2023: SC Planning Thread

[Wheedus]

Moneyball has an article, but I’ve made a better spread sheet.

which teams you looking at?

Give me a list of captain clubs and I’ll have a look for you.

All good. Your 22 Feb post above gives me exactly what I needed. Cheers mate

 

[Shannon]

With more trades available contingency for premiums is less important.
Captain loophole value is more important to me than backup ruck points.
Therefore my option is to trade them out or wear a donut.

This

 

[randomcliche]

All good. Your 22 Feb post above gives me exactly what I needed. Cheers mate

If Chesser is not named rnd 1 for whatever reason - a brilliant floating donut to play.

 

[Shannon]

Surely he plays round 1 after that preseason game …

 

[Wheedus]

If Chesser is not named rnd 1 for whatever reason - a brilliant floating donut to play.

True, although I was looking at $102k priced players. Gilbee looks to be the best option there. Chesser definitely the better play if you're punting on some games down the track. WC play second up in Rd 6, 8 and 9 which is not ideal but no doubt other donuts will emerge in our lists by then

 

[randomcliche]

FYI - with Oliver falling out of a few teams, the Laird Bont VC/C combo into WC donut (rnds 2-8) or GWS donut (rnds 1-11 excl rnd 7 [VC Dunkley or Neale]) works a treat.

 

[randomcliche]

True, although I was looking at $102k priced players. Gilbee looks to be the best option there. Chesser definitely the better play if you're punting on some games down the track. WC play second up in Rd 6, 8 and 9 which is not ideal but no doubt other donuts will emerge in our lists by then

Absolutely we'll need to buy another floating donut by rnd 9!
Round 6, Dogs play first - VC Bont/Macrae
Round 8, Brisbane Carlton play first - VC Dunks, Neale, Cripps
Round 9, is a bit of stretch with Richmond Geelong up first. I hope to have the problem of no new donuts by round 9 #nailingmyrookies.

Gilbee is a popular choice for good reasons if running E-saver at R3. Allows you to optimise many rookies across Def/Mids.

 

[Wheedus]

View attachment 53398


Surely he plays round 1 after that preseason game …

A bit of chaos never hurt anyone....

 

[randomcliche]

Also just figured I can use the spreadsheet to calculate rookie loopholing potential. E.g Gilbee allows Baker (Dogs) and McKenzie (Hawks) to loophole for the first 6 rounds.

Or can allow Brisbane (couple of options) Carlton (Cowan etc) to loop rounds 1-5 with the popular defence rookies.

Good choice!

 

[donnybuang]

Moneyball has an article, but I’ve made a better spread sheet.

which teams you looking at?

Thanks, but I mean I'm usually busy during that time and often won't check SC scores

 

[Shannon]

Biggest ownership drops post preseason games :-

-11.2% Nick Daicos
-10.9% Toby McLean
-10.2% Josh Weddle
-7.6% Jack Steele
-7.4% Josh Sinn
-7.3% Stephen Coniglio
-7.1% Matthew Johnson
-6.9% Jacob van Rooyen

 

[Shaunpro1]

I just dont see Sav as some Ruck saviour that you must pick as cover, floor will be genuinely woeful and isn't even gauranteed to be best 22 long term.

 

[TopBillings]

I just dont see Sav as some Ruck saviour that you must pick as cover, floor will be genuinely woeful and isn't even gauranteed to be best 22 long term.

170k a bit steep for a bloke with average JS

 

[donnybuang]

Biggest ownership drops post preseason games :-

-11.2% Nick Daicos
-10.9% Toby McLean
-10.2% Josh Weddle
-7.6% Jack Steele
-7.4% Josh Sinn
-7.3% Stephen Coniglio
-7.1% Matthew Johnson
-6.9% Jacob van Rooyen

Wow, couple of serious over reactions there.

 

[Shaunpro1]

170k a bit steep for a bloke with average JS

People seem to forget that we played 8 games without Henry last year and didnt bring in another key defender for any of them, this notion that it suddenly makes Sav a lock to play every week I find baffling.

 

[Professor]

https://twitter.com/i/web/status/1632624139407351809

View: https://mobile.twitter.com/SCMates/status/1632624139407351809

 

[frosty1]

https://twitter.com/i/web/status/1632624139407351809

View: https://mobile.twitter.com/SCMates/status/1632624139407351809

Surely gives Comben or similar more JS? Not sure that anyone is going to play their 18yo debutante small forward in a Key Forward role?

 

[Ben's Beasts]

Don’t know about anybody else but I’m really liking that with several iterations of my team, a 50/50 call will be made by whether Carlton select one first year player over the other 😆

Also, how good is it that the Blues play the first match of the round for this reason.

 

[Shannon]

Don’t know about anybody else but I’m really liking that with several iterations of my team, a 50/50 call will be made by whether Carlton select one first year player over the other 😆

Also, how good is it that the Blues play the first match of the round for this reason.

Yep, who would of though that Cincotta would be so vital to the preferred structure of many including myself

 

[Leroy]

Don’t know about anybody else but I’m really liking that with several iterations of my team, a 50/50 call will be made by whether Carlton select one first year player over the other 😆

Also, how good is it that the Blues play the first match of the round for this reason.

Yep, who would of though that Cincotta would be so vital to the preferred structure of many including myself

I'm gearing up for a big Saturday morning shuffle after seeing what happens in those first 2 games

Probably the main call before then is whether to pay up for Esava at R3 to generate some extra coin. $70k invested on the bench to make maybe $80k in time for DPPs? Borderline useful