaw

After Mitchell, who is likely to improve on his 2020 season with the return of standard quarters, it’s slim pickings from a KFC SuperCoach perspective at the Hawks with James Sicily injured. Worpel could bounce back while Wingard’s ceiling is as high as any but Scrimshaw could be the surprise, after increasing his average by 22 when Sicily went down.

Al Paton’s predicted top 3

Tom Mitchell

Jaeger O’Meara

Ben McEvoy

Smoky: Will Day

2020

Tom Mitchell 1930 points avg 113.5

Chad Wingard 1431 points avg 84.2

Ben McEvoy 1358 points avg 84.9

MELBOURNE

Tim Michell’s top 3

Max Gawn

Clayton Oliver

Christian Petracca

Smoky:Steven May

Don’t be shocked if Gawn’s 139-point average dips to about 130 this year. He attracted a lot of scaling due to his large influence on Melbourne games, although these points won’t be as pronounced when quarters return to normal length. Oliver is a KFC SuperCoach stud but he won’t average 130, while it would be foolish to think Petracca will struggle to back up his breakout campaign. Steven May was one of Melbourne’s best scorers in the run home, posting triple figures in six of the last seven matches.

The Phantom’s top 3

Max Gawn

Clayton Oliver

Christian Petracca

Smoky: Ed Langdon

Just about the most-certain top three in the competition. Oliver and Petracca could improve again, while Gawn may drop slightly as the impact of every player on the field evens out again in 20 minute quarters. But the movement is unlikely to change the order, if all three remain healthy.

Al Paton’s predicted top 3

Max Gawn

Clayton Oliver

Christian Petracca

Smoky: Angus Brayshaw

2020

Clayton Oliver 2078 points avg 122.2

Christian Petracca 1998 points avg: 117.5

Max Gawn 1958 points avg: 139.9
 
Joined
1 Feb 2014
Messages
1,995
Likes
6,950
AFL Club
Hawthorn
NORTH MELBOURNE

Tim Michell’s top 3

Todd Goldstein

Luke McDonald

Jy Simpkin

Smoky:Luke Davies-Uniacke

Goldstein was comfortably the top Roo of 2020 and although he’s in the twilight of his career there’s been nothing to suggest he can’t continue to be the third or fourth-best SuperCoach ruck behind Grundy and Gawn. Luke McDonald was a shining light in a forgettable season for the Roos, relishing freedom across halfback and averaging an incredible 118.4 in his last 10 games. Jy Simpkin marked himself as a star of the future last year and KFC SuperCoaches can expect him to take another step forward in 2021.

The Phantom’s top 3

Jy Simpkin

Todd Goldstein

Luke McDonald

Smoky: Luke Davies-Uniacke

I’m still worried about his kicking - Simpkin recorded a below-average kicking efficiency of 54 last season - but he does so much else well. And it translates to KFC SuperCoach scoring, as his nine scores of 100 or more in and the 120-point average through the first six rounds of 2020 proves. This could be the year Goldstein is dethroned. I wanted to put Davies-Uniacke at No. 3 but it’s hard to ignore McDonald’s finish to the year, which saw him average 25 disposals and 118 KFC SuperCoach points in the final 10 matches.

Al Paton’s predicted top 3

Todd Goldstein

Ben Cunnington

Jy Simpkin

Smoky: Tom Powell

2020

Todd Goldstein 1904 points avg: 112

Trent Dumont 1721 points avg: 101.2

Luke McDonald 1623 points avg: 95.5

PORT ADELAIDE

Tim Michell’s top 3

Travis Boak

Ollie Wines

Scott Lycett/Peter Ladhams

Smoky:Zak Butters/Connor Rozee

Even teams such as the Power and Richmond don’t tend to produce many top KFC SuperCoach scorers. Travis Boak has produced his best two scoring seasons in the past two years and is showing no sign of slowing down, while Wines averaged over 100 for the first time in 2020. Whichever one of Ladhams and Lycett is Port Adelaide’s starting ruckman could average triple figures, but that becomes less likely if they share the role.

The Phantom’s top 3

Travis Boak

Ollie Wines

Connor Rozee

Smoky:Zak Butters

He’s threatened so many times but will Ollie Wines ever elevate himself to true KFC SuperCoach premium status? I’m more sure Boak will continue his career-best form in 2021. Rozee and Butters are both a chance to take another step in their third year and leapfrog a group of solid KFC SuperCoach scorers at Alberton, which includes Dan Houston, Scott Lycett, Robbie Gray and Charlie Dixon.

