News Round 6: Weekly Review

What is your current overall rank?


  • Total voters
    53
Joined
31 Mar 2012
Messages
1,124
Likes
4,780
AFL Club
West Coast
#21
Score: 2,311
Weekly Rank: 463
Overall Rank: 54,798 (from 77,373)
Points Behind Leader: 1,400 (current leader 14,026) made up 119 points lol
Heroes: everyone except Holman
Villains: Holman
Trades Made: Murphy - Guefle
Trades Planned: possibly 2 up. 420k in the bank. Cripps maybe? Danger next week?
Comments:
So close to my life long dream of not having to vote ‘other’ in the poll. Good week score wise. Keep trading. Win $50k. simple.
 

Humph

Rising Star Nominee
Joined
12 Feb 2013
Messages
147
Likes
126
AFL Club
Sydney
#22
Score : 2,145
Weekly Rank : 20,373
Season Rank : 4,277 (from 4,592)

Heroes : Gawn (C), Cripps
Villians : Danger, Parker, Dahlhaus, Nic Nat

Trades Made :
Banfield to Yeo
Garlett to Guelfi

Trades Planned :
Fauxgarty to Zmerrett
Murray to Spargo

Comments :
Not bad with Buddy and Petracca out. Was upset I didn't vice Cripps, but Gawn made me forget about that. After two weeks of getting burnt by my blind faith in Tmitch, it was nice to make the right choice for once. Shoulda traded out Holman instead of Banfield, but it hasn't hurt me too much yet.

So after I do my trades this round I'll have 23 trades left, everyone on field averaging over 80 and only 5 on field rookies. My ranking obviously isn't as impressive as a lot of people on here, but i feel like it's a solid base. It just hasn't been good enough where I don't keep looking back at my starting choices wondering what could have been if I had've started with Dusty, Cogs, Grundy, Gray instead of Danger, Parker, Nic Nat, Dahlhaus. I'm still hopeful it's a bit of a "This too shall pass" situation with all of them.
 
Joined
22 Jan 2018
Messages
110
Likes
242
AFL Club
Collingwood
#23
Score: 2,073
Weekly Rank: 45,532
Overall Rank: 14,013 (from 11,518)
Heroes: Gawn, Kelly, Cripps
Villains: Billings, Holman, Nic Nat, Myself for taking the C off Gawn
Trades Made: Out: Keefe, Garlett In: Mirra, Guelfi
Trades Planned: May not trade, but if I do it will be Billings out!
Comments: Shocking week this week after a great one last week. Nothing quite worked, and a late change of captain from Gawn to Fyfe really was the final nail in the coffin! I have 24 trades left so hoping not to have to trade, but very tempting to move Billings on.
 
Joined
25 Jul 2012
Messages
49,503
Likes
112,987
AFL Club
Collingwood
#24
too many "good luck stories" being posted here............................congratulations everyone on your starts and hope it continues

Score: 2,071
Overall: 13,096 (leader 14,026)

Weekly Rank: 46,323
Overall Rank: 16,927 (from 14,499)

Heroes: Gawn, Cripps, Mitchell, Selwood (VC) , Fyfe, McLean , Smith, Lycett, Kelly, Shaw, Dixon, Coniglio, Fritsch and captain Sicily
Villians: Sicily , Gunston, Dusty, Nic Nat

Trades Done: Papley to Gunston (+4)
Trades Planned; need to rid my bench of non-playing/slow cash generating players the next 2 rounds so look out Coffield, Murphy, Garlett, Barry & OConnor

Comments: next 2 weeks to get it right, then I will be coming home like a steam train.

One lesson I have learnt is you can have all the best starting premiums from the start, but if your rookies and bench are not generating $$$ you will struggle to upgrade. The key in the first 6 weeks is rookie $$$ , as Rowsus always says C & VC, sort the rucks, then select the rookies and premiums around that.

I know hindsight is a wonderful thing (especially in this game) BUT, IF I started Laird, T Kelly, Heeney & Gray from the start instead of CEllis, Sloane, Lambert & Papley I would be 600-700 points better off and sitting inside the Top 100..................................if only............................perhaps one year I will learn how to play this game properly and nail it.

good luck everyone for the rest of the season.
 
Joined
7 Jul 2012
Messages
11,790
Likes
34,947
AFL Club
West Coast
#25
Score: 1,978
Weekly Rank: 81,499
Overall Rank: 5,154 (from 1,384)
Heroes: Gawn, Cripps
Villains: Billings (Again!!), Holman (Again!!), Sicily, Petracca, Hogan, Simpson, Dusty, Coniglio, Nic Nat, English, Me
Trades Made: Brander to Guelfi, Ryan to Higgins
Trades Planned: Billings to a packet of chips
Comments: Horrible week. Infact Horrific week. Completely undid all of last weeks good work and gains. Really depressing stuff.

