Strategy 2023: Round 3 Trades

Joined
15 Jan 2018
Messages
1,973
Likes
5,007
AFL Club
Richmond
Flanders to chandler
Darcy to D Cameron
L Jones to daicos
Or
Flanders to Ziebell
Darcy to English
Doc to Daicos
Would love some feedback on this one i cant decide. I feel bad trading out Doc but i get some good ins in doing so.
 
Joined
27 Mar 2015
Messages
4,906
Likes
5,442
AFL Club
Carlton
I feel chandler has 1 or 2 quiet games and he gets dropped. Adj job security is pretty good. Both important but bot must haves.
Thanks mate. Think it ultimately depends on who I trade out. Was only able to trade in 1 with the trades I had planned, but Ridley playing a lockdown today has maybe allowed me to go

Ridley > Daicos
Chesser/Baker >ADJ
Greene > Chandler

Had planned Jones, Darcy, and Greene for Daicos, DC, and Chandler.

Darcy may survive the cull
 

Darkie

Leadership Group
Joined
12 Apr 2014
Messages
25,401
Likes
65,467
AFL Club
Collingwood
I very rarely trade out premiums early on in the season, but I think he has to go. There are two things that lead me to this. Obviously Bevo moving him to the forward line after the first quarter is worrying (especially as I felt he was there best mid at the time). I think Macrae went back into the midfield in the last quarter but was too late by then. Also, to the naked eye, Macrae just looks like he is struggling to cover ground. Looks tired, and a step behind getting to the spots you would like him to get too. I have him and I'm 95% sure I'm trading him.
Very interesting, thank you. I think I just replied to your post about Bevo in another thread 🙂

Macrae seems like the type that we should back in, but as I mentioned elsewhere, Macrae didn’t look himself at times last night. I wonder if he’s either not quite fit, or maybe underwhelmed at the prospect of being played out of position.

I’m happy that Bont wasn’t first choice to go forward given that I also own him, but I would have thought that Bont and Libba would both be better choices to play forward.
 
Joined
15 Jan 2018
Messages
1,973
Likes
5,007
AFL Club
Richmond
Thanks mate. Think it ultimately depends on who I trade out. Was only able to trade in 1 with the trades I had planned, but Ridley playing a lockdown today has maybe allowed me to go

Ridley > Daicos
Chesser/Baker >ADJ
Greene > Chandler

Had planned Jones, Darcy, and Greene for Daicos, DC, and Chandler.

Darcy may survive the cull
After watching darcy last night his first on the chopping block
 
Joined
5 Feb 2014
Messages
1,354
Likes
6,817
AFL Club
Carlton
Flanders > Chandler

That's about all I've worked out. Would have enough for Hopper > Daicos if Hopper was out for any time. Would prefer Hopper is fine but that seems my only way to get Daicos nicely with two trades.
 
Joined
9 Mar 2014
Messages
4,259
Likes
7,602
AFL Club
Port Adelaide
Flanders to chandler
Darcy to D Cameron
L Jones to daicos
Or
Flanders to Ziebell
Darcy to English
Doc to Daicos
Would love some feedback on this one i cant decide. I feel bad trading out Doc but i get some good ins in doing so.
Prefer the second option but Chandler is a must for cash generation first imo.
 
Joined
2 Mar 2014
Messages
588
Likes
2,041
AFL Club
Essendon
Number of options under consideration for 3rd round:

Bruhn/Ridley/Doc > Daicos
Allen/Greene> Chandler
Darcy > Cameron

or Bruhn > Daicos
Greene/Baker > Chandler
Allen > Ziebel sit on Darcy

or Bruhn > LDU and Ridley/Doc > Daicos and Greene/Baker/Allen to Chandler sit on Darcy.

  • LDU been on edge of breakout for a while and looks like it has come together this year. Upside is 115+ with min downside
  • Daicos is just better than I expected for a 2nd year player.
  • Chandler is cash grab over a slow burn.
  • Darcy looking ominous for failure with Jackson in the team. Might have to wait for Round 4 and see what cost is to trade Darcy.
my trades this week were Jones > Young, Ash to Callaghan and Kelly to Sheezel. 214K itb.
 
Joined
23 Mar 2014
Messages
6,389
Likes
17,516
AFL Club
Hawthorn
Flanders to chandler
Darcy to D Cameron
L Jones to daicos
Or
Flanders to Ziebell
Darcy to English
Doc to Daicos
Would love some feedback on this one i cant decide. I feel bad trading out Doc but i get some good ins in doing so.
Would go with option 2 mate….
Gets you top defender and top ruck plus Ziebell who could be top 8 forward at this rate….

would try and keep Doc if you can but understand it gives you 100k to spend elsewhere
 
Top