Al Paton’s predicted top 3

Travis Boak

Scott Lycett

Tom Rockliff

Smoky: Dan Houston

2020

Travis Boak 1868 points, avg 109.9

Ollie Wines 1565 points, avg 104.3

Robbie Gray 1554 points, avg 91.4

RICHMOND

Tim Michell’s top 3

Dustin Martin

Dion Prestia

Toby Nankervis

Smoky:Bachar Houli

He'll always dominate two or three games a season but Dustin Martin’s past two years have been his lowest by average since 2014. An average of 100-105 this year might still be enough to keep him ahead of Dion Prestia — who finished with a better average than Martin in 2019. Toby Nankervis will get a full season as the Tigers’ No.1 ruckman and therefore edges out Jayden Short for the third spot. I expect he’ll share a few points with Bachar Houli.

The Phantom’s top 3

Dustin Martin

Dion Prestia

Shai Bolton

Smoky:Jack Graham

In a sign of just how even the Richmond side is, Martin was the only Tiger to average 100 KFC SuperCoach points last season. Prestia battled injury in 2020 but he can push the three-time Norm Smith Medallist for the No. 1 spot. As can Bolton, who posted five KFC SuperCoach tons in the minor round before tallying 135 points in the grand final, after taking on more midfield responsibility in his fourth season.

Al Paton’s predicted top 3

Dustin Martin

Jayden Short

Toby Nankervis

Smoky: Shai Bolton

2020

Jayden Short 1643 points, avg 96.6

Dustin Martin 1613 points, avg 100.8

Nick Vlastuin 1440 points, avg 90

ST KILDA

Tim Michell’s top 3

Jack Steele

Rowan Marshall

Brad Crouch

Smoky:Hunter Clark

Steele became one of the premier midfielders in KFC SuperCoach last year, lifting his average from 95 in 2019 to 122.5. Whether that’s sustainable when quarters return to normal remains to be seen, but it’s unlikely Steele’s average would drop below 105-110. Marshall’s mobility makes him a great KFC SuperCoach scorer, although his points will always be capped when Paddy Ryder is also playing. Crouch averaged 98 in 2019 and that would have been enough to be in St Kilda’s top three last season.

The Phantom’s top 3

Jack Steele

Rowan Marshall

Hunter Clark

Smoky:Jade Gresham

I can’t see any Saint catching Jack Steele this year and Rowan Marshall, while he didn’t reach the heights of 2019, averaged 107 points in the final six games of the year alongside Paddy Ryder. Brad Crouch and Jack Billings will be around the mark again but I’m tipping 2021 to be the year Clark really takes a big step. The 21-year-old posted four KFC SuperCoach tons in the final nine matches of his third year, despite remaining at half-back.

Al Paton’s predicted top 3

Jack Steele

Rowan Marshall

Jack Billings

Smoky: Hunter Clark

2020

Jack Steele 2082 points, avg 122.5

Rowan Marshall 1763 points, avg 103.7

Jack Billings 1629 points, avg 95.8

SYDNEY

Tim Michell’s top 3

Jake Lloyd

Luke Parker

Isaac Heeney

Smoky:Lance Franklin

After neglecting to start Jake Lloyd last season, I’ll never doubt him again. No player wins free ball across half back like him and his distribution is first-class. The increase to 15m space for kick-ins will help him and there should be plenty of ball in the Swans’ defence again. Parker is Sydney’s best on-baller and Heeney has always threatened to average 105+. Wouldn’t it be something if Buddy returned and averaged 95+ too?

The Phantom’s top 3

Jake Lloyd

Isaac Heeney

Luke Parker

Smoky:Ollie Florent

Young gun Isaac Heeney will return after another frustrating, injury-plagued year but he’s unlikely to catch runaway KFC SuperCoach leader at the Swans Lloyd, who finished with a career-high 122-point average last season. Speaking of young, Parker isn’t that old, turning 28 in October, a few weeks after putting together his best KFC SuperCoach season since 2016. And Florent is likely to completely breakout at some point.