Had Gawn Captain all week, then on Sunday fearing even more carnage I switched to take Mitchell's 126... Lost a ton of points. Held Petracca and that muppet Sicily, so lost points because of them. What the hell was that Hogan? Terrible effort and shocking Body Language to go with it. And Jack Billings... Would struggle to get a kick in an under 10's Girls Aus Kick comp... What a spud!!

It's weeks like last week that really make reconsider playing SC and the time I put into it.

Well done to all those that are Flyin' at the moment
 

Tamuhawk

Leadership Group
Joined
4 Feb 2013
Messages
24,493
Likes
70,178
AFL Club
Hawthorn
#26
Score: 2,096
Weekly Rank: 36,666
Overall Rank: 112 (from 26)
Heroes: Gawn, Cripps, Mitchell, McLean, Fyfe, Smith & Kelly
Villains: Dusty, Goldy, Holman & Walters :(
Trades Made: Garlett to Guelfi, Fritsch to Mirra.
Trades Planned: Walters to someone and ???
Comments:

DEF: 5/10
Not one tonne in this line with Laird losing 1 point due to scaling. Hibberd hurrah, finally a decent score and hoping that it's a step in the right direction. Doedee did good. Finlayson & Murray quite disappointing. Had to field Mirra due to his teammate suspending himself and ended up on a decent score. Really hope Murphy comes back in soon to make some $$$.

MID: 6/10
Really should have kept the VC on Cripps but Trac being out gave lots of late options. Who knew that playing it safe would Tom Mitchell would cost a lot more points than I thought. Fyfe solid. Tim Kelly still the best rookie going around. Dusty 2nd underpar score. Cogs first time failing to get the tonne. Banfield the best out of a lot of very poor scores. Holman useless that game. Bench options in Coff/Crowden/Barry all under 50 too.

RUC: 8/10
FEAR THE BEARD!!! Was my captain but played it safe with Mitchell. Goldy horrible 1st half but bounced back in the 2nd but was against a part-timer in the ruck, so really should have annihilated his opponent. Can't wait to trade him to Ryder during the byes. English poor score but still mooing along nicely.

FWD: 7/10
This was probably my best scoring line up until the last game of the round. Walters injury hurt so much. McLean bounced back with his 3rd 110+ out of 4 in my side. Heeney first time dropping below the tonne. Gray tagged but ended up on an ok score. Smith finally with his 2nd tonne! Choosing Guelfi over Higgins kinda sucking right now.

Overall Comments:
Gee have a look at that weekly rank, the devil's number in there. My luck had to run out eventually with my first rankings drop of the year to outside the top 100. Walters my most POD player getting injured definitely hurts the most and also lost $52k in value so trading him out to another premo will eat away at my cash reserves. Tamuhawk's League took a massive hit overall, my friend who left Nank on the bench definitely did not help our rank. Proud to be part of SCS Div2 who are currently ranked 2nd & SCS$50 who are currently ranked 10th overall. Have doubts that Petracca will come back but Sicily is a welcome inclusion plus my Walters replacement. Just glad we have longer this week to plan our trades unlike last week. Hope to bounce back inside the top 100 next round.
 
Joined
7 Apr 2012
Messages
3,096
Likes
5,921
AFL Club
Adelaide
#27
Score: 1,978
Weekly Rank: 81,499
Overall Rank: 5,154 (from 1,384)
Heroes: Gawn, Cripps
Villains: Billings (Again!!), Holman (Again!!), Sicily, Petracca, Hogan, Simpson, Dusty, Coniglio, Nic Nat, English, Me
Trades Made: Brander to Guelfi, Ryan to Higgins
Trades Planned: Billings to a packet of chips
Comments: Horrible week. Infact Horrific week. Completely undid all of last weeks good work and gains. Really depressing stuff.

Had Gawn Captain all week, then on Sunday fearing even more carnage I switched to take Mitchell's 126... Lost a ton of points. Held Petracca and that muppet Sicily, so lost points because of them. What the hell was that Hogan? Terrible effort and shocking Body Language to go with it. And Jack Billings... Would struggle to get a kick in an under 10's Girls Aus Kick comp... What a spud!!

It's weeks like last week that really make reconsider playing SC and the time I put into it.

Well done to all those that are Flyin' at the moment
Hang in there mate I hear ya!! At least the eagles and crows had a win....onwards to next week!:D
 
Joined
25 Mar 2012
Messages
4,834
Likes
1,761
AFL Club
North Melb.
#28
Score: 2,167
Weekly Rank: 14,608
Overall Rank: 2,387 (from 2,953)
Points Behind Leader: 587
Heroes: Laird, Fyfe, Ticth, Cripps (C), T.Kelly, Gawn, McLean, Smith, Fritsch.
Villains: Billings, Holman, Dusty.
Trades Made Round 5: Brayshaw > Coffield
Trades Made Round 6: Petracca and Banfield > Mirra and Higgins.
Trades Planned: Sitting on 786k in the bank so i think it's highly likely 2 premiums will come in this week for Holman and Garlett. Sicily vs Westhoff vs Gray. Macrae vs Treloar vs Selwood. Really tough decisions to make. Following that, I think i'll be looking to go Finlayson/Murray to Dangerfield next week, as i think his price will have bottomed out.
Comments: I've been away the last 2 weeks as i was moving house and had no internet or tv reception :mad: I did well enough the past two weeks to not lose any positions overall and in fact moved forward 129 spots while only trading in rookies.
 

