Discussion 2022 Round 10: Teams & In Game Discussion

[Meltingpot38]

The Cogs decision is killing me.
Have been aggressive with trades this year and currently sit inside the top 1000.
Want Oliver and/or RD 14 bye players as RD13 is the worst for me.
Thinking one of the following:

1. Cogs, SDK to Oliver & Rookie
2. Cogs, CMcDonald to Zorko & rookie
3. Hold and hope Cogs goes ok

Great discussion around Cogs but personally he was always a stepping step to a top 6-8 forward or mid, and with a BE of 146 I'm using him to get Oliver who I've been missing. As mentioned I'm sure will burn us sometimes with a big score, but a top 6 mid? Don't think so personally.
Brodie on the other hand, could end up being a nice F6.

FWIW I'd go with option 1.

 

[pizza safety]

I feel like Horse has always tagged Cripps, they’ve only tagged Touk and Danger this year to my knowledge with Rowbottom who is out. I think Warner has tagged before as well, is he a tag risk or not?

Tossing up who to pair with Clarry this week, Macrae is hard to vc because I won’t know his scaling before Oliver, Shiels half likely to come in and tag Neale

I probably will to do Oliver into Neale, even with a tag Neale Will likely tonne up, I want to get Clarry’s upside as VC and will take 120+

 

[stephen]

I feel like Horse has always tagged Cripps, they’ve only tagged Touk and Danger this year to my knowledge with Rowbottom who is out. I think Warner has tagged before as well, is he a tag risk or not?

Tossing up who to pair with Clarry this week, Macrae is hard to vc because I won’t know his scaling before Oliver, Shiels half likely to come in and tag Neale

Macrae averages silly numbers at Mars and against GC. I wouldn't worry about scaling. You'll know one way or the other. (although it's always more fun to VC on a friday night, I can't deny)

 

[pizza safety]

Macrae averages silly numbers at Mars and against GC. I wouldn't worry about scaling. You'll know one way or the other. (although it's always more fun to VC on a friday night, I can't deny)

You could be right and I just don’t enjoy the quick turnaround, he was average vs crows at Mars but that’s an anomaly

Neale should go very well against the Hawks but there’s a 50/50 chance Shiels comes in and tags him. If he’s not tagged he probably scores 130+ and if he is around 110, Hawks ranked 16th vs mids

definitely favouring these two over Cripps

 

[pizza safety]

Macrae averages silly numbers at Mars and against GC. I wouldn't worry about scaling. You'll know one way or the other. (although it's always more fun to VC on a friday night, I can't deny)

I am quite tempted to at least VC Oliver otherwise Macrae would be an easier choice. When Clarry goes massive it tends to be against poor midfield opponents

Edit: I have decided if Shiels is in I’ll go Macrae if not I’ll go Neale

 

[Chumpion]

You could be right and I just don’t enjoy the quick turnaround, he was average vs crows at Mars but that’s an anomaly

Neale should go very well against the Hawks but there’s a 50/50 chance Shiels comes in and tags him. If he’s not tagged he probably scores 130+ and if he is around 110, Hawks ranked 16th vs mids

definitely favouring these two over Cripps

Pretty sure Nash tagged Oliver super effectively for a lot of the Hawks vs Demons game before moving over to Trac so there is a risk there if they decide to send him to Neale.

I also have a hazy recollection that Simpkin has done some jobs this season and he's back this week so could go to Oliver or Trac, however he played vs the blues and freo and both Cripps and Brayshaw went 130+ so probably less risk that I thought.

 

[stephen]

I am quite tempted to at least VC Oliver otherwise Macrae would be an easier choice. When Clarry goes massive it tends to be against poor midfield opponents

Edit: I have decided if Shiels is in I’ll go Macrae if not I’ll go Neale

I've already realised I can't resist the tide of a Friday night VC. Go well on debut, VC Sam Walsh

 

[inwhiterooms]

Marscrae VC into new boy Laird C for me.

 

[jaca]

I’m holding Cogs for now but will happily shift him if I need to unlock cash over the byes.

