2022: AFL SC Player Discussions

Joined
24 Dec 2019
Messages
351
Likes
598
AFL Club
Essendon
I’d say it’s possible, but if the current setup persists probably not. If he and De Goey keep switching and JDG is just building into greater fitness/more mid time, it could make sense that Lipinski gets M-F, but in practice I doubt the two would repeatedly switch positions like that in a proper game. I imagine they’d be rotating through those positions and the bench, for example.
Cheers Darkie
 

Bomber18

Leadership Group
Joined
11 Nov 2012
Messages
27,409
Likes
65,138
AFL Club
Essendon
$255k mid this season. @Connoisseur you tempted?

View: https://twitter.com/afl/status/1488651474531864577?s=21


ST KILDA coach Brett Ratten believes injury-plagued star Dan Hannebery can put a nightmare start to his time at Moorabbin behind him and play plenty of football in 2022.

….the former Swan hasn’t missed a session across the off-season and pre-season, following a meticulously tailored running and gym program that should see him feature in match simulation in the coming weeks and St Kilda's intra-club later this month.

"He's had a pre-season that I think by the numbers is the most he's done in the three or four years here, which is great," Ratten told AFL.com.au.
 

Connoisseur

Leadership Group
Joined
3 Jul 2017
Messages
38,960
Likes
126,626
AFL Club
Port Adelaide
$255k mid this season. @Connoisseur you tempted?

View: https://twitter.com/afl/status/1488651474531864577?s=21


ST KILDA coach Brett Ratten believes injury-plagued star Dan Hannebery can put a nightmare start to his time at Moorabbin behind him and play plenty of football in 2022.

….the former Swan hasn’t missed a session across the off-season and pre-season, following a meticulously tailored running and gym program that should see him feature in match simulation in the coming weeks and St Kilda's intra-club later this month.

"He's had a pre-season that I think by the numbers is the most he's done in the three or four years here, which is great," Ratten told AFL.com.au.
If he was to receive forward status then yes but I have not really considered any midfielders between the Constable and Rowell price range.
 

Bomber18

Leadership Group
Joined
11 Nov 2012
Messages
27,409
Likes
65,138
AFL Club
Essendon
Is Baldwin on the pink team or blue team ?
Have tracked this down from a poster on bomberblitz. Baldwin in the Blue team. Ridley playing for Pink.

Pink team is:-

Merrett
Shiel
Caldwell
Parish
Laverde
Stewart
Kelly
Durham
Heppell
Stringer
Snelling
Langford
McGrath
Draper
Wright
Smith
Ridley
Francis

Blue Team

Hobbs
Phillips
Clarke
Baldwin
Hind
Bryan
Ham
McBride (if he is 42?)
Hird
Redman
McDonough
Guelfi
Lord
Cutler
Waterman
Wanganeen
Fejo
And maybe Martin?
Pink team is:-
B: Laverde Stewart Kelly
Hb: Heppell Ridley Durham (later Hind)
C: Mcgrath Caldwell Langford
Foll: Draper Parish Merrett
Hf: Stringer Francis Sheil
F: Smith Wright Snelling

Blue Team
B: Redman McBride Guelfi
Hb: Martin Cutler Hind (later Durham)
C: Ham McDonough Fejo
Foll: Bryan Hobbs Clarke
Hf: Lord Baldwin Waterman
F: Hird Phillips Wanganeen
 

Bomber18

Leadership Group
Joined
11 Nov 2012
Messages
27,409
Likes
65,138
AFL Club
Essendon
View: https://twitter.com/scootermcneice/status/1489099446403182594?s=21


EFC Training Report Thursday Feb 3rd
Training Report Thursday Feb 3rd

Much cooler conditions with little humidity that i think got the boys up and about today. They were quite vocal and as February starts you can tell the season is not far from starting. Little did we know too that the boys were going to complete their first proper intra club match for 3 x 20min Periods (no overtime). This is what I wanted to see as you get a much better sense of where players are at.

