So let's see...
Warner, Campbell, Gulden combined - 214. You'd take that from three rookies any day of the week, especially against Richmond. Can't remember who said it but that really just shifts the par score, not positive or negative since most everyone will have them.
Short + Mills - 186. Short a little disappointing today, but still fourth best in a well beaten side and awful DE so it's hard to see how he goes any worse.