Al Paton’s predicted top 3

Jake Lloyd

Luke Parker

Isaac Heeney

Smoky: Lance Franklin

2020

Jake Lloyd 2077 points, avg 122.2

Luke Parker 1807 points, avg 106.3

Callum Mills 1521 points, avg 101.4

Western Bulldogs

Tim Michell’s top 3

Jack Macrae

Marcus Bontempelli

Adam Treloar

Smoky:Bailey Smith

Write off Jack Macrae at your peril. Some KFC SuperCoach believed shorter quarters would stop Macrae being as prolific but his average as still above 120 for the third consecutive season. The influence of every Marcus Bontempelli disposal helped the Bulldogs skipper average a career-best 116.1 despite his possession average dropping from 26 to 21. Tim English enjoyed a breakout season but the arrival of Stefan Martin will cut his time in the middle. Could gun recruit Adam Treloar get back to his 2019 heights, when he averaged 113? Or will the Dogs’ midfield be too packed to get a proper share of the 3300 points in every game?

The Phantom’s top 3

Adam Treloar

Jack Macrae

Marcus Bontempelli

Smoky:Bailey Smith

Treloar appears the least versatile star of the jam-packed Bulldogs midfield so is he the one we can count on remaining at the centre bounce all year? Maybe. Given his effectiveness there, I’m tipping Bontempelli to play more forward, as well as Josh Dunkley to a lesser extent. Does Macrae push out onto a wing at times? There’s too many questions at this stage.

Al Paton’s predicted top 3

Jack Macrae

Marcus Bontempelli

Josh Dunkley

Smoky: Bailey Williams

2020

Jack Macrae 2057 points, avg 121

Marcus Bontempelli 1974 points, avg 116.1

Tim English 1744 points, avg 102.6

West Coast

Tim Michell’s top 3

Tim Kelly

Andrew Gaff

Elliot Yeo

Smoky: Alex Witherden

Nic Naitanui was one of the major beneficiaries of a shorter season and shorter quarters, but KFC SuperCoaches will no doubt be wondering whether he can replicate his influence in a full campaign. The Eagles’ defence shares the ball (and points) too much, so their most-prolific scorers are likely to come from their midfield. Kelly, Gaff and Yeo are the standouts in the West Coast engine room.

The Phantom’s top 3

Andrew Gaff

Tim Kelly

Alex Witherden

Smoky:Liam Duggan

Extended quarters should only help endurance king Gaff, who recorded his lowest KFC SuperCoach average since 2017 last season and still finished as the highest-scoring Eagle. Kelly should be better for his debut season and I’m expecting big things from Witherden, who will suit West Coast’s ball movement out of defence perfectly.

Al Paton’s predicted top 3

Andrew Gaff

Nic Naitanui

Tim Kelly

Smoky: Dom Sheed

2020

Andrew Gaff 1806 points, avg 106.2

Nic Naitanui 1768 points, avg 110.5

Tim Kelly 1637 points, avg 96.3
 
Joined
1 Feb 2014
Messages
1,995
Likes
6,950
AFL Club
Hawthorn
KFC SuperCoach 2021: Quick guide to picking a winning team

Thirty players to pick, $10 million to spend. Where do you start? Follow SuperCoach expert Al Paton’s step-by-step guide.

Al Paton

@al_superfooty

6 min read

January 29, 2021 - 6:00AM

News Corp Australia Sports Newsroom

You’ve signed up for KFC SuperCoach, have a killer team name and uniform and you’re ready to start your charge to league domination, and maybe even the $50,000 grand prize. Now what?

Staring at the team screen with 30 blank boxes — and more than 700 players to choose from — can be daunting.

Here’s a simple step-by-step guide to picking a winning team.

Just like an AFL list manager, you only have limited funds to work with when selecting your squad. A $10 million salary cap sounds a lot but it will disappear fast, so look for players who provide value for money as well as scoring potential. Players returning from injury are often attractively priced, but come with some risk, so you don’t want too many.

You need a balance of superstars, mid-range players and kids who are ready to emerge.

Note: You can make as many trades as you like before Round 1, so decisions made now aren’t final. Expect to make some changes as we get hints on form, injuries and likely Round 1 selections over the pre-season. It’s possible to save a partially-finished team, but make sure you have a full squad of 30 players saved before Round 1 lockout to be part of the action.

1. START IN THE RUCK

The ruck is the third of the four positions on the SuperCoach player menu, but this is the place to start because these decisions will impact every other position.

