Discussion 2021 Round 5: Teams & In Game Discussion

Who's the better Rookie to trade in this round...? Asking for Randomcliche

  • Waterman

    Votes: 79 73.1%
  • Bergman

    Votes: 29 26.9%

  • Total voters
    108
Joined
27 Feb 2014
Messages
598
Likes
2,061
AFL Club
Essendon
Last night Short's score went up by one for doing exactly that. Uncontested mark. Short pass directly to Steele which directly lead to a goal on turnover as the Richmond players were out of position. I know supercoach is a formula but ideally there should be more reflection of reality.
You were most likely seeing the effects of scaling.

It's very obvious in blowouts. The first quarter gets progressively scaled higher as the game goes on.

What happens in the last quarter almost doesn't matter
 
Joined
28 Dec 2012
Messages
4,021
Likes
2,719
Last night Short's score went up by one for doing exactly that. Uncontested mark. Short pass directly to Steele which directly lead to a goal on turnover as the Richmond players were out of position. I know supercoach is a formula but ideally there should be more reflection of reality.
You were most likely seeing the effects of scaling.

It's very obvious in blowouts. The first quarter gets progressively scaled higher as the game goes on.

What happens in the last quarter almost doesn't matter
It would have come after the mark points or adjusted in scaling.
 
Joined
9 Aug 2012
Messages
40,127
Likes
151,430
AFL Club
Carlton
WESTERN BULLDOGS
In:
J.Sweet, H.Crozier
Out: S.Martin (Managed), C.Daniel (Suspension), P.Lipinski (Omitted)
New: Jordon Sweet

Last week's sub: P.Lipinski (unused)

GOLD COAST
In:
J.Farrar, J.Corbett
Out: S.Lemmens (concussed), C.Ballard (ankle), S.Flanders (omitted)
New: Jy Farrar

Last week's sub: S.Flanders (replaced S.Lemmens

Sydney v Greater Western Sydney at the SCG, 4.35pm AEST

SYDNEY
In:
L.Melican, W.Hayward
Out:
I.Heeney (hand), J.Bell (omitted), D.Rampe (finger)

Last week's sub: J.Bell (replaced Isaac Heeney)

GREATER WESTERN SYDNEY
In: S.Reid
Out: M.Buntine (omitted), N.Shipley (omitted)

Last week's sub: N.Shipley (unused)

CARLTON
In:
M.McGovern, Z.Williams, T.Williamson
Out:
W.Setterfield (omitted), P.Dow (omitted), L.Parks (injured), J.Silvagni (shoulder)

Last week's sub: M.Kennedy (replaced J.Silvagni)

PORT ADELAIDE
In: T.Marshall, B.Woodcock, M.Bergman
Out: X.Duursma (knee), Z.Butters (ankle), P.Ladhams (omitted), W.Drew (omitted)

Last week's sub: S.Mayes (replaced Z.Butters)

BRISBANE
In:
D.McStay, J.Prior
Out:
T.Berry (omitted), D.Robertson (omitted), T.Fullarton (omitted)

Last week's sub: C.Ah Chee (unused)

ESSENDON
In: Z.Reid, M.Redman
Out: M.Guelfi (omitted), D.Zaharakis (omitted), B.Zerk-Thatcher (omitted)
New: Zach Reid

Last week's sub: D.Zaharakis
 
Joined
6 Mar 2013
Messages
10,190
Likes
31,121
AFL Club
Carlton
WESTERN BULLDOGS
In:
J.Sweet, H.Crozier
Out: S.Martin (Managed), C.Daniel (Suspension), P.Lipinski (Omitted)
New: Jordon Sweet

Last week's sub: P.Lipinski (unused)

GOLD COAST
In:
J.Farrar, J.Corbett
Out: S.Lemmens (concussed), C.Ballard (ankle), S.Flanders (omitted)
New: Jy Farrar

Last week's sub: S.Flanders (replaced S.Lemmens
These Dogs rookies play every week no matter how terrible they look.
 
Top