Opinion 2022: Rookie Roulette

[jmack5]

M.Rioli or Hamilton on field?

Need to play one due to English out (again )

 

[Zimmer]

M.Rioli or Hamilton on field?

Need to play one due to English out (again )

Think I'd go Rioli against the Hawks... who knows what happens with GWS? There may be others with better knowledge of Hamilton though.

 

[Zimmer]

Preempting the round:

DEF: Daicos (69) or McCartin/SDK
MID: Mcomb, Clark
FWD: Rioli, McCartin, SDK (depending on def loop)
RK: Hayes S. (looped) potential to swing Jackson fwd.

Why do I make things so complicated?

Edit: Guess I take Daicos 69. Now to work out who to loop in the forwards out of Rioli, McCartin, SDK.

 

[Goodie's Guns]

Preempting the round:

DEF: Daicos (69) or McCartin/SDK
MID: Mcomb, Clark
FWD: Rioli, McCartin, SDK (depending on def loop)
RK: Hayes S. (looped) potential to swing Jackson fwd.

Why do I make things so complicated?

Edit: Guess I take Daicos 69. Now to work out who to loop in the forwards out of Rioli, McCartin, SDK.

I'd probably take Daicos I think, you might gain 20, but you might also be down 20.
So I reckon I'd probably just take it and enjoy having a calm weekend.

I don't quite understand the FWD predicament, but I think I would want to be potentially be able to access McCartin's score out of the three, he could get quite a few intercept marks against the Bombers I reckon.

 

[Zimmer]

I'd probably take Daicos I think, you might gain 20, but you might also be down 20.
So I reckon I'd probably just take it and enjoy having a calm weekend.

I don't quite understand the FWD predicament, but I think I would want to be potentially be able to access McCartin's score out of the three, he could get quite a few intercept marks against the Bombers I reckon.

Fwd predicament is, dependant on taking Daicons. I can swing have either SDK or McCartin forward. And Rioli could be looped. I was leaning toward McCartin. Though whether I bring in Rioli or not is something I'm pondering now. Not sure I should go Hamilton, or Carroll instead.

 

[Monya Meow Meow]

Surely I take the 69 from Daicos over Carroll or Hobbs right?

 

[Goodie's Guns]

Surely I take the 69 from Daicos over Carroll or Hobbs right?

Yes I would. At best you might miss out on 20 points, but the worst case could see you down 40 or more if things don't go well for the other two.

 

[Monya Meow Meow]

Yes I would. At best you might miss out on 20 points, but the worst case could see you down 40 or more if things don't go well for the other two.

I still have nightmares of Hobbs getting me 13 the week I chose to play him...

 

[Darkie]

Surely I take the 69 from Daicos over Carroll or Hobbs right?

I would.

 

[Rumbler]

McComb (E) didn't work out with only 41.
I can field Hobbs or Rioli BUT I will lose my chance at the VC loophole and will need to put the C on someone directly.

If I want to use the VC option, I will need to take McComb's score which is well under par.
Really not sure what to do. Need some advice please

 

[James4]

Carroll vs Hobbs

Playing GWS and Sydney respectively. Both away.

 

[Zimmer]

McComb (E) didn't work out with only 41.
I can field Hobbs or Rioli BUT I will lose my chance at the VC loophole and will need to put the C on someone directly.

If I want to use the VC option, I will need to take McComb's score which is well under par.
Really not sure what to do. Need some advice please

Who/what was your VC/score?

 

[Rumbler]

Who/what was your VC/score?

Haven't used the VC yet! But was planning to put it on Neale.

 

[big fella]

should i take the daicos 69, or instead who best to field out of rioli and Caroll

 

[Darkie]

Carroll vs Hobbs

Playing GWS and Sydney respectively. Both away.

Tough one. I would probably back whoever you expect to have the better role. If unsure, I’d go Carroll.

 

[Darkie]

should i take the daicos 69, or instead who best to field out of rioli and Caroll

I would take the 69.

 

[Zimmer]

Haven't used the VC yet! But was planning to put it on Neale.

View attachment 44048

If Neale goes super large then perhaps McComb's subpar score won't matter that much.

If Owens is your donut for Neale VC, doesn't Owens play first? Or am I missing something. Sorry if so.

 

[Maccas marvels]

who to field…

SDK versus saints or
P Mcartin versus the bombers?

 

[Rumbler]

If Neale goes super large then perhaps McComb's subpar score won't matter that much.

If Owens is your donut for Neale VC, doesn't Owens play first? Or am I missing something. Sorry if so.

Sorry, yea completely missed that. I guess I'll need to put the C straight on someone. For some reason I thought the St.Kilda game was tomorrow.
Thanks

 

[Zimmer]

who to field…

SDK versus saints or
P Mcartin versus the bombers?

I’m going McCartin. Always close games, lots of I50s to have a crack at. Both seem to be fairly reliable now.