Discussion Rookie Roulette!

[quite ironic]

Am actually considering Setterfield over Parker on the field this week with Balta playing and no chance to loop now.

 

[Ironhawk]

Greatly appreciate thoughts on which 2 of the following quartet to field in defence- S Collins, J Clark, X Duursma and J Scrimshaw. Currently leaning towards X Duursma and J Clark.

Clark vs Collins vs Duursma vs Scrimshaw

Need to play 2

Duursma and Collins? I have to play three of them, went for Clark as the emergency.

 

[Feerits Elf]

Oops, maybe should have posted here.

Need to bench one of Scrimshaw, Clark, Duursma or Setterfield. Thoughts please

 

[Goodie's Guns]

Am actually considering Setterfield over Parker on the field this week with Balta playing and no chance to loop now.

Just came to this thread to post this exact X vs. Y, thinking I'll do the same also.

 

[jaca]

Just came to this thread to post this exact X vs. Y, thinking I'll do the same also.

Could be a nice win, think a lot will go the other way.

 

[Darkie]

Greatly appreciate thoughts on which 2 of the following quartet to field in defence- S Collins, J Clark, X Duursma and J Scrimshaw. Currently leaning towards X Duursma and J Clark.

I would field the same two. Collins clearly last for now.

 

[Connoisseur]

I would field the same two. Collins clearly last for now.

Thanks. Fielded Duursma but ended up fielding Scrimshaw on debut for me over J Clark.

 

[Tamuhawk]

Assuming clark continues his scoring in the 2nd half.

Who to bench to get his score?
Scrimshaw, Duursma or Parker (via moore dpp)?

 

[Darkie]

Thanks. Fielded Duursma but ended up fielding Scrimshaw on debut for me over J Clark.

Looks like a decent call based on how Clark is tracking.

 

[quite ironic]

Take 65 from Clark or put Collins on??

Probably a -30 +20 variable situation so I assume go Clark?

 

[Inside50]

Take 65 from Clark or put Collins on??

Probably a -30 +20 variable situation so I assume go Clark?

Clark for sure. In the same situation.

 

[EyeloveRichmond]

Parker or Setterfield onfield? Would appreciate any opinions, cheers.

 

[Monya Meow Meow]

Parker or Setterfield onfield? Would appreciate any opinions, cheers.

Very 50/50 this one, I would go for Setters but just.

 

[Darkie]

Very 50/50 this one, I would go for Setters but just.

Same for me.

If in doubt I often consult the DT scores. Much closer YTD on that basis, albeit Parker still ahead. Probably still Setterfield though.

 

[BC]

Scott v Setterfield on field?
I no Scott had a stinker last week but apparently had a gastro type thing on gameday.
Also have Clarke's score on bench. Take it.or role with Duursma?
Thanks lads

 

[bomberboy]

Scott v Setterfield on field?
I no Scott had a stinker last week but apparently had a gastro type thing on gameday.
Also have Clarke's score on bench. Take it.or role with Duursma?
Thanks lads

For me - Scott and Duursma. Setterfield is gonna be a slow burn.

3 of: 65, Collins, Scrimshaw and Duursma.

 

[OzRulesFootball]

Constable 99 and Jordan Clark 69 as emergencies last night.
Loophole agent Tobe Watson lets me claim Constable 99 by having Watson on field and leave Scott and Gibbons on bench, However, that means not shifting Watson down back to claim Jordan Clark. I could claim the 69 too from Clark if I did not trade Hore and put him on field, but it is more important to trade Hore to Scrimshaw than claim a 69 emergency score so that is what I will do. Setterfield I will emergency loophole up forward with another loophole agent. So will play Collins and Duursma on field in backline and shift Burgess to bench from forward to back when I do my McGrath to Rockliff correction trade this evening.

 

[anfa18]

Durrsma or Collins on field?

 

[Dustman]

Durrsma or Collins on field?

Probably Duursma,but I have a nagging feeling Collins will see a bit of ball,how that translates to scores,your guess is as good as mine.

 

[Pieman17]

Pick 2 of Setterfield,Rozee and Parker to start.