Discussion 2023 Round 7: Teams & In Game Discussion

What was your final score?

  • Less than 2100

    Votes: 1 1.1%
  • 2100 - 2149

    Votes: 1 1.1%
  • 2150 - 2199

    Votes: 8 9.1%
  • 2200 - 2249

    Votes: 9 10.2%
  • 2250 - 2299

    Votes: 19 21.6%
  • 2300 - 2349

    Votes: 27 30.7%
  • 2350 - 2399

    Votes: 13 14.8%
  • 2400 - 2449

    Votes: 3 3.4%
  • 2450 - 2499

    Votes: 6 6.8%
  • More than 2500

    Votes: 1 1.1%

  • Total voters
    88
Joined
12 Jan 2014
Messages
3,760
Likes
11,755
AFL Club
West Coast
Which one do we go on then?
You cannot be sure of either but you can see the difference in the quality of reporting. Aunty ABC is unlikely to post a reporters guess. They want a quote from a legit source hence they quote the Crows CEO. Doesn't mean Laird will play, but they are presenting information from a stated source. Take it or leave it.

Norris meanwhile is trying to just rack up a profile on a story. Quotes no one and gives his own opinion. And confuses people in the process. When he says "Had several discussions with medical staff and coaches regarding his calf concern." Does he mean Laird was seen having discussions with medical staff or does he mean I (ie Norris) had several discussions with medical staff and I am reporting what they told me. I think he means Laird was seen talking to medical staff. Which means he probably knows very little. Hence his second tweet back tracking a bit on his first.
 
Joined
2 Apr 2014
Messages
1,128
Likes
4,812
AFL Club
Essendon
Dunkley, Ashcroft, Mckenna in the first game today with Johnson e if Laird doesn’t get up and Sturt on bench with e in forwards. Tom Green and Gulden in the GWS Swans game.
 
Joined
27 Feb 2014
Messages
598
Likes
2,061
AFL Club
Essendon
It was the governments $240m I was referring to, that will cost $400m.
No government on Earth can have a major project come in on budget. To be honest, I'm not sure why they even set budgets. They're not fooling anyone.
We have a new hospital being built near us. It started with a budget of 4 billion kroner. They are only half way done, and it has already blown out to 6 billion kroner.
To give you an idea of how well this hospital has been planned.
2 years before they broke ground, they announced there was not enough money in the budget to build a kitchen in the new hospital. o_O:ROFLMAO:
Think about that. This is a 600 bed hospital, with goodness knows how many staff. How are they going to feed everyone? Outside catering? That will cost more in 2 years, than the kitchen would of cost!!!!
They patted themselves on the back, because they had forward planned a new train station that will be around 800m from the hospital....... until someone pointed out, 6 months after the hospital was started, that there was no real road infrastructure, nor bus service for the new hospital. Outside of a small "country road", there is no other way to get to and from the hospital!!! Yep, they are going to have to spend megabucks to expand that 2 or 3 kilometres of road, so it can properly service the hospital. Not planned for. Not budgeted. But they can't afford a kitchen ......
I said to my wife, this was most short sighted planning on record. Blind Freddy could see no kitchen wasn't an option. They will probably announce 5 years after it opens in 2024 (6 months behind schedule), that they will spend 3 billion kroner to add a kitchen (might have cost a quarter of that, if they just bit the bullet, and got it in the first place!!!), as outside catering is becoming too expensive. They will probably be expecting to be lauded for such a "brilliant and money saving idea!!!". Idiots.
View: https://youtu.be/dOe_6vuaR_s
 
Joined
15 Mar 2019
Messages
15,033
Likes
57,916
AFL Club
Hawthorn
It was the governments $240m I was referring to, that will cost $400m.
No government on Earth can have a major project come in on budget. To be honest, I'm not sure why they even set budgets. They're not fooling anyone.
We have a new hospital being built near us. It started with a budget of 4 billion kroner. They are only half way done, and it has already blown out to 6 billion kroner.
To give you an idea of how well this hospital has been planned.
2 years before they broke ground, they announced there was not enough money in the budget to build a kitchen in the new hospital. o_O:ROFLMAO:
Think about that. This is a 600 bed hospital, with goodness knows how many staff. How are they going to feed everyone? Outside catering? That will cost more in 2 years, than the kitchen would of cost!!!!
They patted themselves on the back, because they had forward planned a new train station that will be around 800m from the hospital....... until someone pointed out, 6 months after the hospital was started, that there was no real road infrastructure, nor bus service for the new hospital. Outside of a small "country road", there is no other way to get to and from the hospital!!! Yep, they are going to have to spend megabucks to expand that 2 or 3 kilometres of road, so it can properly service the hospital. Not planned for. Not budgeted. But they can't afford a kitchen ......
I said to my wife, this was most short sighted planning on record. Blind Freddy could see no kitchen wasn't an option. They will probably announce 5 years after it opens in 2024 (6 months behind schedule), that they will spend 3 billion kroner to add a kitchen (might have cost a quarter of that, if they just bit the bullet, and got it in the first place!!!), as outside catering is becoming too expensive. They will probably be expecting to be lauded for such a "brilliant and money saving idea!!!". Idiots.
It's very similar here in Australia, yes. A few projects do come in under budget, but the vast majority end up a fair chunk over. Agree it's better to pay up early, as costs have been getting significantly higher over time.
 
