Position SC 2021: Defender Discussion
- Thread starter THCLT
- Start date
- Joined
- 1 Nov 2019
- Messages
- 435
- Likes
- 2,565
- AFL Club
- Richmond
I had a look at JShort's 2020 games with his SC scores below and the games in bold are the games Houli played.
It doesn't look like Houli influences his scoring.
JShort's 2020 games with his SC scores:
Grand Final 169
Prelim. 52
Semi Final 72
Qual. Final 129
Round 18 101
Round 17 75
Round 16 x
Round 15 114
Round 14 94
Round 13 88
Round 12 106
Round 11 85
Round 10 125
Round 9 94
Round 8 110
Round 7 86
Round 6 118
Round 5 75
Round 4 82
Round 3 126
Round 2 78
Round 1 86
It doesn't look like Houli influences his scoring.
JShort's 2020 games with his SC scores:
Grand Final 169
Prelim. 52
Semi Final 72
Qual. Final 129
Round 18 101
Round 17 75
Round 16 x
Round 15 114
Round 14 94
Round 13 88
Round 12 106
Round 11 85
Round 10 125
Round 9 94
Round 8 110
Round 7 86
Round 6 118
Round 5 75
Round 4 82
Round 3 126
Round 2 78
Round 1 86
The GF is somewhat of an outlier compared to the other games as Bachar tore his calf early on plus Vlastuin was KO'd.
Therefore Short had much more responsibility for the rebound.
Of course he was brilliant and without him we would have been in strife; but removing that game his average was 90 with Bachar in the team.
No doubt Jayden benefits from the new rules, but I'm not sure if that's enough to get him to 100+
Therefore Short had much more responsibility for the rebound.
Of course he was brilliant and without him we would have been in strife; but removing that game his average was 90 with Bachar in the team.
No doubt Jayden benefits from the new rules, but I'm not sure if that's enough to get him to 100+
Can always hope he's one of those players who scores better in the AFL, for certain positions it's actually easier. If he plays an intercept role at all it would definitely help.
My suspicion is he's going to be everyone's donut when Talia is back but he's got the chance to outplay Butts for the 2nd spot, definitely think there is a spot available for one of them if they earn it. Definitely a chance that neither earns it though and they're forced to play Doedee and Kelly as their other talls.
This is the rook backs situation this season, options like this are "viable"
My suspicion is he's going to be everyone's donut when Talia is back but he's got the chance to outplay Butts for the 2nd spot, definitely think there is a spot available for one of them if they earn it. Definitely a chance that neither earns it though and they're forced to play Doedee and Kelly as their other talls.
This is the rook backs situation this season, options like this are "viable"
Can always hope he's one of those players who scores better in the AFL, for certain positions it's actually easier. If he plays an intercept role at all it would definitely help.
My suspicion is he's going to be everyone's donut when Talia is back but he's got the chance to outplay Butts for the 2nd spot, definitely think there is a spot available for one of them if they earn it. Definitely a chance that neither earns it though and they're forced to play Doedee and Kelly as their other talls.
This is the rook backs situation this season, options like this are "viable"
My suspicion is he's going to be everyone's donut when Talia is back but he's got the chance to outplay Butts for the 2nd spot, definitely think there is a spot available for one of them if they earn it. Definitely a chance that neither earns it though and they're forced to play Doedee and Kelly as their other talls.
This is the rook backs situation this season, options like this are "viable"
I'm running clark at d6 most likely so no Murray in my team with Kosi and Highmore on my pine
I think Butts is well ahead of Murray and his spot in the team is pretty on the edge. If kelly and doedee play I'm not sure if he even fits in come round 1. If he does play he has between 2 and 4 weeks to show he is better than Butts when Talia comes back. Honestly don't know much about him other than us making the smart move to sign him given our young KPDs need some support particularly
A bit of a big call maybe but i think Butts is actually quite good. I don't know if he is worth the premium rookie price but i think his form will keep him comfortably in the team. Decent skills for a big guy
I think Butts is well ahead of Murray and his spot in the team is pretty on the edge. If kelly and doedee play I'm not sure if he even fits in come round 1. If he does play he has between 2 and 4 weeks to show he is better than Butts when Talia comes back. Honestly don't know much about him other than us making the smart move to sign him given our young KPDs need some support particularly
A bit of a big call maybe but i think Butts is actually quite good. I don't know if he is worth the premium rookie price but i think his form will keep him comfortably in the team. Decent skills for a big guy