Strategy Round 9: Trades

Joined
17 Apr 2013
Messages
1,436
Likes
2,961
I thought he was limping and looked pretty sore at the end of the game but yeah he hasn’t been tagged as injured anywhere.
He had that sleeve or whatever it was around his calf through the game. I can't recall a game this season when he hasn't limped at some stage, he came back on at the end of the game after limping off in that last quarter on the weekend. You'd have to put the durability question mark over him TBH, but he's still putting up decent scores even with Ryder in the team with him.
 
Joined
25 Feb 2019
Messages
8,833
Likes
14,268
AFL Club
Hawthorn
Trades this week
Morrison out Harmes in
L. Jones out (H.Sharp to Def) Poulter in
 
Joined
9 Aug 2012
Messages
239
Likes
1,003
AFL Club
Adelaide
Im looking at 2 options.

1. Tex/Kozi Out, Poulter/RCD in. 522.5k itb
2. Tex/Kozi Out, Poulter/any premium i famcy on any line. Thinking Boak, Lyons or Stewart at this stage with an R12 bye the preference.

Option 1 allows some leeway for assessing options and a double UG next week. But the prospect of another premium score at the expense of someone like Scott on field is really appealling too.

Ive flirted briefly with the idea of aaron hall, but i think i will save that for my draft league off the waiver wire!

Any thoughts on the merits of the 2 options above greatly appreciated!
 
Joined
8 May 2018
Messages
646
Likes
1,785
Here's hoping that Richmond can get some of that magic Hickey potion for Bolton...promotes miraculous recovery times ( former Hickey and current Bolton owner)

8 LTIs so far, not to mention all the STOs and DNPs like Martin, Daniel, Ridley, Flynn, Highmore, Meek, Fullarton, Clark, Hunter, Dow...and of course I managed to trade Koschitzke and Rowe out the very rounds they choose to have spike games...and that's just for starters :).

Still, I feel like maybe I'm one of the luckier ones so can't complain (y).

Down to 16 trades so Bolton goes to the bench for now. Like most, probably Poulter and RCD are targets this round.
 
Last edited:
Joined
20 Feb 2020
Messages
290
Likes
735
AFL Club
Bulldogs
Im looking at 2 options.

1. Tex/Kozi Out, Poulter/RCD in. 522.5k itb
2. Tex/Kozi Out, Poulter/any premium i famcy on any line. Thinking Boak, Lyons or Stewart at this stage with an R12 bye the preference.

Option 1 allows some leeway for assessing options and a double UG next week. But the prospect of another premium score at the expense of someone like Scott on field is really appealling too.

Ive flirted briefly with the idea of aaron hall, but i think i will save that for my draft league off the waiver wire!

Any thoughts on the merits of the 2 options above greatly appreciated!
Lyons or Mcluggage for mine
 
Joined
8 Jan 2020
Messages
6,262
Likes
26,151
AFL Club
Geelong
mmm, can hall be the answer to my bolton problem? he doesn't, tackle, bump or go near other players, plays kick to kick with seagull2 makes 70+k and becomes bolton post byes.
Id be more worried about the Hall pick if there was safe forward premium options but really you cant bank on any of them not getting injured really when you analyse their last 12-18 months.
Zorko- calf and achilles concerns
Marshall- ongoing foot issue to manage and looked sore as **** late in the game on the weekend.
Sidebottom- already done a calf once and form has been patchy.
Greene- Multiple hamstring injuries last year and always a suspension risk.
 
Last edited:
Joined
15 Feb 2021
Messages
1,307
Likes
5,403
AFL Club
Geelong
My SC Guardian Angel 😀 has "suggested" I do :-

Stringer - > Poulter
Berry - > Collier-Dawkins

so happy to go that way

Warner needs another big score to get his $$$ going again otherwise he will be going backwards.

Murphy out for 2 months so helps Berry , haven't heard much on Crouch lately.

Not sure if Pedlar is still injured.

IF Collier-Dawkins is up to AFL standard he has to stay in their side with all their injuries , he now is almost Top 2-3 mid option.

Everyone waiting for Flynn's next game , no doubt Mumford will have a rest and they will try Briggs for a game.

Is Flynn - > Sweet a option (questionable JS) , sounds like Hayes might get a go with Lycett out

Not sure whether to go up with Flynn to Marshall or down to ??? ,if we get a rookie debuting this round and looks ok.
Those 2 trades suggested to you look solid, gets the cash gen rolling again. Upgrade next week.
 
Joined
14 Jul 2020
Messages
1,192
Likes
2,132
AFL Club
Collingwood
Ok i got 2 questions for whoever

1. Is Jacob Weitoring worth bringing in? Seems like a bit of a discounted Docherty (Doch is my second option to him)

2. Isnt Butters coming back this week? I havent heard anything but i thought he wanted to come back in rd9 ready for the byes?
 
Joined
28 Dec 2016
Messages
747
Likes
3,842
AFL Club
Richmond
Super keen on Kosi > Ridley but now thinking it'll have to wait a week, which should be fine given their breakevens.

Warner > Poulter
Mansell > Byrnes

Already have RCD, and think that Mansell might find himself out after a few blunders late in the game. Have liked him as a player but he's just not an SC scorer, already holding a few dead rookies (Highmore, Sharp, Macrae, Flynn, Waterman) so I need to get these 2 in and hope they can still around until round 14.

Leaves me with 378k so the Rids trade next week is easy, will probably flick Flynn next round too.
 
Joined
31 Jan 2016
Messages
393
Likes
1,675
Normally a double downgrade this week would be a no brainer for me, but with Mitchells BE so low I'm wondering whether it's better to get Mitchell in now and just pay more for RCD/Byrnes next week. If everyone scores what they're supposed to then it looks like that move would cost me about $25-$30k more but would gain 50 odd points for having Mitchell on field over a rookie a week earlier. The problem is I have no idea which one is better, cash or points. This move also gives another week to have a look at which rookie is the best after 3 games, although on the flip side another week to look at Mitchell can't hurt either.
 
Joined
25 Feb 2019
Messages
2,576
Likes
11,640
AFL Club
Adelaide
Ok i got 2 questions for whoever

1. Is Jacob Weitoring worth bringing in? Seems like a bit of a discounted Docherty (Doch is my second option to him)

2. Isnt Butters coming back this week? I havent heard anything but i thought he wanted to come back in rd9 ready for the byes?
Got my eye on Weitering as well.

Re Butters: https://www.portadelaidefc.com.au/news/933401/injury-update-houston-to-be-monitored

Midfielder/forward Zak Butters began running last week as he continues to progress his rehabilitation from a left ankle syndesmosis repair, but his return will be delayed due to the ongoing recovery of an associated nerve injury around his knee, sustained in the initial incident against the Tigers in Round 4.

The nerve injury has resulted in some lower leg weakness that, although continues to improve, will prolong the rehabilitation process'
 
Top