 

[Deeman1]

I’m holding Cogs for now but will happily shift him if I need to unlock cash over the byes.

Yeah I'm much the same, with Whitfield and Ridley out I have to turf one of them, so Coniglio survives for now. If Ridley was not out I would have held Whitfield, but something has to give.

 

[inwhiterooms]

The Cogs decision is killing me.
Have been aggressive with trades this year and currently sit inside the top 1000.
Want Oliver and/or RD 14 bye players as RD13 is the worst for me.
Thinking one of the following:

1. Cogs, SDK to Oliver & Rookie
2. Cogs, CMcDonald to Zorko & rookie
3. Hold and hope Cogs goes ok

I'd go option 1 there, stay aggressive and get a ripping premium in Oliver. You're in a great spot and Cogs has more than done his job for you.

 

[AngryAnt]

Really hoping that Jacob Wehr cements a spot, perfect round for him to be debuting in, McCartin down to him in round 13 is definitely on the cards.

 

[Montyjnr]

Really hoping that Jacob Wehr cements a spot, perfect round for him to be debuting in, McCartin down to him in round 13 is definitely on the cards.

We might even need to go early on him next week given the lack of rookies!

 

[AngryAnt]

We might even need to go early on him next week given the lack of rookies!

Let's see how Cleary goes this week, he looked pretty decent last week. I've barely got 18 playing in round 13 so a downgrade to a round 12 rookie for cash and an upgrade to a round 12 premo that round (targeting Docherty) would be excellent.

 

[Socrates2]

I'm very nervous to have Rosas, M.Rioli, DeKoning and P.McCartin as on field rookies this week.

 

[KLo30]

Sunday, May 22
Greater Western Sydney v West Coast at Giants Stadium, 2.10pm AEST

GREATER WESTERN SYDNEY

In: Z.Sproule, J.Hogan, J.Brander, T.Bruhn, J.Peatling, J.Wehr
Out: L.Keeffe (omitted), C.Hamilton (omitted), M.de Boer (omitted), N.Haynes (illness), C.Stone (hamstring), L.Whitfield (ankle), F.Callaghan (shoulder)

Last week's sub: Bobby Hill (unused)

WEST COAST

In: A.Gaff, L.Shuey
Out: L.Ryan (suspension), L.Foley (concussion), S.Petrevski-Seton (HS Protocol)

Last week's sub: Patrick Naish (replaced L.Ryan)

Hawthorn v Brisbane at UTAS Stadium, 3.20pm AEST

HAWTHORN

In: D.Howe, T.Mitchell, C.Jiath
Out: F.Maginness (omitted), J.Gunston (ankle), C.Macdonald (Medi-Sub), J.Worpel (omitted)

Last week's sub: Connor MacDonald (replaced J. Gunston)

BRISBANE

In: T.Fullarton
Out: M.Adams (HS protocol), R.Lester (personal), T.Berry (medi-sub)

Last week's sub: Thomas Berry (unused)

Fremantle v Collingwood at Optus Stadium, 3.20pm AWST

FREMANTLE

In: M.Taberner, M.Walters, S.Switkowski
Out: D.Tucker (omitted), J.Treacy (omitted), N.Erasmus (omitted), B.Walker (omitted)

Last week's sub: Brandon Walker (unused)

COLLINGWOOD

In: S.Pendlebury, M.Cox, J.Elliott, J.Ginnivan, N.Murphy
Out: A.Begg (omitted), O.Henry (omitted), C.Brown (omitted), C.Poulter (omitted), J.Madgen (shoulder), F.Macrae (Medi-Sub)

Last week's sub: Finlay Macrae (replaced J. Madgen)

 

[AngryAnt]

I'm very nervous to have Rosas, M.Rioli, DeKoning and P.McCartin as on field rookies this week.

McCartin has been very good since he came back from his week off.

 

[Connoisseur]

https://twitter.com/i/web/status/1527532827130093568

 

[OnTopBar]

I'm very nervous to have Rosas, M.Rioli, DeKoning and P.McCartin as on field rookies this week.

You should be!

 

[PC]

Dixon is out it seems?

(wish HS updated the app in a timely manner!)