The easiest — and potentially smartest — call is to pick Demon Max Gawn and Magpie Brodie Grundy. They have been the highest-scoring rucks of the past three seasons by a big margin — last year Gawn had the highest average of any player (140) and Grundy had the ixth-highest (120).

They are likely to deliver big scores every week and save you a lot of stress. The sticking point in selecting both is that it will use up almost $1.4 million — 14 per cent — of your salary cap on two players.

There are other elite ruckmen who come a bit cheaper — Todd Goldstein and Nic Naitanui have a good scoring history — but if you’re going to take the risk of starting without Grundy or Gawn the best move is to pick a bargain big man who you hope can score similar to the top tier and free up a big pile of cash to spend in other positions.

Braydon Preuss ($303,000) could be the best option in this category as he prepares to take the role of No.1 ruckman for the first time at GWS. Essendon’s Sam Draper ($379,100) or new Swan Tom Hickey ($261,100) are also cheap — but risky!

Whichever path you take, don’t spend more than $150,000 on your bench ruckman as they are unlikely to be called on. Fremantle’s Josh Treacy ($102,400 FWD/RUCK) will be a popular pick.

2. FILL YOUR BENCH

The next step is to pick your bargain basement players — aim for under $130,000 — in defence (two), the midfield (three) and forward line (two). These are your bench players who will rise in value once they start playing and can fill in if one of your first-choice 22 is injured.

The most important goal when picking a SuperCoach team is to find bench players who will get game time. Many teams have unravelled because there are too many cheapies who aren’t even playing.

Check out our ROOKIE BIBLE for a guide to the bottom-priced players expected to push for senior selection. Historically, first-round draft picks are safe bets, especially midfielders. Mature-age recruits are also good options because they are often signed to fill a specific role in the team — James Rowe at the Crows is a safe bet.

3. SOME MORE CHEAPIES

To fit your team under the salary cap you’ll need to start some of these cheap players on the field — so it’s even more important they are getting games!

Pick two more in the midfield and one more in the defence and forward line. You can up your budget here a little bit to include players like top draftees Will Phillips ($188,300 MID) or mature-age recruits like Connor Menadue ($201,500 DEF).

With all your rookies it’s OK to take a bit of a guess now and pick players to fill these roles who might not make your final team. Just remember to check back in before Round 1 to make sure you have the best cheapies — they aren’t much use to us if they’re aren’t scoring any points.

4. GET SOME BIG GUNS

Now for the fun bit. It’s time to splash some cash on the biggest — and most expensive — players in the game.

Due to their high price, you can only have a handful in each position — 2-3 in the backline and forward line and 4-5 in the midfield.

You need to spend wisely. Look for proven performers over multiple seasons — a breakout year could be a sign of things to come or it might be a flash in the pan. Players such as Jack Macrae, Jake Lloyd and Patrick Dangerfield have been high scorers for several years, so you can bet they will be again in 2021.

Reliability is a key factor. Players who appear every week save you trades and headaches throughout the season. You can’t go past Brisbane’s Lachie Neale — he has missed just two games in the past seven seasons.

5. FIND A BARGAIN OR THREE

There should be a couple of spots to fill in each position (apart from the ruck) and a bit of money left to spend (your ruck choice will have a large bearing on how much).

These positions are where you can take a punt on a mid-pricer — players who are massively underpriced based on their scoring potential, but who usually come with a large element of risk as well.

They might be coming back from a serious injury, like Jack Ziebell, looking for a fresh start, like Jackson Hately, or a young player ready to take his game to the next level, like Shai Bolton.

Their prices can range anywhere from Joe Daniher’s $223,300 to Jy Simpkin’s $499,700. What they all have in common is the potential to score way above their starting price — if everything goes their way.

These guys can make your KFC SuperCoach season, or break it. So you don’t want too many.

6. A NOTE ON DUAL-POSITION PLAYERS

Some players in SuperCoach can be picked in more than one position — they are known as dual-position players, or DPPs. Their real value in your team is they can switch between those positions during the year, potentially allowing you to cover for an injury without using a trade.

They also allow us to pack our sides with extra high-scoring midfielders by picking them in defence or the forward line.

As a general rule if high-scoring players are available as MID/FWD or MID/DEF, pick them in defence or the forward line — so put the likes of Dangerfield and Dustin Martin in your forward line, where dependable high scorers are harder to find. That leaves spots in your midfield for pure mids like Neale, Nat Fyfe and Tom Mitchell.

