Discussion 2021 Round 6: Teams & In Game Discussion

Professor

Professor

#21
Joined
9 Aug 2012
Messages
40,127
Likes
151,430
AFL Club
Carlton
#21
In the mix
Adelaide
Verdict: Himmelberg for Frampton. David Mackay replaces Murray as sub. – Nathan Schmook

Brisbane
Verdict: Unchanged - Michael Whiting

Carlton

Verdict: Stocker and Cuningham to replace Williamson and Betts, with Owies an outside chance of earning a recall. – Riley Beveridge


Collingwood
Verdict: Sier, Hoskin-Elliott, Kelly and Murphy for Greenwood, De Goey, Howe and Keane. Kelly and Murphy to play roles down back and Moore to start forward again. - Mitch Cleary

Essendon
Verdict: Zerk-Thatcher for Ridley. - Callum Twomey

Fremantle

Verdict: Crowden for Cerra. Giro as the medical sub. – Nathan Schmook

Geelong

Verdict: Cameron and O'Connor for De Koning and an unlucky Atkins. Henry and Kolodjashnij to be prioritised given the Eagles' height in attack. - Mitch Cleary

Gold Coast
Verdict: Ballard and Lemmens for Macpherson and Harbrow - Michael Whiting

GWS

Verdict: Flynn and Perryman into the starting 22 for Mumford and Reid. Shipley to replace Buntine as medical sub. - Martin Pegan
Hawthorn

Verdict: Lewis and Cousins for Nash and Howe. - Mitch Cleary

Melbourne

Verdict: Weideman and Ben Brown to replace Mitch Brown and Melksham, with McDonald used higher up the ground and with Fritsch given another week to recover from hand surgery. May to replace Petty if fit. – Riley Beveridge

North Melbourne
Verdict: Davies-Uniacke and Zurhaar to return for Hall and Lazzaro, with Garner getting closer. – Riley Beveridge

Port Adelaide
Verdict: Drew and McKenzie for Hartlett and Houston. – Nathan Schmook

Richmond

Verdict: Unchanged. - Callum Twomey

Saints

Verdict: Marshall, Jones, Long and Byrnes for Hunter, Dunstan, Webster and Bytel. - Mitch Cleary

Swans

Verdict: Rowbottom, McLean and Sinclair into the starting 22 for Franklin, Hickey and Wicks. Wicks to replace Stephens as medical sub. - Martin Pegan

Eagles

Verdict: Jones for Vardy. Foley as the medical sub. – Nathan Schmook

Western Bulldogs

Verdict: Daniel, Martin and Vandermeer in for Williams, Sweet and Lachie McNeil.
 
Quasimodo

Quasimodo

#22
Joined
14 Oct 2019
Messages
1,182
Likes
4,279
AFL Club
Sydney
#22
Professor said:
In the mix
Adelaide
Verdict: Himmelberg for Frampton. David Mackay replaces Murray as sub. – Nathan Schmook

Brisbane
Verdict: Unchanged - Michael Whiting

Carlton

Verdict: Stocker and Cuningham to replace Williamson and Betts, with Owies an outside chance of earning a recall. – Riley Beveridge


Collingwood
Verdict: Sier, Hoskin-Elliott, Kelly and Murphy for Greenwood, De Goey, Howe and Keane. Kelly and Murphy to play roles down back and Moore to start forward again. - Mitch Cleary

Essendon
Verdict: Zerk-Thatcher for Ridley. - Callum Twomey

Fremantle

Verdict: Crowden for Cerra. Giro as the medical sub. – Nathan Schmook

Geelong

Verdict: Cameron and O'Connor for De Koning and an unlucky Atkins. Henry and Kolodjashnij to be prioritised given the Eagles' height in attack. - Mitch Cleary

Gold Coast
Verdict: Ballard and Lemmens for Macpherson and Harbrow - Michael Whiting

GWS

Verdict: Flynn and Perryman into the starting 22 for Mumford and Reid. Shipley to replace Buntine as medical sub. - Martin Pegan
Hawthorn

Verdict: Lewis and Cousins for Nash and Howe. - Mitch Cleary

Melbourne

Verdict: Weideman and Ben Brown to replace Mitch Brown and Melksham, with McDonald used higher up the ground and with Fritsch given another week to recover from hand surgery. May to replace Petty if fit. – Riley Beveridge

North Melbourne
Verdict: Davies-Uniacke and Zurhaar to return for Hall and Lazzaro, with Garner getting closer. – Riley Beveridge

Port Adelaide
Verdict: Drew and McKenzie for Hartlett and Houston. – Nathan Schmook

Richmond

Verdict: Unchanged. - Callum Twomey

Saints

Verdict: Marshall, Jones, Long and Byrnes for Hunter, Dunstan, Webster and Bytel. - Mitch Cleary

Swans

Verdict: Rowbottom, McLean and Sinclair into the starting 22 for Franklin, Hickey and Wicks. Wicks to replace Stephens as medical sub. - Martin Pegan

Eagles

Verdict: Jones for Vardy. Foley as the medical sub. – Nathan Schmook

Western Bulldogs

Verdict: Daniel, Martin and Vandermeer in for Williams, Sweet and Lachie McNeil.
Click to expand...
Predicting Atkins OUT hey! :eek:

Geez I hope not otherwise so much for all that talk here last week that he could be a season long keeper. :LOL:
 
wogitalia

wogitalia

#25
Joined
18 Jul 2016
Messages
3,769
Likes
26,254
AFL Club
Sydney
#25
SuchIsLife said:
Thoughts on the likelihood of Gulden/Campbell/Warner being rested?
Click to expand...
Warner I think is very unlikely.

