Strategy 2023: Player X v Player Y
- Thread starter Leroy
- Start date
Both are good options.
If you have enough spots, I’d suggest you will want both. Sicily is inferior value but has a lower BE, so the expected timing of those two upgrades may determine who comes in first.
If you can only get one, Sinclair is cheaper.
If in doubt, you could let your bye structure decide.
If you have enough spots, I’d suggest you will want both. Sicily is inferior value but has a lower BE, so the expected timing of those two upgrades may determine who comes in first.
If you can only get one, Sinclair is cheaper.
If in doubt, you could let your bye structure decide.
- Joined
- 3 Jul 2017
- Messages
- 38,964
- Likes
- 126,637
- AFL Club
- Port Adelaide
Merrett. Two games against both the Eagles and Roos to come, along with a few other easier opponents. Butters hasn't performed at this level for an extended period before and is a higher risk option, but that said I have suggested him for the combined team (we already have Merrett).
I like both options.
I like both options.
Butters is really only now or never unless you think he averages 125+ from here, or you are about to finish your forward and mid lines. If it’s the latter, that’s fair enough, but I think the former is very unlikely.
I would favour Merrett by a margin. Butters could easily be another Anderson/Rowell type in a month’s time.
I would favour Merrett by a margin. Butters could easily be another Anderson/Rowell type in a month’s time.