Discussion 2022 Round 9: Teams & In Game Discussion

Rowsus

Statistician
Joined
19 Mar 2012
Messages
29,130
Likes
64,893
AFL Club
Melbourne
At some point Craig McRae will realise Begg is ****, Cameron would have gone 120 if he didnt sit forward in key moments while that kid got absolutely belted.
I think McRae is aware of Begg's limitations, but if you're not going to give him a run against Sweet/Cordy, then you may as well banish him to the VFL until next season. He's only 19!!!
 
Joined
9 Feb 2015
Messages
9,440
Likes
57,908
AFL Club
West Coast
From Bevo’s after match presser :-

RUCKMAN Tim English is set to miss another game with illness next week as the Western Bulldogs look to get on a winning run after their strong victory over Collingwood on Friday night.

The Dogs were too strong for the Magpies at Marvel Stadium, running out 48-point winners to take their season to 4-5 after last year’s Grand Final performance.

They will push to make it back-to-back wins for the first time since the finals last year with their clash against Gold Coast next week in Ballarat but are expecting to again be without their first-choice big man, who has been hit hard by the flu over the past week.

“I don’t think Tim will come back this week. I mentioned he’d been really ill and I mean really ill and so I don’t think he’ll be ready to play next week so ‘Sweety’ is likely to continue on,” Beveridge said post-game.

“Jarrod Witts got the 10 coaches votes last week and was really influential in the game against the Swans having studied them in the lead-up, so he’ll be a big challenge for Sweety but it’s likely to be a similar (ruck) set up as it was tonight.

“(English) just has a really, really bad bout of this flu. It’s just really knocked him around. Nothing sinister, we think he’ll be OK, but he’s probably dropped a little bit of weight and it will take a while to get his bearings again.”
Coach Luke Beveridge praised the performance of big man Jordon Sweet, who had 26 hit-outs and 13 disposals against the Pies, and said he would again shoulder the ruck duties against the Suns.

😳

Wow, very unlucky for those that held him.
 
Joined
15 Mar 2019
Messages
15,034
Likes
57,916
AFL Club
Hawthorn
From Bevo’s after match presser :-

RUCKMAN Tim English is set to miss another game with illness next week as the Western Bulldogs look to get on a winning run after their strong victory over Collingwood on Friday night.

The Dogs were too strong for the Magpies at Marvel Stadium, running out 48-point winners to take their season to 4-5 after last year’s Grand Final performance.

They will push to make it back-to-back wins for the first time since the finals last year with their clash against Gold Coast next week in Ballarat but are expecting to again be without their first-choice big man, who has been hit hard by the flu over the past week.

“I don’t think Tim will come back this week. I mentioned he’d been really ill and I mean really ill and so I don’t think he’ll be ready to play next week so ‘Sweety’ is likely to continue on,” Beveridge said post-game.

“Jarrod Witts got the 10 coaches votes last week and was really influential in the game against the Swans having studied them in the lead-up, so he’ll be a big challenge for Sweety but it’s likely to be a similar (ruck) set up as it was tonight.

“(English) just has a really, really bad bout of this flu. It’s just really knocked him around. Nothing sinister, we think he’ll be OK, but he’s probably dropped a little bit of weight and it will take a while to get his bearings again.”
Coach Luke Beveridge praised the performance of big man Jordon Sweet, who had 26 hit-outs and 13 disposals against the Pies, and said he would again shoulder the ruck duties against the Suns.

😳

Wow, very unlucky for those that held him.
***. :mad:
 
Joined
8 Jan 2020
Messages
6,262
Likes
26,153
AFL Club
Geelong
I think McRae is aware of Begg's limitations, but if you're not going to give him a run against Sweet/Cordy, then you may as well banish him to the VFL until next season. He's only 19!!!
Its blatantly obvious he should be in the VFL the guys attended 85 Ruck contests for 9 hitouts lol, doing nothing for a kids development when you are playing them when they clearly aren't ready.
 
Joined
9 Aug 2012
Messages
239
Likes
1,003
AFL Club
Adelaide
5/569
Baz, Macrae, Dunkley, Crisp, Cameron

Was hoping for more from Cameron but the role is very strong and cash gen real. DPP surely in a few weeks opens up option with Goldy so happy enough.

Only real worry (famous last words) is SDK and PMC on field in defence this week.

And of course the lottery of needing to choose a captain with Macrae VC not quite cutting it. Neale, Mills, Oliver, Gawn, Touk, Cripps all possible
 
Joined
9 Aug 2012
Messages
239
Likes
1,003
AFL Club
Adelaide
Maybe it's the toddler induced early morning wake up, but is anyone getting an itchy trigger finger on Cogs? Flicking him allows either Goldy to F5 and Preuss in to R2 or SDK swing to F6 and Lloyd/Vlaustin to D5.

I'm real late on Preuss but he looks good for 100+ each game particularly agaist the Blues with no real recognised ruck (I know TDK is a good prospect) and Flynn omitted

Is moving cogs on now ridiculous?
 
Last edited:
Joined
5 Feb 2014
Messages
384
Likes
1,292
AFL Club
Geelong
Maybe it's the toddler induced early morning wake up, but is anyone getting an itchy trigger finger on Cogs? Flicking him allows either Goldy to F5 and Preuss in to R2 or SDK swing to F6 and Lloyd/Vlaustin to D5.

I'm real late on Preuss but he looks good for 100+ each game particularly agaist the Blues with no real recognised ruck (I know TDK is a good prospect) and Flynn omitted

Is moving cogs on now ridiculous?
I ended up moving Cogs this week for Cameron. If you take out the 149 spike he’s only averaging 86 and I don’t see him being top 6 or even 8 on the fwd line
 
Joined
9 Aug 2012
Messages
239
Likes
1,003
AFL Club
Adelaide
I ended up moving Cogs this week for Cameron. If you take out the 149 spike he’s only averaging 86 and I don’t see him being top 6 or even 8 on the fwd line
That's where I'm leaning also. Just a question of Pruess or a D5 keeper
 
Top