Discussion 2023 Round 5: Team & In Game Discussion

[Under The Dome]

15/1575 English

McKenna, Michalanney, Wilmot
Bontempelli, Rozee, Setterfield, Hopper, Ashcroft
English(VC)
Dunkley, Taranto, Gulden, Ziebell, Sheezel, Chandler

Left to play:
Daicos, Buckley, Ginbey
Kelly, Green, Coniglio
Marshall

 

[NT.Thunder]

Non English owner here, but watching game last night looked like a 150 plus game from English. I think he was a bit ripped off, totally dominated.

I thought that initially, looked tired in the last though. I was maybe going to bring him in when the Grundy experiment finished but now not so sure. I know as soon as I do he'll go down.

After Port subbed Lycett I expected a 150+ game so was somewhat relieved to be close to within 10 points of his score. Incredible start to the year though

 

[NT.Thunder]

Grundy owners, look away. Exert from the HS.

Melbourne is optimistic captain Max Gawn will return for its ANZAC Day eve clash against Richmond as Demons coach Simon Goodwin described his sides’ loss to Essendon as “not us”.

Any numbers on Gawns price with his 0 rolling through? Maybe a straight swap with Grundy on the merry go around ruck line.

 

[THCLT]

Any numbers on Gawns price with his 0 rolling through? Maybe a straight swap with Grundy on the merry go around ruck line.

Let's say he goes 110/110, then his price will be approx. $524,800 with a BE of 86 going into his 3rd game after his return.

 

[Zagbag]

1739 / 16 + C Oliver

Couldn’t get a loop to work without taking Cowan’s 42, so was unable to take Darcy’s VC. Still worked out given Wilmot trounced Cowan.

Doesn’t feel too bad. Reckon Marshall goes big, and Green massacres hawks today…

 

[FirstTimer]

Final Quarter Scores ( Fully Scaled )
Round 5 2023

 

[FirstTimer]

Final Quarter Scores ( Fully Scaled )
Round 5 2023

 

[7/11]

18/1801

At a loss as to whether I lock in Oliver’s 115 or roll the dice on Green, Daicos or Marshall. Ginbey the other to come.

Are you already locking in a decent E score to loop it in? Or just using madden to get Marshall’s score?

I’d probably lock it in. Don’t see Daicos getting zero attention from the saints.

Marshall might have a strong game, but we thought that last week against Moyle and he was subbed. Was only on track for about 115-125 anyway.

Green is the interesting one as he could go nuts against Hawthorn but has scored over 115 less than 10 times ever.

 

[Maccas marvels]

How many other Grundy owners are a tad nervous going into this week?
Surely Gawn is not needed this week against the Tigers in the ruck?

Wouldn’t it throw the cat amongst the pigeons if he is named and plays?
helps that the game is on Monday too…giving Gawn a few extra days to get up

 

[Darkie]

Did Lycett have some sort of a knock or niggle? Seems a strange tactical sub choice.

 

[THCLT]

Did Lycett have some sort of a knock or niggle? Seems a strange tactical sub choice.

No heart is what I'm hearing...

 

[NT.Thunder]

Did Lycett have some sort of a knock or niggle? Seems a strange tactical sub choice.

They said it was a tactical sub with the rain to get more run. I guess they ran over the top of the Dogs in the last so you can't really knock it on paper.

 

[jel]

Grundy owners, look away. Exert from the HS.

Melbourne is optimistic captain Max Gawn will return for its ANZAC Day eve clash against Richmond as Demons coach Simon Goodwin described his sides’ loss to Essendon as “not us”.

Hopefully his BE wil be low enough that we can see them both and if his output drops there won't be a big price fall.

 

[Zimmer]

17/1801 English.
Wait for it, yes I've traded Naicos in, hopefully he hasn't run out of points. Naicos, Green, Marshall, Long and Caminiti to play, projected 2246, I'll take 2200.

I’m playing you in P2 - looks like a close one. Think you’ve got me though.

 

[HoleyFrijole$]

18/1801

At a loss as to whether I lock in Oliver’s 115 or roll the dice on Green, Daicos or Marshall. Ginbey the other to come.

Daicos 3/4 this year beats 115 and only 109 when he doesn’t. Can easily go 150 and then you miss 35 points?

 

[Brookesy]

Did Lycett have some sort of a knock or niggle? Seems a strange tactical sub choice.

No. He was getting absolutely towelled by English. Finlayson and Dixon took ruck duties and were infinitely better. Lycett should be dropped next week, looks finished.

 

[Feerits Elf]

I've had that happen to me on the phone. But then I got on the lap top, and it was ok.
Try logging out and back in.

I'm on a desktop.

Have logged out then back in, restarted, used a different browser. No change.

What a joke.

 

[Darkie]

Thanks @THCLT @NT.Thunder @Brookesy. Fingers crossed for next week!

 

[toxic]

No. He was getting absolutely towelled by English. Finlayson and Dixon took ruck duties and were infinitely better. Lycett should be dropped next week, looks finished.

Is Hayes still playing?

 

[Professor]

I’m playing you in P2 - looks like a close one. Think you’ve got me though.

lol, I think you have me covered. 1801 vs 1810 we both have Naicos, Marshall and Green. Then it's Long and Caminiti vs Stewart and Ginbey, enough said. 😁