Yep, has to be Cincotta or Plowman this week IMO. Both good VFL form. I know many Carlton supporters are anti-Plowman but I'd lean him. First game so we'll know!
Playing the advocate here, but if Doc is only out 4, then you get 2x price cycles out of Cincotta before he's out the door again if not performing well.
Then again, what other defender rookies are then on the horizon we can take a gamble on?