Gulden I think is unlikely, while Heeney was fit I thought Hayward could come in to spell him for a week but not he's in anyway so unlikely, he's our best forward with Buddy and Heeney out so be gutsy to drop him.

Campbell definitely a chance but at the same time I'm not sure you rest him against an opponent where he'd play on someone his own age and a good chance to get some confidence up even if I think GC are a very good chance of winning.

Would think that McInerney should be the first one out for Rowbottom but definitely could make a case for Campbell there but they're not like for like.

With Rampe already out I'm not sure if we want to unsettle the back six any more.

Definitely an interesting period, would think they're back in next week if they do get rested though. All 3 are too good to waste time in reserves with, imo. Especially when we're playing guys like McInerney, Wicks, Rowbottom, Florent, Cunningham, Hewett and Hayward instead who've all basically established themselves as limited players with far less potential (Rowy might still have something but the rest pretty much are what they are at this point).
 
GrainFedBeef

GrainFedBeef

#26
Joined
6 Jul 2012
Messages
4,890
Likes
11,150
AFL Club
West Coast
#26
Goodie's Guns

Goodie's Guns

Leadership Group
#29
Joined
21 May 2012
Messages
22,311
Likes
31,152
AFL Club
Hawthorn
#29
whiteTiga2k

whiteTiga2k

#30
Joined
26 Feb 2014
Messages
3,147
Likes
3,311
AFL Club
Hawthorn
#30
Goodie's Guns said:
Based on the weekends performance, he should be safe even with Lewis and Gunston to come back in.
O'Brien and Nash go out without second thought for mine. Jeka pressing his case with great VFL form, but Kosi should still see more games to eek out more coin.
Click to expand...
Really need him this game with ridley out and highmore unlikely.

Hoping Atkins doesn't get dropped. Praying for Flynn and Clark to get named
 
Vicwood

Vicwood

#31
Joined
24 Feb 2020
Messages
4,895
Likes
13,330
AFL Club
Collingwood
#31
Professor said:
In the mix
Adelaide
Verdict: Himmelberg for Frampton. David Mackay replaces Murray as sub. – Nathan Schmook

Brisbane
Verdict: Unchanged - Michael Whiting

Carlton

Verdict: Stocker and Cuningham to replace Williamson and Betts, with Owies an outside chance of earning a recall. – Riley Beveridge


Collingwood
Verdict: Sier, Hoskin-Elliott, Kelly and Murphy for Greenwood, De Goey, Howe and Keane. Kelly and Murphy to play roles down back and Moore to start forward again. - Mitch Cleary

Essendon
Verdict: Zerk-Thatcher for Ridley. - Callum Twomey

Fremantle

Verdict: Crowden for Cerra. Giro as the medical sub. – Nathan Schmook

Geelong

Verdict: Cameron and O'Connor for De Koning and an unlucky Atkins. Henry and Kolodjashnij to be prioritised given the Eagles' height in attack. - Mitch Cleary

Gold Coast
Verdict: Ballard and Lemmens for Macpherson and Harbrow - Michael Whiting

GWS

Verdict: Flynn and Perryman into the starting 22 for Mumford and Reid. Shipley to replace Buntine as medical sub. - Martin Pegan
Hawthorn

Verdict: Lewis and Cousins for Nash and Howe. - Mitch Cleary

Melbourne

Verdict: Weideman and Ben Brown to replace Mitch Brown and Melksham, with McDonald used higher up the ground and with Fritsch given another week to recover from hand surgery. May to replace Petty if fit. – Riley Beveridge

North Melbourne
Verdict: Davies-Uniacke and Zurhaar to return for Hall and Lazzaro, with Garner getting closer. – Riley Beveridge

Port Adelaide
Verdict: Drew and McKenzie for Hartlett and Houston. – Nathan Schmook

Richmond

Verdict: Unchanged. - Callum Twomey

Saints

Verdict: Marshall, Jones, Long and Byrnes for Hunter, Dunstan, Webster and Bytel. - Mitch Cleary

Swans

Verdict: Rowbottom, McLean and Sinclair into the starting 22 for Franklin, Hickey and Wicks. Wicks to replace Stephens as medical sub. - Martin Pegan

Eagles

Verdict: Jones for Vardy. Foley as the medical sub. – Nathan Schmook

Western Bulldogs

Verdict: Daniel, Martin and Vandermeer in for Williams, Sweet and Lachie McNeil.
Click to expand...
IF Kelly plays down back it’s just further proof of Nathan’s state of mind.

Howe is out so Darcy needs to move back. Obvious. Right.?
 
Bermi

Bermi

#33
Joined
21 Jan 2016
Messages
8,415
Likes
31,955
AFL Club
Collingwood
#33
Vicwood said:
IF Kelly plays down back it’s just further proof of Nathan’s state of mind.

Howe is out so Darcy needs to move back. Obvious. Right.?
Click to expand...
I think Darcy could be a 'horses for courses' type of player, to make use of his talents depending on the opposition. If Cox was a better player, I think Nathan would play Darcy solely in defence.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top