Discussion NRL SuperCoach Discussion

Joined
29 Nov 2019
Messages
5,671
Likes
20,334
AFL Club
Brisbane
Hi all,

What's your thoughts with the following?

Cheapies are still a wait until TLT

No Cleary, have included Grant and Munster instead, they should be good to go RD2.
$62K ITB

Could go Sexton > SJ ??

Randall / Grant
Haas, Arrow / EB*, Moe
DFif, TPJ, Aitken / Tago*, KTui, Piak
Sexton / Ilias
Hastings / Munster
XC, Pareira, Suaali, Penisini / Amone*, TayMay, Moga
Teddy (C) / Paps*

Any ideas with this draft?
 

KLo30

Leadership Group
Joined
27 Jan 2014
Messages
18,220
Likes
53,273
AFL Club
North Melb.
Hi all,

What's your thoughts with the following?

Cheapies are still a wait until TLT

No Cleary, have included Grant and Munster instead, they should be good to go RD2.
$62K ITB

Could go Sexton > SJ ??

Randall / Grant
Haas, Arrow / EB*, Moe
DFif, TPJ, Aitken / Tago*, KTui, Piak
Sexton / Ilias
Hastings / Munster
XC, Pareira, Suaali, Penisini / Amone*, TayMay, Moga
Teddy (C) / Paps*

Any ideas with this draft?
I'm not sure I'd be going with both Grant and Munster. You can cover one for round 1, but two might be a bridge too far. Paps injured himself recently (ankle) and might be struggling for round 1 as well. The rest looks fine, but I'd be spending at least 2/3s of that $600K after TLT.
 
Joined
29 Nov 2019
Messages
5,671
Likes
20,334
AFL Club
Brisbane
I'm not sure I'd be going with both Grant and Munster. You can cover one for round 1, but two might be a bridge too far. Paps injured himself recently (ankle) and might be struggling for round 1 as well. The rest looks fine, but I'd be spending at least 2/3s of that $600K after TLT.
Slight changes made

Thinking of
EB, Munster, Paps > Turbo, GB, Geyer


Randall / Grant
Haas, Arrow / EB*, Moe
DFif, TPJ, Aitken / Tago*, KTui, Piak
Sexton / Ilias
Hastings / Munster
XC, Pareira, Suaali, Penisini / Amone*, TayMay, Moga
Teddy (C) / Paps*

to

Randall / Grant
Haas, Arrow / GB*, Moe
DFif, TPJ, Aitken / KTui, Piak, Geyer
Sexton / Ilias*
Hastings / Amone*
XC, Pareira, Tago, Penisini / Suaali, TayMay, Moga
Turbo (C) / Teddy*

$1.8m in the 2nd Row, so could even do something like
Curran, TPJ, McInnis

Just not sure - All cheapies are based on TLT.
I don't mind being light in the halves, and CTW's as long as they all start and look to make money
 
Joined
29 Nov 2019
Messages
5,671
Likes
20,334
AFL Club
Brisbane
Slight changes made

Thinking of
EB, Munster, Paps > Turbo, GB, Geyer


Randall / Grant
Haas, Arrow / EB*, Moe
DFif, TPJ, Aitken / Tago*, KTui, Piak
Sexton / Ilias
Hastings / Munster
XC, Pareira, Suaali, Penisini / Amone*, TayMay, Moga
Teddy (C) / Paps*

to

Randall / Grant
Haas, Arrow / GB*, Moe
DFif, TPJ, Aitken / KTui, Piak, Geyer
Sexton / Ilias*
Hastings / Amone*
XC, Pareira, Tago, Penisini / Suaali, TayMay, Moga
Turbo (C) / Teddy*

$1.8m in the 2nd Row, so could even do something like
Curran, TPJ, McInnis

Just not sure - All cheapies are based on TLT.
I don't mind being light in the halves, and CTW's as long as they all start and look to make money
With a small adjustment, I now have

$1,147,900 to spend on

2 FRF/2RF spos up for grabs - Still thinking TPJ gets one, and prob Aitken the other (I like the flexibility they'll give me early on)

Haas, Arrow
DFif, ?, ?

So, still deciding between a combination from the following....
What's your thoughts?

price, (left in kitty)

Gus - straight up gun
$653,200, ($494,700)

Curran - I like this guy, the ball seems to follow him
$586,800, ($561,100)

TPJ - probs will take 1 spot - I like the ceiling - if he plays up, easy swap
$569,900, ($578,000)

Matto - seems a keeper, but those head knocks...
$569,300, ($578,600)

Cam McInnes - DPP, coming back from a season off
$535,400, ($612,500)

Tino - DPP, Titans captain = more minutes??
$493,500, ($654,400)

Aitken - DPP, so looking most likely. I'm happy with my CTW's, so I'm not looking at starting him there
$486,000, ($661,900)

Tups - A solid keeper all year round
$482,200, ($665,700)

Others I've thought about.
Uto, AFB (Arrow > 2RF), Kolo, and Ola

Argh! so many good players
 

Connoisseur

Leadership Group
Joined
3 Jul 2017
Messages
39,297
Likes
127,821
AFL Club
Port Adelaide
I don't see much upside. You'll get what you pay for. No DPP doesn't help his cause.
Thank you. Fond memories from prior ownership and you know my penchant for seeking value. On that note, do you think S Walker is worthy of a starting selection?
 
Top