Opinion 2024: Rookie Roulette
- Thread starter KLo30
- Start date
Only have Livingston as a C donut, Reid is the other non player but doesn't help things playing in the 2nd game.
Def: Graham v Comben?
Mid: Roberts, Massimo, Clohesy with McAuliffe and Wilson benched
Fwd: Dempsey v Darcy and Garcia?
Hoping Clark doesn't get named which would open up a mid loop. With the way cash gen is going I might be able to downgrade to a FD, could be handy over the next 4-5 rounds
Def: Graham v Comben?
Mid: Roberts, Massimo, Clohesy with McAuliffe and Wilson benched
Fwd: Dempsey v Darcy and Garcia?
Hoping Clark doesn't get named which would open up a mid loop. With the way cash gen is going I might be able to downgrade to a FD, could be handy over the next 4-5 rounds
ROOKIE LOOP MID: Graham, (Garcia (St.K) E) Looping agent Clark.
ROOKIE LOOP FWD: Comden, Darcy, (Wilson, Cadman E) Looping agent Reid.
Not sure about the forward setup. Could field Cadman and loop Wilson... or could swap Wilson and Cadman's positions M/F...
Sorry, put this in the wrong thread. Yes, spinning me around, too.
ROOKIE LOOP FWD: Comden, Darcy, (Wilson, Cadman E) Looping agent Reid.
Not sure about the forward setup. Could field Cadman and loop Wilson... or could swap Wilson and Cadman's positions M/F...
Sorry, put this in the wrong thread. Yes, spinning me around, too.
Garcia loves a tackle which gives him a good floor if he's struggling to get into the game. Getting CBA's too so there is good opportunity there as well. Wilson I think could struggle vs Port, and Garcia could too, but I think Wilson has a lower floor and Garcia a higher ceiling, so I'm going Garcia over Wilson.
Rookie Roulette is doing my head in this week:
Roberts and Reid have basically earned their spots if they play. Sam Darcy is just a rung below, but he probably gets the same courtesy unless the loop of Garcia/Wilson/Biggie fires well enough.
Saints give up monster scores to general defenders/designated kickers (Sheezel, McKercher, Biggie, Comben) and North gives up points to general forwards (Garcia, Wilson). I'm happy to field McKercher and Sheezel because they've earned their stripes, but Biggie, Comben, Garcia and Wilson could either go 80+ or 40, and because they play each other I can't loop them.
To add to the confusion, the Suns duo of Graham and Closely have been solid performers and more every week; Brisbane is tougher but every couple of weeks they give up a monster score to an opposition inside mid. That's probably not going to be Graham; but does he get some advantage from it?
Roberts and Reid have basically earned their spots if they play. Sam Darcy is just a rung below, but he probably gets the same courtesy unless the loop of Garcia/Wilson/Biggie fires well enough.
Saints give up monster scores to general defenders/designated kickers (Sheezel, McKercher, Biggie, Comben) and North gives up points to general forwards (Garcia, Wilson). I'm happy to field McKercher and Sheezel because they've earned their stripes, but Biggie, Comben, Garcia and Wilson could either go 80+ or 40, and because they play each other I can't loop them.
To add to the confusion, the Suns duo of Graham and Closely have been solid performers and more every week; Brisbane is tougher but every couple of weeks they give up a monster score to an opposition inside mid. That's probably not going to be Graham; but does he get some advantage from it?
