Discussion 2025: AFL RDT Dream Team Discussion

Joined
25 Jul 2012
Messages
49,509
Likes
113,001
AFL Club
Collingwood
Quick throw together

Dawson , Daicos , Yeo , Coffield , Cole , Jones / McKenna , Wilmot

Laird , Andrew Brayshaw , Miller , Macrae , Mitchell , Hopper , Ashcroft , Phillips / Sinn * , Blakely , Chesser *

Grundy , Lycett / Madden *

Dunkley * , Rozee * , D Cameron * , Allen , McLean * , B King / Bruce , van Rooyen

Bank $ 24,600.00
 
Joined
25 Feb 2019
Messages
9,089
Likes
14,951
AFL Club
Hawthorn
Same as SuperCoach, price doesn’t go up until the 3rd game is played. Whereas AFL Fantasy prices go up as soon as
AFL Fantasy is my least favourite out of the three, for a few reasons, how it’s set out, prices changing after playing one game and 2 trades every week, l love trading, but there should be a season limit
 
Last edited:
Joined
12 Jan 2014
Messages
3,903
Likes
12,349
AFL Club
West Coast
AFL Fantasy is my least favourite out of the three, for a few reasons, how it’s set out, prices changing after playing one game and 2 trades every week, l love trading, but there should be a season limit
I also thought one of the fundamental scoring differences was that SC puts scoring weight on what players do with the ball ie effective kicking. Whereas Fantasy just recorded a kick as a kick with no difference whether it hit a target or not. Which was why SC scores for first and second year players are often lower because they often have not yet developed the ball skills.

Is the scoring not like that anymore? It often made some high possession, but low skilled players more valuable in Fantasy than SC.
 
Joined
25 Jul 2012
Messages
49,509
Likes
113,001
AFL Club
Collingwood
I also thought one of the fundamental scoring differences was that SC puts scoring weight on what players do with the ball ie effective kicking. Whereas Fantasy just recorded a kick as a kick with no difference whether it hit a target or not. Which was why SC scores for first and second year players are often lower because they often have not yet developed the ball skills.

Is the scoring not like that anymore? It often made some high possession, but low skilled players more valuable in Fantasy than SC.
Basically it just gives points for the actions and doesn't take into account impact or influence at all , so less subjective.

A premium mid like Laird & a first year player get 10 kicks they score the same points (in simple terms).

No grey areas

No 3300 points per game limit either , no scaling.

What you do , you get rewarded (or penalised) for it.
 
Top