Discussion 2023 Round 5: Team & In Game Discussion

[KLo30]

Think I'm the only one with Menzies in my team. Has made 70K. High of 74 last week. BE of 6.

Still more money to make, but is it worth going to JVR who, although has JS risk, looks very tempting?

Not in place of Menzies. If you have an underperformer then do the trade. Maybe some DPP magic for the round.

 

[mike89]

https://twitter.com/i/web/status/1647060336556789760

View: https://twitter.com/AFL/status/1647060336556789760?s=20

Let's play "how many subs were offloaded by Gold Coast" this weekend. That's at least 3 so far...

 

[THCLT]

Make or break day, 12 players involved today.

I must be broken already with 14 on-field plus Wilmot & JVR on the bench.

 

[7/11]

You know what to do Mackenzie owners

https://twitter.com/i/web/status/1646696310425403394

Honestly not sure what to do with Mackenzie at this point. If he wasn’t sub, I’d not have a care in the world!

 

[Old Big 'Ead]

Think I'm the only one with Menzies in my team. Has made 70K. High of 74 last week. BE of 6.

Still more money to make, but is it worth going to JVR who, although has JS risk, looks very tempting?

He'll make you another 30+k. Definitely keep IMO. Wish I had have chosen instead of Greene.

 

[Zimmer]

Not in place of Menzies. If you have an underperformer then do the trade. Maybe some DPP magic for the round.

Could swing Rozee into the mids, Davey into forwards and trade Davey to JVR.

This would allow me Stewart rather than Dale (in a straight trade), or Dale and more cash for Dawson.

 

[KLo30]

Could swing Rozee into the mids, Davey into forwards and trade Davey to JVR.

This would allow me Stewart rather than Dale (in a straight trade), or Dale and more cash.

I wouldn't trade Davey. He has a BE -1. Just having a rest this week and will be back to make more money.

The Bytels, MacKenzies, Cheesers, etc would be worthwhile.

JVR is a nice have not a must have.

 

[AngryAnt]

Hoping for another Sheezel ton, don't think that would have ever been done before, five tons in the first five games. Not sure if four has even been done.

 

[FirstTimer]

Who would people play on field Greene , JVR , Bruce and the E ?????

 

[Old Big 'Ead]

Could swing Rozee into the mids, Davey into forwards and trade Davey to JVR.

This would allow me Stewart rather than Dale (in a straight trade), or Dale and more cash for Dawson.

Do you want to get Stewart yet? Has he bottomed out in price? Depends if you think getting him this week with the score he'll make this week is worth it.

He is definitely better than Dale, just have to decide whether you will be okay with others getting him cheaper.

 

[Zimmer]

I wouldn't trade Davey. He has a BE -1. Just having a rest this week and will be back to make more money.

The Bytels, MacKenzies, Cheesers, etc would be worthwhile.

JVR is a nice have not a must have.

Only other option is Greene - will probably hold. Dale has been sitting as option all week, but could go Redman et al. Not sure Redman will keep his scoring up with the run Essendon has - went 49 in the loss against the Saints.

 

[OnTopBar]

Do you want to get Stewart yet? Has he bottomed out in price? Depends if you think getting him this week with the score he'll make this week is worth it.

He is definitely better than Dale, just have to decide whether you will be okay with others getting him cheaper.

Stewart has a BE of 69

 

[Old Big 'Ead]

Stewart has a BE of 69

Oh, I never saw that!

Still think he'll come down again though when the 160+ drops out of his moving average. Depends on how he goes this week I
guess

But hey, don't listen to me.... lol

 

[Maccas marvels]

Think I'm the only one with Menzies in my team. Has made 70K. High of 74 last week. BE of 6.

Still more money to make, but is it worth going to JVR who, although has JS risk, looks very tempting?

Would keep Menzies as he seems in best 22 and strong Job security…
is there another avenue you could use to bring in JVR?

 

[Zimmer]

Would keep Menzies as he seems in best 22 and strong Job security…
is there another avenue you could use to bring in JVR?

Only really Greene.

 

[AngryAnt]

Only really Greene.

How about Mackenzie?

 

[Maccas marvels]

View attachment 55606

Honestly not sure what to do with Mackenzie at this point. If he wasn’t sub, I’d not have a care in the world!

Still makes money this week but it will slow his cash growth…
im thinking of keeping him this week…
then next week flip him to roberts for 130-140k cash

 

[Zimmer]

How about Mackenzie?

No avenue to him for JVR.

Edit: oh hang on, Mackenzie out, Rozee mids, JVR forward!

 

[Maccas marvels]

Only really Greene.

McKenzie could be the move if you have him…

think Menzie has better scoring potential compared to Greene… both still got money to make

 

[Tamuhawk]

Big afternoon game!

McKenna, Wilmot, Ashcroft (E), Dunkley, LDU, Ziebell & Sheezel. Let's go!