Joined
10 Feb 2014
Messages
11,375
Likes
21,228
AFL Club
Essendon
Callaghan has the E on him for me , I would like to trade him out but I can't just in case Laird is an out.
Johnson vs Hollands for the E. Can loop but if we won't know about Laird till the game, it's probably not worth the risk.
 
Joined
23 Mar 2019
Messages
2,131
Likes
7,021
It was the governments $240m I was referring to, that will cost $400m.
No government on Earth can have a major project come in on budget. To be honest, I'm not sure why they even set budgets. They're not fooling anyone.
We have a new hospital being built near us. It started with a budget of 4 billion kroner. They are only half way done, and it has already blown out to 6 billion kroner.
To give you an idea of how well this hospital has been planned.
2 years before they broke ground, they announced there was not enough money in the budget to build a kitchen in the new hospital. o_O:ROFLMAO:
Think about that. This is a 600 bed hospital, with goodness knows how many staff. How are they going to feed everyone? Outside catering? That will cost more in 2 years, than the kitchen would of cost!!!!
They patted themselves on the back, because they had forward planned a new train station that will be around 800m from the hospital....... until someone pointed out, 6 months after the hospital was started, that there was no real road infrastructure, nor bus service for the new hospital. Outside of a small "country road", there is no other way to get to and from the hospital!!! Yep, they are going to have to spend megabucks to expand that 2 or 3 kilometres of road, so it can properly service the hospital. Not planned for. Not budgeted. But they can't afford a kitchen ......
I said to my wife, this was most short sighted planning on record. Blind Freddy could see no kitchen wasn't an option. They will probably announce 5 years after it opens in 2024 (6 months behind schedule), that they will spend 3 billion kroner to add a kitchen (might have cost a quarter of that, if they just bit the bullet, and got it in the first place!!!), as outside catering is becoming too expensive. They will probably be expecting to be lauded for such a "brilliant and money saving idea!!!". Idiots.

I mean that seems terribly planned, but on the general premise that there's no point, you need to plan, and you need contingencies, and there is so much that can go wrong in projects of this size that it's near I possible to predict everything.
 
Joined
27 Feb 2014
Messages
598
Likes
2,061
AFL Club
Essendon
I mean that seems terribly planned, but on the general premise that there's no point, you need to plan, and you need contingencies, and there is so much that can go wrong in projects of this size that it's near I possible to predict everything.
For example, Geelong's stadium is delayed because the quality of the steel is no good?
I doubt that would have been in the budget.
What about all the cost increases due to COVID? No one could have predicted that, etc etc
 
Joined
2 Mar 2023
Messages
1,931
Likes
7,046
AFL Club
Essendon
You cannot be sure of either but you can see the difference in the quality of reporting. Aunty ABC is unlikely to post a reporters guess. They want a quote from a legit source hence they quote the Crows CEO. Doesn't mean Laird will play, but they are presenting information from a stated source. Take it or leave it.

Norris meanwhile is trying to just rack up a profile on a story. Quotes no one and gives his own opinion. And confuses people in the process. When he says "Had several discussions with medical staff and coaches regarding his calf concern." Does he mean Laird was seen having discussions with medical staff or does he mean I (ie Norris) had several discussions with medical staff and I am reporting what they told me. I think he means Laird was seen talking to medical staff. Which means he probably knows very little. Hence his second tweet back tracking a bit on his first.
Perfectly said(y)
 
Joined
20 Mar 2016
Messages
1,397
Likes
4,836
You cannot be sure of either but you can see the difference in the quality of reporting. Aunty ABC is unlikely to post a reporters guess. They want a quote from a legit source hence they quote the Crows CEO. Doesn't mean Laird will play, but they are presenting information from a stated source. Take it or leave it.

Norris meanwhile is trying to just rack up a profile on a story. Quotes no one and gives his own opinion. And confuses people in the process. When he says "Had several discussions with medical staff and coaches regarding his calf concern." Does he mean Laird was seen having discussions with medical staff or does he mean I (ie Norris) had several discussions with medical staff and I am reporting what they told me. I think he means Laird was seen talking to medical staff. Which means he probably knows very little. Hence his second tweet back tracking a bit on his first.
I still appreciate the insight from Corey Norris though. It wasn’t exactly a flawless “nothing-to-see-here” session from Laird - he was first to leave the track and spoke to medical staff.
 
Joined
9 Aug 2012
Messages
40,127
Likes
151,432
AFL Club
Carlton
You can't swap a mid/fwd premo with a non playing mid rookie?
I've already swung Taranto to mids, my mid bench is bare, so if Laird is out, it's a donut or a possible injury affected score. Anyway I've traded him out to my pod in Viney who has built up nicely over the last 3 weeks.
 
Joined
20 Dec 2016
Messages
10,767
Likes
52,325
AFL Club
Carlton
Decided I'll swap one of my trades to LDU out to cover myself against Laird not getting up, but have been denied by my phone!

My phone has developed a dead zone across the centre of the screen, which just happens to be exactly where the confirm trade button is on the last screen. In most apps I can get around this by either rotating the screen or changing the text size, but SC doesn't appear to allow either of those. I would just do it on my laptop but I'm still at work!

I'm now locked out of that trade because the intention was to bring McKenna back in. Just watch him go 90+ now.
 
Top