Analysis 2023 Preseason Games
- Thread starter wogitalia
- Start date
- Joined
- 14 Dec 2018
- Messages
- 359
- Likes
- 1,838
- AFL Club
- Geelong
Expected Cats best 22 after yesterdays game, compared with GF team:
That 4th bench spot could easily go to Rohan / Miers / Parfitt / Menegola instead of Z Guthrie. Reckon the 3 new recruits are gonna get first crack and form will determine if they can hold their spot. Ratugolea covers for J Henry and could get half a dozen games in (and perhaps hold depending on form), not that the extent of J Henry's injury is clear
That 4th bench spot could easily go to Rohan / Miers / Parfitt / Menegola instead of Z Guthrie. Reckon the 3 new recruits are gonna get first crack and form will determine if they can hold their spot. Ratugolea covers for J Henry and could get half a dozen games in (and perhaps hold depending on form), not that the extent of J Henry's injury is clear
Carlton wasteful with the ball use first quarter, but kicked really well at goals. 2nd quarter Pies couldn't miss a set shot so probably evened out.
Glad it's a pre-season game, stressful otherwise
Shame NDaicos did very little, seemed everyone was locking him in...
(He got a little more ball in Q2 though)
They've got Hawthorn next week, so everyone can jump back on!
Carlton's 7th defender pretty unclear still, Cowan was solid, Cincotta too, but I'd still say Plowman is our safest bet early, looked good too. Marchbank didn't play today so expect he's still likely too (2 of Cowan/Cincotta/Plowman/Marchbank will play, I'd expect it to be the latter two, but will be matchup dependant for Marchbank I'd argue)
Doc's role mostly as I expected, across half back. Don't see why he'd get mid time unless one of Kennedy/Cerra/Cripps/Hewett gets injured. Was happy with Acres, such a good recruit
Didn't see Titch much first half... I'd be dismissing him, considering Collingwood's fit midfield (Adams/JDG etc) - Pendles had some CBA's, can't think of any mids that were missing so that's a little surpising as I thought his CBA time was over.
Non-fantasy wise; happy with TDK today (no Pitt) - took some good marks, McStay looked great as he did in intraclub, Cox rucking more than Cameron, I'd still expect a 50/50 split but not great for Cameron. Ed Curnow looks fit (no more mid time for him in his career, but was linking up well across half forward)
Glad it's a pre-season game, stressful otherwise
Shame NDaicos did very little, seemed everyone was locking him in...
(He got a little more ball in Q2 though)
They've got Hawthorn next week, so everyone can jump back on!
Carlton's 7th defender pretty unclear still, Cowan was solid, Cincotta too, but I'd still say Plowman is our safest bet early, looked good too. Marchbank didn't play today so expect he's still likely too (2 of Cowan/Cincotta/Plowman/Marchbank will play, I'd expect it to be the latter two, but will be matchup dependant for Marchbank I'd argue)
Doc's role mostly as I expected, across half back. Don't see why he'd get mid time unless one of Kennedy/Cerra/Cripps/Hewett gets injured. Was happy with Acres, such a good recruit
Didn't see Titch much first half... I'd be dismissing him, considering Collingwood's fit midfield (Adams/JDG etc) - Pendles had some CBA's, can't think of any mids that were missing so that's a little surpising as I thought his CBA time was over.
Non-fantasy wise; happy with TDK today (no Pitt) - took some good marks, McStay looked great as he did in intraclub, Cox rucking more than Cameron, I'd still expect a 50/50 split but not great for Cameron. Ed Curnow looks fit (no more mid time for him in his career, but was linking up well across half forward)
Carlton wasteful with the ball use first quarter, but kicked really well at goals. 2nd quarter Pies couldn't miss a set shot so probably evened out.
Glad it's a pre-season game, stressful otherwise
Shame NDaicos did very little, seemed everyone was locking him in...
(He got a little more ball in Q2 though)
They've got Hawthorn next week, so everyone can jump back on!
Carlton's 7th defender pretty unclear still, Cowan was solid, Cincotta too, but I'd still say Plowman is our safest bet early, looked good too. Marchbank didn't play today so expect he's still likely too (2 of Cowan/Cincotta/Plowman/Marchbank will play, I'd expect it to be the latter two, but will be matchup dependant for Marchbank I'd argue)
Doc's role mostly as I expected, across half back. Don't see why he'd get mid time unless one of Kennedy/Cerra/Cripps/Hewett gets injured. Was happy with Acres, such a good recruit
Didn't see Titch much first half... I'd be dismissing him, considering Collingwood's fit midfield (Adams/JDG etc) - Pendles had some CBA's, can't think of any mids that were missing so that's a little surpising as I thought his CBA time was over.
Non-fantasy wise; happy with TDK today (no Pitt) - took some good marks, McStay looked great as he did in intraclub, Cox rucking more than Cameron, I'd still expect a 50/50 split but not great for Cameron. Ed Curnow looks fit (no more mid time for him in his career, but was linking up well across half forward)
Glad it's a pre-season game, stressful otherwise
Shame NDaicos did very little, seemed everyone was locking him in...
(He got a little more ball in Q2 though)
They've got Hawthorn next week, so everyone can jump back on!
Carlton's 7th defender pretty unclear still, Cowan was solid, Cincotta too, but I'd still say Plowman is our safest bet early, looked good too. Marchbank didn't play today so expect he's still likely too (2 of Cowan/Cincotta/Plowman/Marchbank will play, I'd expect it to be the latter two, but will be matchup dependant for Marchbank I'd argue)
Doc's role mostly as I expected, across half back. Don't see why he'd get mid time unless one of Kennedy/Cerra/Cripps/Hewett gets injured. Was happy with Acres, such a good recruit
Didn't see Titch much first half... I'd be dismissing him, considering Collingwood's fit midfield (Adams/JDG etc) - Pendles had some CBA's, can't think of any mids that were missing so that's a little surpising as I thought his CBA time was over.
Non-fantasy wise; happy with TDK today (no Pitt) - took some good marks, McStay looked great as he did in intraclub, Cox rucking more than Cameron, I'd still expect a 50/50 split but not great for Cameron. Ed Curnow looks fit (no more mid time for him in his career, but was linking up well across half forward)