Opinion Player X vs Player Y
- Thread starter yakka
- Start date
Sloane for me. Sloane v Selwood gets a bit more difficult as both have good draws. I'd probably even go Sloane over Selwood.
Think JuniorWolf made a good comment saying Sloane might even become a brownlow smokie. His form and draw is becoming too good to ignore.
Selwood might also cop a rest R22 in the away game vs the Lions (which concerns me as an owner). Sloane for me!
Think JuniorWolf made a good comment saying Sloane might even become a brownlow smokie. His form and draw is becoming too good to ignore.
Selwood might also cop a rest R22 in the away game vs the Lions (which concerns me as an owner). Sloane for me!
- Joined
- 16 Mar 2013
- Messages
- 877
- Likes
- 867
- AFL Club
- Melbourne
Final defensive upgrade this week. Can't afford Doc and my current lineup includes Shaw, Simpson, Laird, Rance, Bartel
Boyd vs JJ vs Howe vs ZWilliams
Will JJ start taking points off Boyd?
Will Boyd get a rest at some stage?
Will Howe be 10-15 less than Boyd per week? Allows me to keep a D/F link, but is he a Premo?
Will JJ get back to his early season form or was it just a hot streak?
Is ZWilliams worth it at the price? Missed the boat?
Boyd vs JJ vs Howe vs ZWilliams
Will JJ start taking points off Boyd?
Will Boyd get a rest at some stage?
Will Howe be 10-15 less than Boyd per week? Allows me to keep a D/F link, but is he a Premo?
Will JJ get back to his early season form or was it just a hot streak?
Is ZWilliams worth it at the price? Missed the boat?
Think it depends on your risk appetite. If you want to take a punt on some potentially good scores, I'd run with JJ. I'm of the opinion that his last two games were just warmups to get back into the groove, after all he did miss about 10 weeks. He averaged 105 before his injury so reckon he can get back to that kind of form and probably has a higher ceiling than the others. I'd go JJ just over Boyd, then Howe/Williams (less pedigree in the last two).
G
For me it's Ablett to Ward,Trealor,Tich,Gibbs,Sidebottom,Shiel,Hodge. Any of the 490k guys so i can afford a top line defender.
Thoughts of which one?
Leaning towards Ward & Hodge atm as Hodge gives me a shot at Shaw should the stars align. Midfield is Dangerfield,Selwood,Pendlebury,Hannebury,Priddis,Gray,Parker,(Ablett) so i can afford to take a punt on a 490k guy.
Thoughts of which one?
Leaning towards Ward & Hodge atm as Hodge gives me a shot at Shaw should the stars align. Midfield is Dangerfield,Selwood,Pendlebury,Hannebury,Priddis,Gray,Parker,(Ablett) so i can afford to take a punt on a 490k guy.
