Discussion 2023 Round 3: Teams & In Game Discussion
- Thread starter KLo30
- Start date
- Joined
- 6 Jan 2013
- Messages
- 19,071
- Likes
- 80,329
- AFL Club
- Melbourne
I am.
Zero Thatcher only missing a week apparently, and Scott has shown that if possible he'd prefer to play Ridley as a distributor. BZT getting injured last week impacted last week, and not having Reid or Stewart to come in due to injury means that this week is likely affected, but I don't mind the long term prospects, and have far more pressing needs elsewhere. (Note, I have Daicos. If I didn't have Daicos that might have been a different decision, but there's no must have amongst the others at that price range)
Zero Thatcher only missing a week apparently, and Scott has shown that if possible he'd prefer to play Ridley as a distributor. BZT getting injured last week impacted last week, and not having Reid or Stewart to come in due to injury means that this week is likely affected, but I don't mind the long term prospects, and have far more pressing needs elsewhere. (Note, I have Daicos. If I didn't have Daicos that might have been a different decision, but there's no must have amongst the others at that price range)
My kid is. But he's 7 years old and playing for the first time.
He also picked his team halfway through round 2 and has bigger issues to fix right now such as no players from the first 6 or 8 teams of last week
Ridley was always a risk, a bit like Young was for me. Your questions should be: has he or his role improved like I thought it might? After that you ask if someone could do it better, hopefully for cheaper
The magic number drops what.... 6% over the course of the year? If he plays as disappointingly as he did last year, you would lose 30k or so over the journey and points wise be running a top 20 or 30 back. (Someone else could be more accurate with that statement). That would require fixing at some stage if true.
Is he one of your 3 biggest issues right now? Can he solve any of your 3 biggest wants without causing more damage?
In my case, I moved on Young because of the 3 biggest wants question. Also because with that 50 in his price for a couple of weeks I have time to get him back in if he should stayed as he shouldn't get away from me (minimise damage). Can you see an argument through all that that makes Ridley a necessary or desirable trade? If so, then proceed knowing that if you got it wrong, your thinking was good and it's all his fault 😀
HTH
He also picked his team halfway through round 2 and has bigger issues to fix right now such as no players from the first 6 or 8 teams of last week
Ridley was always a risk, a bit like Young was for me. Your questions should be: has he or his role improved like I thought it might? After that you ask if someone could do it better, hopefully for cheaper
The magic number drops what.... 6% over the course of the year? If he plays as disappointingly as he did last year, you would lose 30k or so over the journey and points wise be running a top 20 or 30 back. (Someone else could be more accurate with that statement). That would require fixing at some stage if true.
Is he one of your 3 biggest issues right now? Can he solve any of your 3 biggest wants without causing more damage?
In my case, I moved on Young because of the 3 biggest wants question. Also because with that 50 in his price for a couple of weeks I have time to get him back in if he should stayed as he shouldn't get away from me (minimise damage). Can you see an argument through all that that makes Ridley a necessary or desirable trade? If so, then proceed knowing that if you got it wrong, your thinking was good and it's all his fault 😀
HTH
So torn
Take the Neale vc 117 or go Clarry
Thinking safety but 17k overall not sure
Also
Gulden vs d Cameron in this week
D Cameron looks great
Ticks a lot of boxes *1 ruck so easier points
Good ceiling and month of No cox
Gulden
Looks a must have
Barely got out of first gear and going 110
Think both are must haves and I’ll get the other down the line
What would you guys do for both? Opinions appreciated
Take the Neale vc 117 or go Clarry
Thinking safety but 17k overall not sure
Also
Gulden vs d Cameron in this week
D Cameron looks great
Ticks a lot of boxes *1 ruck so easier points
Good ceiling and month of No cox
Gulden
Looks a must have
Barely got out of first gear and going 110
Think both are must haves and I’ll get the other down the line
What would you guys do for both? Opinions appreciated
- Joined
- 25 Dec 2022
- Messages
- 3,378
- Likes
- 16,582
- AFL Club
- West Coast
Yep. But would’ve traded to Naicos if I could make a fourth trade. Can’t see him going even top 10 unfortunately. His role just changes every week. Still might trade him to Naicos next week if their price differential doesn’t get out of hand. Will either have 33k bank with Setterfield or 72k bank with Worpel.
Heard on Sen1116 that Moore could be a late out.
View: https://mobile.twitter.com/CalebBarras4/status/1641560230877331456
View: https://mobile.twitter.com/CalebBarras4/status/1641560230877331456