And if you can find cheap DPPs who are likely to play, stick them on your midfield bench. They can be hugely valuable as the season plays out.

7. ANOTHER NOTE ON TRADES

After Round 1 you’ll have 30 trades throughout the season — a maximum of two per week, or three during the bye rounds — to fix and improve your squad.

If you take a gamble and it doesn’t pay off, it’s not the end of the world. But a strong starting squad will set up your entire season.

8. GOOD LUCK!

Keep an eye on pre-season games to refine your team before Round 1, and we’ll have plenty of expert advice to help you make the best selection calls.

The next step is to convince your mates to join your private league so the real battle can begin.
 
Joined
1 Feb 2014
Messages
1,995
Likes
6,950
AFL Club
Hawthorn
Champion Data reveals every AFL club’s elite-ranked players entering season 2021
Who are your club’s A-graders? Champion Data has crunched the numbers to unveil which players boast an elite ranking heading into season 2021.
Rebecca Williams
February 3, 2021 - 6:00AM
News Corp Australia Sports Newsroom
Roll out the red carpet.
Champion Data has crunched the numbers to reveal every club’s A-list players.
So, which clubs top the list with the most A-graders? According to Champion Data, there are five clubs each boasting five elite players based on their 2020 player ratings.
Only one club had no A-grade players and four clubs had just one player with an elite rating.
Each player must have played a minimum of five matches and the rating is relevant to the players’ position.
Read on to see who the A-graders are at your club.
ADELAIDE
Elite players: None

After a forgettable season when the club only won three games, the Crows are the only team in the league without an A-lister, having had three the previous year – Rory Sloane and the now departed Cameron Ellis-Yolmen and Hugh Greenwood.
But they did have seven players with an above average rating.
The Crows are in a rebuilding phase so are devoid of top-end talent.
Sloane is in the twilight of his career, but they could expect young leader Tom Doedee to take the step in coming years from his above average ranking to the elite level.
BRISBANE
Elite players: Five – Daniel Rich, Harris Andrews, Lachie Neale, Jarryd Lions, Hugh McCluggage

After their preliminary final run in 2020, the Lions have emerged as one of five teams with the most A-grade players in the league.
Headlined by Brownlow medallist Lachie Neale, who had an elite ranking for disposals, kicks, handballs, marks and total clearances in a standout 2020, the Lions’ group of elite talent rose from three in 2019.
The Lions also have a further six players with an above average ranking, including the likes of Cam Rayner and Charlie Cameron, who could easily make the leap to elite.
With the addition of key forward Joe Daniher the cherry on top of what is already one of the most exciting lists in the league, the Lions’ time to roar is now.
CARLTON
Elite players: Three – Adam Saad, Zac Fisher, Sam Walsh

He’s the club’s biggest star, but after playing banged up with a hurt shoulder for parts of last year, Patrick Cripps has lost his “elite” status based on his 2020 player rating.
The Carlton co-captain is one of 10 Blues players rated above average, slipping from his elite ranking in 2019.
But the arrival of former Bomber Adam Saad has ensured Carlton retained the same number of A-listers from the previous season.
The running defender, who boasted an elite ranking for disposals and metres gained last season, joins Zac Fisher and young midfield star Sam Walsh as the Blues’ A-graders based on their 2020 rating.
Fisher met the minimum five-game qualifier with eight senior games, but ticked the boxes as a small forward with his ball-winning, pressure and goal accuracy.
He ranked elite for F50 ground ball gets and above average for contested and uncontested possessions, goals and forward half pressure points.
COLLINGWOOD
Elite: Five – Jack Crisp, Jordan De Goey, Brayden Maynard, Mason Cox, Steele Sidebottom

The Magpies are one of five teams to boast the equal-highest number of elite-ranked players in the league with five.
Headlined by vice-captain Steele Sidebottom, who missed the team’s 2020 finals campaign to return to Melbourne for the birth of his first child, and star forward Jordan De Goey, Collingwood’s tally of A-graders is up from three in 2019.
Ruckman Brodie Grundy and captain Scott Pendlebury were ranked above average after being among the elite in 2019.
After an injury hit 2020 when he missed a chunk of games in the middle of the season with an injured finger, De Goey needs more time on the ground and could be pushing for more midfield time after the off-season departure of Adam Treloar.
ESSENDON
Elite: One – Jordan Ridley

