14. CARLTON
The top-liners: Sam Walsh (22 Games in 2021, 117 Average SuperCoach Score), Adam Cerra (18, 90), Ed Curnow (22, 86), Marc Pittonet (13, 85), Patrick Cripps (20, 84), Matthew Kennedy (12, 81), Jack Newnes (19, 67), Will Setterfield (8, 62), Tom De Koning (13, 60), Paddy Dow (16, 56), Matthew Cottrell (12, 49)
The top-ups: Lochie O’Brien (5, 65), David Cuningham (4, 60), Jack Carroll (0, 0), Alex Mirkov (0, 0)
MICK SAYS
Clearly the Blues had to add some more midfield talent to take the pressure off Patrick Cripps and Sam Walsh and they did that during the trade period last year. Recruiting the talented young Adam Cerra and the experienced George Hewett — who can play midfield or defence — were really important to add to the depth. Cripps has to get back to being the inside competitive contested ball winner we know he can be and let Cerra and Walsh do the work on the outside. Walsh’s delayed start to the season with ankle surgery is far from ideal, but for the Blues’ sake hopefully their reigning best-and-fairest is back on the field and back firing soon. I’d move defender Sam Docherty to a wing role, where he is capable of doing what Mitch Robinson does for Brisbane. After a solid season as a defender, I’d also be looking to give Liam Stocker some time as a midfielder, which he was recruited to be. The great debate will be whether ruckman Marc Pittonet and Tom De Koning can play in the same team as a ruck combination as they also have key forwards in Harry McKay, Charlie Curnow and even Jack Silvagni who was used as a relief ruckman last year. De Koning is an exciting and developing player but isn’t quite ready to take over the mantle as No. 1 ruckman.
Adam Cerra is a big recruit for Carlton. Picture: Getty Images
15. FREMANTLE
The top-liners: Sean Darcy (21 Games in 2021, 118 Average SuperCoach Score), Andrew Brayshaw (20, 107), Nat Fyfe (15, 100), David Mundy (22, 100), Caleb Serong (21, 83), Jordan Clark (8, 62), Lloyd Meek (9, 48), Connor Blakely (11, 44)
The top-ups: Will Brodie (4, 52), Joel Western (4, 22), Eric Benning (0, 0), Neil Erasmus (0, 0), Matthew Johnson (0, 0), Luke Valente (0, 0)
MICK SAYS
I really rate ruckman Sean Darcy, who played 21 games in a breakout 2021 to win the Dockers’ best and fairest. He’s such an impressive player with his follow up work, he has good footy IQ and has the mobility to get around the ground to support in the air. He’s a prominent ruckman who complements an ever-evolving midfield group of Andrew Brayshaw, Caleb Serong, Nat Fyfe and David Mundy very well. I also like the recruitment of Jordan Clark, who can play a key role on one wing for Fremantle this year. Does fellow recruit Will Brodie get a run? He was a highly-touted Gold Coast draftee but he hasn’t shown it yet. My concern for the Dockers is their on ball depth. Two or three injuries among the key midfield group and they look in trouble.
16. ADELAIDE
The top-liners: Rory Laird (22 Games in 2021, 116 Average SuperCoach Score), Ben Keays (22, 103), Rory Sloane (18, 97), Reilly O’Brien (20, 96), Paul Seedsman (22, 96), Lachlan Sholl (18, 66), Harry Schoenberg (22, 72), Matt Crouch (0, 0)
The top-ups: Kieran Strachan (2, 101), Brayden Cook (3, 48), Jackson Hately (3, 43), Luke Pedlar (2, 20), Luke Nankervis (0, 0), Jake Soligo (0, 0), Zac Taylor (0, 0).
