Discussion 2024 Round 5: Teams & In Game Discussion

[neeld]

Jhye Clark could be at risk with the Cats? Scoring not great but a slow burner would be nice to keep playing.

looks like he'll either be dropped or SUB imo

 

[ScottishBomber]

looks like he'll either be dropped or SUB imo

What is the best option? Sub to me would indicate maybe a rookie rest and back in next week. Dropped a bit more ominous.

 

[neeld]

What is the best option? Sub to me would indicate maybe a rookie rest and back in next week. Dropped a bit more ominous.

depends what your plans are with him I guess. if you want to move him on real soon then SUB, if you want to hold for a while then being dropped is probably more conducive for his potential for cash flow

 

[freowho]

What is the best option? Sub to me would indicate maybe a rookie rest and back in next week. Dropped a bit more ominous.

Dropped so I can loop.

 

[wolfbunny]

https://twitter.com/i/web/status/1778330867209015556

View: https://twitter.com/JoshGabelich/status/1778330867209015556?t=bqqGYvOpGJfrX-6Dp41gPQ&s=19

Fallen foul of Bevo and his idea that players are picked to play a position in the team. That is midfielders aren't small forwards so why they have the 2 small forwards. of West and Weightman.
Daniel is/was a halfback flanker and he prefers Dale, Richards, Johannisen and Bramble. surplus to needs I guess?

 

[Blue Bloods]

Not too worried when you look at the other names on the bench (outside of Walsh).

Carlton been swapping small forwards so Durdin probably but Carroll would be next in line and if considering limiting game time for Walsh, Carroll would be used 50/50 call.

 

[Blue Bloods]

One more slow game Oliver, have a good rest over the bye get your body right, then smash out a good game after the bye and will have a good hard look at bringing you in.

 

[Tamuhawk]

Last game not owning you Gawny... have mercy tonight plz.

 

[Athomas]

I’m not so worried about Carroll as he’s been playing well and Walsh may need managing in his first game back.

I'd lean Carroll sub on the current teams but also seems Elijah Hollands is still unlikely, so Binns could come as sub, Walsh plays a bit more HFF to ease him in.

Great that Darcy didn't come in, hopefully another 90+ for Jackson this week and he can kick a few against WCE the week after, and then he's out of my team

 

[Maccas marvels]

Phillips named, does that impact Powell and his role at nth?

 

[Maccas marvels]

Last game not owning you Gawny... have mercy tonight plz.

Only a breakeven of 75 tonight….

 

[7/11]

I'd lean Carroll sub on the current teams but also seems Elijah Hollands is still unlikely, so Binns could come as sub, Walsh plays a bit more HFF to ease him in.

Great that Darcy didn't come in, hopefully another 90+ for Jackson this week and he can kick a few against WCE the week after, and then he's out of my team

I hope we can get another week of solid scoring from Carroll. 150k from a rookie I wasn’t 100% on in my starting team would be amazing.

Got a feeling McKay is going to brain it against Adelaide this week. Spewing Carlton aren’t playing before Bont does otherwise the VC would’ve been slapped on him!

 

[Nothing]

Last game not owning you Gawny... have mercy tonight plz.

I've done my bit for you and named him VC. Should be good for a 85.

 

[Connoisseur]

Gawn VC tonight.
Considered Lohmann but scared after Berry and Thomas in the past couple of rounds, so will wait on Comben/Georgiades. Holding Howes as E since I am concerned about Carroll’s job security with Walsh returning and would prefer to trade out Coffield instead sooner rather than later. May pass on Flanders but should be able to grab a Dawson/LDU/etc type instead next round.

 

[Connoisseur]

https://twitter.com/i/web/status/1778353797615829169

 

[donnybuang]

How real of a threat is this really.

You'd hate to fade Flanders over this and the tag doesn't eventuate.

I'd only fade Flanders for his role change.
No reason why Powell and him don't swap scores this week.

 

[Miller is a Steele]

Just a quick summary on Tholstrup from me.

Watched him play a lot of football last year for Subiaco (who I support) and he broke through for 10 League games. Lots of swagger and personality, looks like a great kid too. Medium sized forward (AFL site has him listed at 186cm). More of your X-factor type of guy rather than your high possession getter, SC style of game type of guy.

Averaged 11 touches a game for Subi at League level, 3.5 marks, 2.4 tackles, 0.7 goals. Improved as the season went on. Played pretty deep.

I have been following him and he racked up 21 touches in each of his 2 VFL games to date, with 13 tackles and 10 marks between them. This is a big improvement from a statistical perspective. I assume he’s playing in a higher role now at Melbourne.

Would like to see him get a good run at it at AFL level but from a SC lense, the ideal scenario is he’s a one and done for Pickett when he returns. Hope for a return later in upgrade season.

3 minutes in and I can already tell you he’s playing a much higher role.

 

[Feerits Elf]

Gawn VC tonight.
Considered Lohmann but scared after Berry and Thomas in the past couple of rounds

Good move I reckon, Lohmann would have been quite the bold choice for VC.

 

[Lost In The Sky]

Salem subbed out with a hamstring

 

[7/11]

Salem subbed out with a hamstring

Big opportunity for a Howes spike game.