The Bombers are among four teams to have just the one elite ranking on their list for 2021, down from two in 2019.
Ridley was a standout for the Bombers in 2020, winning the club’s best-and-fairest award after emerging as one of the game’s elite defenders – all with just 26 games to his name.
Before last season, Ridley had played only nine senior games for the Bombers.
Dylan Shiel and Zach Merrett were the Bombers’ two elite players in 2019, but were rated above average last year.
After finishing 13th last year and losing key players at the trade table, the Bombers needed to enliven their list with future elite talent with three picks inside the top 10 in the national draft to kickstart a fresh era for new coach Ben Rutten.
FREMANTLE
Elite: One – Nat Fyfe

The dual Brownlow medallist is the Dockers’ only A-lister from last season after Fremantle boasted four in 2019. Entering his 12th season with the Dockers, Fyfe averaged more than 21 disposals a game and kicked 10 goals for the season in 2020.
Problem for the Dockers is they need two Fyfe’s – one in the midfield and one forward.
Coach Justin Longmuir last year flagged more forward time for Fyfe to allow Fremantle’s young midfielder the chance to grow, but can the Dockers afford to take him out of the engine room?
The Dockers also have six players with an above average rating, including best-and-fairest winner Luke Ryan, midfield young gun Adam Cerra and key forward Matt Taberner.
GEELONG
Elite: Four – Mark Blicavs, Tom Hawkins, Patrick Dangerfield, Sam Menegola

As they booked their first Grand Final appearance since 2011, the Cats had four elite performers on their list last year, according to Champion Data.
Up from their three A-graders in 2019, Tom Hawkins’ Coleman Medal-winning season earned him elite status alongside Mark Blicavs, Patrick Dangerfield and Sam Menegola.
The Cats have another seven above average players on their list this season.
The key for the Cats now is how boom recruit Jeremy Cameron, whose ranking has slipped from elite in 2019 to above average in a 24-goal season last year, fits into the forward mix.
GOLD COAST
Elite: Two – Sam Collins, Matt Rowell

The Gold Coast Suns had only one player with an elite ranking in 2019 – Jarrod Witts, but scored two last season.
Defender Sam Collins, who has an elite ranking for intercept marks, earned his A-grade status after a stellar season in which he claimed the club’s best and fairest award.
Midfield young gun Matt Rowell sneaks in under Champion Data’s criteria of a minimum of five games played after his barnstorming start to his debut season before he was struck down with a shoulder injury.
It will be exciting to see what he can do in an unhindered season.
The Suns also have nine more players with an above average rating, including Izak Rankine and Jack Lukosius.
GREATER WESTERN SYDNEY
Elite: One – Harry Perryman

The Giants boasted five A-graders in 2019, but midfielder Harry Perryman is now the only player to make the grade after the Giants missed the finals last year. Josh Kelly, Lachie Whitfield, Stephen Coniglio and the now departed Zac Williams and Jeremy Cameron all boasted an elite ranking in 2019.
Kelly and Whitfield are among eight players on the Giants’ list this year, including Toby Greene, to hold an above average rating.
HAWTHORN
Elite: Five: Luke Breust, Chad Wingard, James Sicily, Ben McEvoy, Jack Gunston

Despite Hawthorn finishing 15th on the ladder, the Hawks are among the five clubs to boast the equal-highest number of players with an elite ranking on their list.
The Hawks are up from two A-graders in 2019 to five with Luke Breust, Chad Wingard, James Sicily, Ben McEvoy and Jack Gunston owning an elite status this year.
Ruckman McEvoy was the only player to retain his status from 2019.
The Hawks also have another five players on the above average scale, including midfield star Tom Mitchell.
After a challenging off-season, the Hawks will need their A-graders to come to the party if they are to make a push back up the ladder and enhance their overall depth.
 