MICK SAYS
I like the balance of the Crows’ midfield group in that Ben Keays can act as a defensive midfielder but also accumulate the ball and he allows prolific ball winners Rory Laird and Rory Sloane to do what they do best. The two ruckmen in Rilley O’Brien and Kieran Strachan are a work in progress but I like the development they are both showing. Lachlan Sholl and Harry Schoenberg are also developing nicely. Matt Crouch’s return from groin issues will help the Crows a lot, given his ball-winning and clearance ability, experience and short but effective ball use. What I would like to see is more goals from the Crows midfielders. Sloane and Laird each kicked only three goals last season. That’s not good enough from two of your side’s A-Graders.
Rory Sloane needs to kick more goals for Adelaide. Picture: Michael Klein
17. NORTH MELBOURNE
The top-liners: Ben Cunnington (15 Games in 2021, 109 Average SuperCoach Score), Todd Goldstein (22, 101), Jy Simpkin (22, 97), Hugh Greenwood (15, 93), Luke Davies-Uniacke (20, 85), Tarryn Thomas (21, 84), Jed Anderson (7, 82), Luke McDonald (11, 68), Tom Powell (13, 68), Callum Coleman-Jones (8, 66), Will Phillips (14, 48), Jason Horne-Francis (0, 0)
The top-ups: Jared Polec (5, 50), Charlie Comben (1, 35), Jacob Edwards (0, 0), Joshua Goater (0, 0)
MICK SAYS
The Kangaroos are hard to judge, given the unknown with two of their prime movers in Ben Cunnington (cancer) and Jed Anderson (vaccination rules).
The recruitment of Hugh Greenwood is a major positive as a big inside midfielder who can fill some of the void of Cunnington in the short-term.
There are some good younger players in Jy Simpkin, Tom Powell and Will Phillips, while the evergreen Todd Goldstein will continually work overtime. Goldstein plays his best footy when he’s the No. 1 ruckman, but might find himself having to share duties with recruit Callum Coleman-Jones a little this year. No. 1 draft pick Jason Horne-Francis looks a ready-made AFL player. The rapid growth of Tarryn Thomas is also exciting for North fans. He’s got a great skill set. He is tough, breaks the lines, has good poise and makes good decisions. He can also float forward and hit the scoreboard.
18. GOLD COAST
The top-liners: Touk Miller (21 Games in 2021, 125 Average SuperCoach Score), Brayden Fiorini (9, 101), Brandon Ellis (18, 90), David Swallow (21, 90), Jarrod Witts (3, 87), Noah Anderson (20, 84), Lachie Weller (13, 74), Mabior Chol (10, 68), Jeremy Sharp (9, 65), Matt Rowell (12, 63), Chris Burgess (19, 58), Rory Atkins (8, 46), Charlie Constable (3, 49)
The top-ups: Alex Davies (1, 62), Mac Andrew (0, 0), Matt Conroy (0, 0), Elijah Hollands (0, 0), Ned Moyle (0, 0), Patrick Murtagh (0, 0), Bodhi Uwland (0, 0)
More Coverage
Revealed: AFL’s true millionaires and player paymentsTeam reveal: SuperCoach cheapies rookie guru’s pickedFree agents: Gettable guns your club will be eyeing
MICK SAYS
Hugh Greenwood was the loss the Suns didn’t need during last year’s off-season and will be sorely missed as a big inside midfielder who could win the contested ball and clearances.
More responsibility will fall on Touk Miller, David Swallow, Matt Rowell and Noah Anderson to fill the void. Lachie Weller can become the breakaway midfielder around congestion that the Suns desperately need.
Ruckman Jarrod Witts’ return from a knee reconstruction will be important, after the Suns were exposed around stoppages without him last year.
Witts will have some added assistance from recruit Mabior Chol as a forward-ruckman. Chol is a talent, but my knock on him is that he picks and chooses when to put his body on the line when he is needed to help out his defenders.
That reluctance must change if he wants to win respect at his new club. Coach Stuart Dew has the talent there, but the Suns can’t afford to rank 17th for contested possession differential and 15th for centre bounce clearance differential again.
Dramatic change is needed.