Discussion 2023: Rate My Team

Joined
14 Jan 2023
Messages
45
Likes
87
AFL Club
Collingwood
- Still tossing up between Stewart and Dawson
- Really like Callaghan but can't find a way to bring him in without feeling unsure about it. Plus think Mackenzie and Phillips are fine to start on field
- Have toyed with Bruhn but not really convinced on him, think Sheezel at the discount is every chance to score as well.
- Have got cold feet on the $700k mids, backing in guys who I think are value. Looks odds having 2 WBD mids and 2 GWS mids but don't really see that as a concern.


View attachment 53853
This draft is reassuring. Before the Yeo news the only premium we didn't share was Gulden (Macrae and Marshall have left my team as part of a reshuffle).

Clearly I rate this draft.
 
Joined
14 Jan 2023
Messages
45
Likes
87
AFL Club
Collingwood
No interest in Sheezel?
I haven't come across anything compelling for Sheezel. I could be wrong but didn't he score most of his points as a HB (which has to be a one-off)?

I'm not fully across all the rookies but surely you prefer the potential score spikes in Allen at a similar price?
 
Joined
20 Mar 2016
Messages
1,397
Likes
4,836
I haven't come across anything compelling for Sheezel. I could be wrong but didn't he score most of his points as a HB (which has to be a one-off)?

I'm not fully across all the rookies but surely you prefer the potential score spikes in Allen at a similar price?
Why does the HB role have to be a one-off?
 
Joined
13 Mar 2012
Messages
2,790
Likes
2,985
AFL Club
Adelaide
I haven't come across anything compelling for Sheezel. I could be wrong but didn't he score most of his points as a HB (which has to be a one-off)?

I'm not fully across all the rookies but surely you prefer the potential score spikes in Allen at a similar price?
I was preferring Allen but the DT talk guys and other media are calling Sheezel a must have and to start on field
 
Joined
14 Jul 2020
Messages
1,192
Likes
2,132
AFL Club
Collingwood
Screenshot_20230315_200420_SuperCoach.jpg Screenshot_20230315_200428_SuperCoach.jpg
Hey all,
as its probably the last chance i will have to update my team until tomorrow night, by then it will be too late to post a rate my team

What is the thoughts on this?
Any areas apart from Darcy Cameron i need to improve?
 
Joined
13 Jun 2022
Messages
5,228
Likes
17,245
AFL Club
St Kilda
View attachment 53875 View attachment 53876
Hey all,
as its probably the last chance i will have to update my team until tomorrow night, by then it will be too late to post a rate my team

What is the thoughts on this?
Any areas apart from Darcy Cameron i need to improve?
Hold on I'll just stand back 50 feet so I can read it ;)
Looks alright to me but I'd probably put Davey where Drury is...or is Drury your Donut boy?
 
Joined
10 Jan 2020
Messages
510
Likes
1,721
AFL Club
Richmond
Settled on GnR structure after the Yeo news. Gulden is probably the only gun that doesn't have high-scoring history, but plenty of bail out options if needed.
Risky down back, but Gillbee will be handy for looping off the bench.
Would appreciate any thoughts in case I've missed something obvious.
Screenshot_2023-03-15-20-18-22-83_f9537d3117b147e48f5e2aeb5429cc0b.jpg Screenshot_2023-03-15-20-18-22-83_f9537d3117b147e48f5e2aeb5429cc0b.jpg Screenshot_2023-03-15-20-18-36-98_f9537d3117b147e48f5e2aeb5429cc0b.jpg
 
Joined
27 Jan 2014
Messages
6,769
Likes
14,766
AFL Club
Fremantle
View attachment 53875 View attachment 53876
Hey all,
as its probably the last chance i will have to update my team until tomorrow night, by then it will be too late to post a rate my team

What is the thoughts on this?
Any areas apart from Darcy Cameron i need to improve?
Minns and Perrottet for the captains loophole? But they play at the same time.
 

Connoisseur

Leadership Group
Joined
3 Jul 2017
Messages
38,961
Likes
126,629
AFL Club
Port Adelaide
Post preseason lineup. Can make some nice upgrades by downgrading Ziebell to Sheezel.

View attachment 53352
Post Rich VS Carl squads announcement:
8976C10C-D1C7-42CD-BD86-F8B4BDD0AFDB.jpeg
Yeo down to H Clark. Yeo and Bowes have occupied D3 or D4 in most iterations but not in the above. Could use dpp to bring him in or Yeo (later on) if required via Philippou and Constable. Preference has been to go five deep in the midfield with Macrae/Brayshaw/etc but playing around with Rozee at F2 and Callaghan at M6. Rozee, Ziebell and Callaghan could be replaced by Macrae, Flanders and O Allen or even Sheezel and Rat down to two $123,900 rookies to allow Callaghan and Rozee to Macrae and Flanders.
 
Joined
14 Jul 2020
Messages
1,192
Likes
2,132
AFL Club
Collingwood
Hold on I'll just stand back 50 feet so I can read it ;)
Looks alright to me but I'd probably put Davey where Drury is...or is Drury your Donut boy?
Haha my bad, didn't expect it to be that large of a post

Drury could be my donut boy but atm most of the rookies in that price range are just place holders u till i have 99% playing THEN ill find a donut boy
 
Joined
25 Jul 2012
Messages
47,728
Likes
107,810
AFL Club
Collingwood
No doubt it will change again when teams drop

DOCHERTY (VC) , Cumming , RIOLI , Jones , Cole , Constable * / COWAN , McKenna (?)

Bont , CRIPPS , Green , Gulden * , HOPPER , Ashcroft , Mackenzie , Ginbey * / HOLLANDS, Phillips , Chesser *

Darcy , Marshall / Madden *

Dunkley * , TARANTO * , Rozee * , Ziebell , Fyfe * , McLean * / Ratugolea * , Greene

$ 29,000.00 to play with
 
Joined
24 Jan 2016
Messages
4,380
Likes
18,390
Team post #4 and before someone gets ruled out tomorrow.

Probably a bit standard-ish to the template that is going to come out now that the Yeo news has broken. However SC isn't won or lost on day 1 so there's 36 chances to mix it up throughout the season.

Good luck to all. Can't wait for the season to kick off tomorrow night with the traditional fixture.

Screenshot_20230315-205932_SuperCoach.jpg Screenshot_20230315-205947_SuperCoach.jpg
 

KLo30

Leadership Group
Joined
27 Jan 2014
Messages
18,104
Likes
52,784
AFL Club
North Melb.
Took some of @Under The Dome's suggestions and have my second draft. I have under $100K in the bank ($81,800) though and from what I understand, the more you have leftover, the better.
Humphrey won't play, so I'd look to Chesser or Baker. King down to Greene in the FWDs. That will give you another $110K to play with. Ruck Philliips won't play, so use the cash to upgrade there. You should be able to get Marshall, now.

Having some cash on hand is useful if you need to make correction trades or upgrade early. This is on the proviso you are happy with your team, otherwise spend until you are happy.
 
Top