Agars effort last night has me seriously considering taking the c off of Clarke for Short, Lynn or perma captain RK19.
Agar is already 89 ahead of any of those 3.
Lyn is a pure batsman so one mistake and he's gone, so he would be out of the reckoning IMO.
Short is a bit the same, facing Sams/Farooqi/Doggett/Green early would be enough to sway me away from him IMO.
Rashid is probably the only one I would consider, but unless you see him getting 3 or 3+ wickets he is still along way behind Agar.
No guts no glory, I guess, so its your call, but I the type of player I am would lead me to just take the 89 (as disappointing as it might be compared to JRicho).