Joined
1 Feb 2014
Messages
1,995
Likes
6,950
AFL Club
Hawthorn
MELBOURNE
Elite: Three – Christian Petracca, Clayton Oliver, Max Gawn

The Demons’ number of players with an elite ranking jumped from two in 2019 to three on their list this year.
Star ruckman Max Gawn and midfielder Clayton Oliver retain their A-list status and have been joined by Christian Petracca after his standout season, in which he claimed the club’s best-and-fairest award.
Five more players, including defenders Steven May, Jake Lever and former captain Jack Viney, are ranked above average.
The Demons lack of high-ranking forwards underlines the club’s decision to recruit former North Melbourne forward Ben Brown.
NORTH MELBOURNE
Elite: One – Todd Goldstein

The Kangaroos had three players with an elite ranking in 2019, but ruckman Todd Goldstein is the only player on the list to make the cut after a difficult 2020.
Goldstein held an elite ranking in the league for disposals, handballs and total clearances last season. Of the Roos’ other two 2019 A-graders, Shaun Higgins has moved to Geelong and Ben Cunnington battled back injury last year.
The Kangaroos have five more players with an above average ranking, headlined by 2020 best-and-fairest winner Luke McDonald.
PORT ADELAIDE
Elite: Four – Robbie Gray, Steven Motlop, Zak Butters, Charlie Dixon

The 2020 minor premiers had four elite players on their list in 2019 and have retained the same number heading into this season.
Robbie Gray kept his elite status and has been joined by Steven Motlop, Zak Butters and Charlie Dixon.
Motlop ranks among the elite in the league for shot at goal accuracy and score assists.
The Power also have another eight players with an above average ranking, including Travis Boak, Ollie Wines and Connor Rozee, giving the Power arguably the most scope to have more players in the elite bracket by season’s end.
RICHMOND
Elite: Three – Nick Vlastuin, Shane Edwards, Dustin Martin

Despite claiming their third premiership in four years, the Tigers have just the three players with an elite ranking, two less than the equal league high of five.
Adding further weight – and proof – to the adage a champion team can beat a team of champions. Superstar Dustin Martin not surprisingly retains his elite status, alongside Nick Vlastuin and Shane Edwards.
Martin and Edwards were among the Tigers’ three players with an elite ranking in 2019 with Dion Prestia.
Champion Data has eight other players on the Tigers’ list with an above average ranking, led by Jack Riewoldt and Tom Lynch.
ST KILDA
Elite: Two – Dan Butler, Jack Steele

As they stormed into their first finals series since 2011, the Saints had two players earn elite status – former Tiger Dan Butler and the club’s best-and-fairest winner Jack Steele.
Steele had an elite ranking last year for tackles and total clearances, while Butler was also ranked elite for tackles and goals – with 29 for the season.
The Saints had three A-listers in 2019 – Rowan Marshall, Luke Dunstan and Sebastian Ross. Another five players scored an above average ranking.
The lack of elite talent had been an issue for the Saints and the question remains – do they have enough A-graders – or those that can potentially make the leap – to go the extra yard in the finals?
SYDNEY
Elite: Three – Jake Lloyd, Isaac Heeney, Dane Rampe

The Swans had three players with an elite ranking on their list in 2019 and have the same again heading into season 2021.
Dane Rampe retains his A-grade status and is joined by 2020 best-and-fairest winner Jake Lloyd and Isaac Heeney.
Josh Kennedy and Luke Parker’s ranking slipped from their elite status in 2019.
Parker, however, was among the Swans’ seven other players with an above average ranking.
WEST COAST
Elite: Five – Liam Ryan, Jeremy McGovern, Jack Darling, Oscar Allen, Nic Naitanui

The Eagles are among the five clubs to boast the equal-highest number of players with an elite ranking.
Up from their three A-graders in 2019, the Eagles have five players with an elite status on their list heading into season 2021 – star ruckman Nic Naitanui, forward flyer Liam Ryan, Jeremy McGovern, Jack Darling and Oscar Allen.
McGovern was the only player to retain his elite ranking from 2019.
The Eagles have six more players ranked above average.
WESTERN BULLDOGS
Elite: Five – Caleb Daniel, Bailey Williams, Marcus Bontempelli, Josh Dunkley, Lachie Hunter

The Bulldogs also have an equal league-high number of players with an elite status heading into season 2021, up from three in 2019.
Skipper Marcus Bontempelli and Josh Dunkley retain their elite ranking and have been joined on the A-grade list by Caleb Daniel, Bailey Williams and Lachie Hunter.
Jack Macrae’s rating slipped from 2019 and is one of seven Bulldogs players with an above average ranking.
It took the talent-laden Hawks four years to get back to a Grand Final after the 2008 flag and the time is now for the Bulldogs to capitalise on their elite and depth of talent.
 
Top