Ben's Beasts

Leadership Group
Joined
6 Jan 2013
Messages
19,753
Likes
84,484
AFL Club
Melbourne
#29
Score: 2,139
Rank: 4,666 (from 4,868)
Heroes: Captain Mitchell, Gawn, Cripps, Nankervis, Fyfe, D Smith, Savage, T Kelly, Fritsch
Villains: Hogan (inj), Billings, Dusty, Oliver, Henry, L Fogarty
Trades Made: OUT: Bonner, Garlett IN: Mirra, Guelfi
Trades Planned: Either Billings to a better player or no trades at all
Comments: Like most, it was always going to be tough with Sicily and Petracca on the bench. Expected so much more from Billings and Hogan although the latter was playing injured. Still, moved up the rankings slightly so I'll take that. Hopefully will be able to field all my keepers this round coming.
 
Joined
25 Jan 2013
Messages
1,571
Likes
1,374
AFL Club
Essendon
#30
Score: 2,087
Weekly rank: 40,085
Overall rank: 700 (from 252)
Points behind leader: 442

Trades made: Greene to Mirra, Fritsch to Guelfi
Heroes: Titch VC, #FearTheBeard, McLean, Smith, TKelly
Villains: Dusty, Billings, Parker, Holman
Trades planned: Holman/Banfield to Danger, Murray to Howe?

Comments:
Disappointing week. On the back foot with Greene out with a mystery foot injury and Sicily's suspension. Aside from TKelly and Doedee, the rookies also didn't score as well as they have so far. Was expecting to fall further down the overall rank but the damage wasn't too bad in the end. Chickened out Gawn C, was put off by his short turn around. Forgot that Essendon are actually woeful in the ruck.

Decided to trade out Greene as GWS seem unsure when he will return, words like "could be 2 weeks, could be 10 weeks" didn't fill me with confidence. Also needed to trade Fritsch out to cover Sicily's donut in the backline (by moving him forward). Was comfortable with that trade as Fritsch didn't seem seem like a long term prospect and Guelfi seems like a solid pick. Annoyed that Fritsch went on to score 80+ but that's the way the cookie crumbles.

For this week, I will use the cash from Greene to restructure. Need to get the Holman/Banfield types off field ASAP. Will get Danger this week even though he is not looking quite like himself at the moment. If I pass now, I won't be able to get him for a while yet and may be out of reach. Also looking to cull Murray for a keeper in defence. Howe the one who interests me most with the funds I have available.

Awesome to see many SCS coaches still right up there! Let's trade well, hopefully one us can take the top prize this year. Hang in there, community.
Onwards and Upwards!
 

Connoisseur

Leadership Group
Joined
3 Jul 2017
Messages
39,508
Likes
128,582
AFL Club
Port Adelaide
#31
Score: 2097
Weekly Rank: 36,308
Overall Rank: 7895 (from 6691)
Points Behind Leader: 766
Heroes: B Fritsch, N Fyfe, M Gawn (C), M Hurley, T Kelly, S Lycett, T Mitchell and D Smith
Villains: J Billings, N Holman, J Kelly, D Martin, C Oliver and J Sicily
Trades Made: D Venables to M Guelfi
Trades Planned: Out: A Christensen, J Garlett, In: T McLean, C Spargo

Comments: Disappointed with only 7 tons and my lowest score of the year but looking forward to Round 7 as J Sicily returns replacing a fwd rookie, T McLean will be brought in for Christensen and potentially J Kelly returning from injury as well.
 
Joined
4 Jan 2016
Messages
822
Likes
878
AFL Club
Essendon
#32
Bit late, but had to post :)

Score: 2,287
Weekly Rank: 1,020
Overall Rank: 200!!! (from 857)
Heroes: Savage, Fyfe, Titch, Crippa, Kelly, Gawn (C), McLean, Westhoff, Smith
Villains: Martin? Nic Nat? Bilbo
Trades Made: Out: Garlett In: Guelfi
Trades Planned: O'Meara & Billing for Treloar & Macrae atm... Yes Danger is Danger, but not really showing his worth?! Need to keep this momentum going!
Comments: MY BEST POSITION EVER!!! However, only JUST got my first SCS02 win!
Played the rooks pretty well this week, had some good PODs in Hoff and Fisher go solid and got the Captains pick right (through stuffing up my donut and not taking Titch's score)
Now just to work out what's the best play this week... Could get rid of Chriso, but feel like I'm more likely with him than Bilbo. Double down on him and probably Holman or Naughton next week to then potentially get Danger and finish the mids...
Mundy has caught my eye up forward, and need to get Heeney and Gray as well... So there's that to think about too!?!
 
Top