It was Pink v Blue tops. Pink probably being 80% senior best 22 players. There was a 4-5 goal breeze going to the airport end of the oval.

The first bounce of the game and Ben Hobbs in Blue roves and tries to barge through some players. There is a ball up. Ball is bounced again and Hobbs grabs it again from the ruck and releases the handball…it was then i realised…ok I see you Ben!!! Ben would go on to have multiple clearances, hard ball gets and around 16-20 disposals in three short Qtrs. What was pleasing was that his short kicking was spot on today…was a great small game sample…even better it was against our top line mids in Pink.

One thing that stood out was the senior players who have been going “ok” suddenly showed that they mean business now. Parish was just getting so much of the football and became a threat going forward with two goals…one was a great roving play from Wright who tapped it perfectly to him from a boundary throw in. Darcy looked every bit of last years form. Langford for me probablty was the BOG. His overhead marking was brilliant. He must of had something like 20-25 touches and 8 marks in a 3/4 game. Langers played mostly on the wing but sometimes drifted forward to create an option. He is now playing that role to perfection.

As far as forwards…Wright kicked 3 and they were all solid one grab marks. I have to say his opponent was McBride who was really struggling. Francis played the first half for the Pink team and lined up on Cutler…kicked two on him and was creating headaches with his marking. Glad to see his form progressed to match practice. Never seen him actually smile and joke so much with the group today. He is in a great place. Francis went to the Blue team after half time and the oppurtunities naturally were not as much. Baldwin went to the pink team and suddenly we saw him break out and kick two goals. Importantly he had several strong contested marks today. I still dont think he is quite best 22 yet but I do believe he will get games this year and keep progressing stronger as the year goes on. Great signs today.

Shiel and Merrett were very solid today and got plenty of footy…both look in pretty good shape to have big years. McGrath also is showing good signs. I thought Hepps was probabaly the best as far as defenders today…he is moving really well and a full pre season is bearing some fruit. He could have the ability to help on a wing this year if need be.

The players vying for list spots were all pretty down today besides Clarke. Tex, Fejo and Martin i sense struggled a bit with the quicker pace today. Tex probably looked like he could do more damage and was moving well. Tex was half forward flank for the blue team so was a victim of limited delivery. Fejo just could not get into the game on the wing.

As far as rucks Draper was the obvious stand out. Did his normal 40m sprint from a ruck pack and kick the ball sideways lol. His kicking at pace is a slight concern but he does so many other things that impacts the game for the positive.

There were some players not at training like Eyre, Walla, Zerk and Cox. Unsure why sorry. Perkins completed half of full training. He is about ready to go.

Perkins i hear will join full training next week. Jones is only a week away as well. Brand, Reid, Hurley and Voss were in the modified rehab group.

There was a few positional changes. Lord played half the game as a small forward…created a nice goal for Baldwin actually. Lord is a really nice get…like him a lot.

Cutler offensively from defense was impressive and it was similar to his form in the back end of 2021. He is now a much better depth player…possibly even best 22. Defensively Francis got him a few times but overall still had a solid hit out. Snelling was very busy and doing all the things a coach loves. Caldwell also solid but got a slight knock to ribs or guts that made him a bit proppy for 10 mins. Was fine after that.

With a tricky wind the skills were pretty solid today. It was a fun first hot out to watch. Probabaly the main take away in the end was Hobbs…who the coaches would of been thrilled with today.
 
Joined
26 Jun 2019
Messages
2,559
Likes
9,517
AFL Club
Richmond
View: https://twitter.com/scootermcneice/status/1489099446403182594?s=21


EFC Training Report Thursday Feb 3rd
Training Report Thursday Feb 3rd

Much cooler conditions with little humidity that i think got the boys up and about today. They were quite vocal and as February starts you can tell the season is not far from starting. Little did we know too that the boys were going to complete their first proper intra club match for 3 x 20min Periods (no overtime). This is what I wanted to see as you get a much better sense of where players are at.

