Opinion Rate My Team
- Thread starter IDIG
- Start date
- Joined
- 21 Mar 2019
- Messages
- 2,295
- Likes
- 6,291
Thank goodness the wait is over - been trawling over this almost every other night for the past couple of weeks but I've finally settled on a lineup I'm happy enough with in my first foray into supercoach for a long time.
Went a little mid-price mad in spots, probably a little on the cookie cutter side but I've also kind of gone all-in to some degree on players returning from injury and 2nd / 3rd yr midfielders who look like getting more time in the middle this year so hopefully it pays off.
Too late to change anything now I guess - time to sit down and enjoy the footy!
Went a little mid-price mad in spots, probably a little on the cookie cutter side but I've also kind of gone all-in to some degree on players returning from injury and 2nd / 3rd yr midfielders who look like getting more time in the middle this year so hopefully it pays off.
Too late to change anything now I guess - time to sit down and enjoy the footy!
Attachments
Looks good to me, if you started with this I think you'd be just fine. That said, a few ideas:
- I like Collins, but I like Moore more. I have both.
- D Smith had a bicep injury, maybe not a big issue but I think there's modest upside and more downside as a starting pick. Gray and Dunkley seem fairly safe and popular alternatives.
- No obvious rookies you've missed in my view other than the above.
- I don't love Petrucelle and gather he has questionable JS.
- Personally I'm increasingly happy starting a Goldy over Grundy. Grundy had a toe injury in pre season and I think is highly unlikely to outperform his price early. You have other C options.
- Fyfe has had a slight elbow issue but he could be appealing as a C option who is discounted.
- Cogs and Brayshaw look like increasingly popular picks, but Neale and Oliver seem like low risk alternatives. Oliver had shoulder surgeries but did well in JLT.
Hope this helps, good luck!
- I like Collins, but I like Moore more. I have both.
- D Smith had a bicep injury, maybe not a big issue but I think there's modest upside and more downside as a starting pick. Gray and Dunkley seem fairly safe and popular alternatives.
- No obvious rookies you've missed in my view other than the above.
- I don't love Petrucelle and gather he has questionable JS.
- Personally I'm increasingly happy starting a Goldy over Grundy. Grundy had a toe injury in pre season and I think is highly unlikely to outperform his price early. You have other C options.
- Fyfe has had a slight elbow issue but he could be appealing as a C option who is discounted.
- Cogs and Brayshaw look like increasingly popular picks, but Neale and Oliver seem like low risk alternatives. Oliver had shoulder surgeries but did well in JLT.
Hope this helps, good luck!
Could be the deepest starting midfield ever! I think this means you're essentially short the 4th/5th/maybe 6th best pure mid rookies vs a large number of other good sides, so I would consider whether that is a bet you are keen to make.
Chopping your least favourite of your midpriced mids would be something I would seriously consider. You look to be short one def and your forwards are a bit weak from Petrucelle on. Smith and Williqms could help balance out your structure if you decide you're not happy backing this one. I also wouldn't complain if you cut Lloyd to Andrews or similar to help fund a rebalance.
Chopping your least favourite of your midpriced mids would be something I would seriously consider. You look to be short one def and your forwards are a bit weak from Petrucelle on. Smith and Williqms could help balance out your structure if you decide you're not happy backing this one. I also wouldn't complain if you cut Lloyd to Andrews or similar to help fund a rebalance.
For what it's worth I've got Butters and not Hately. Butters hs a modest record though, I think I might prefer Hatelt I feel he hadn't had tonsillitis and I felt I was confident that GWS were short on mids medium term.
No need to change it if you're confident, but i suspect your season couldn't swing on the performance of your mid pricers, and the performance of the mid rookies you don't take as a result.
No need to change it if you're confident, but i suspect your season couldn't swing on the performance of your mid pricers, and the performance of the mid rookies you don't take as a result.