It was Pink v Blue tops. Pink probably being 80% senior best 22 players. There was a 4-5 goal breeze going to the airport end of the oval.

The first bounce of the game and Ben Hobbs in Blue roves and tries to barge through some players. There is a ball up. Ball is bounced again and Hobbs grabs it again from the ruck and releases the handball…it was then i realised…ok I see you Ben!!! Ben would go on to have multiple clearances, hard ball gets and around 16-20 disposals in three short Qtrs. What was pleasing was that his short kicking was spot on today…was a great small game sample…even better it was against our top line mids in Pink.

One thing that stood out was the senior players who have been going “ok” suddenly showed that they mean business now. Parish was just getting so much of the football and became a threat going forward with two goals…one was a great roving play from Wright who tapped it perfectly to him from a boundary throw in. Darcy looked every bit of last years form. Langford for me probablty was the BOG. His overhead marking was brilliant. He must of had something like 20-25 touches and 8 marks in a 3/4 game. Langers played mostly on the wing but sometimes drifted forward to create an option. He is now playing that role to perfection.

As far as forwards…Wright kicked 3 and they were all solid one grab marks. I have to say his opponent was McBride who was really struggling. Francis played the first half for the Pink team and lined up on Cutler…kicked two on him and was creating headaches with his marking. Glad to see his form progressed to match practice. Never seen him actually smile and joke so much with the group today. He is in a great place. Francis went to the Blue team after half time and the oppurtunities naturally were not as much. Baldwin went to the pink team and suddenly we saw him break out and kick two goals. Importantly he had several strong contested marks today. I still dont think he is quite best 22 yet but I do believe he will get games this year and keep progressing stronger as the year goes on. Great signs today.

Shiel and Merrett were very solid today and got plenty of footy…both look in pretty good shape to have big years. McGrath also is showing good signs. I thought Hepps was probabaly the best as far as defenders today…he is moving really well and a full pre season is bearing some fruit. He could have the ability to help on a wing this year if need be.

The players vying for list spots were all pretty down today besides Clarke. Tex, Fejo and Martin i sense struggled a bit with the quicker pace today. Tex probably looked like he could do more damage and was moving well. Tex was half forward flank for the blue team so was a victim of limited delivery. Fejo just could not get into the game on the wing.

As far as rucks Draper was the obvious stand out. Did his normal 40m sprint from a ruck pack and kick the ball sideways lol. His kicking at pace is a slight concern but he does so many other things that impacts the game for the positive.

There were some players not at training like Eyre, Walla, Zerk and Cox. Unsure why sorry. Perkins completed half of full training. He is about ready to go.

Perkins i hear will join full training next week. Jones is only a week away as well. Brand, Reid, Hurley and Voss were in the modified rehab group.

There was a few positional changes. Lord played half the game as a small forward…created a nice goal for Baldwin actually. Lord is a really nice get…like him a lot.

Cutler offensively from defense was impressive and it was similar to his form in the back end of 2021. He is now a much better depth player…possibly even best 22. Defensively Francis got him a few times but overall still had a solid hit out. Snelling was very busy and doing all the things a coach loves. Caldwell also solid but got a slight knock to ribs or guts that made him a bit proppy for 10 mins. Was fine after that.

With a tricky wind the skills were pretty solid today. It was a fun first hot out to watch. Probabaly the main take away in the end was Hobbs…who the coaches would of been thrilled with today.
***

It's not "of"

It's "have"
 
Joined
18 Jul 2016
Messages
3,770
Likes
26,259
AFL Club
Sydney
On a positive, every time someone says or writes this it's a fond memory of my mum threatening me with a backhand if I dare to say it that way again :LOL: I've never known anyone who hates that grammatical faux pas more than she did!

My personal two are the misuse of "loose/looser and lose/loser" which I just can't even understand how or why people screw up (written form only) and dominance/dominant. Both highly sport related :LOL:
 
Top