Strategy 2023: Player X v Player Y

[Ironhawk]

Day's 107 vs Walsh?

No brainer to take Day, right?

Yeah, don't see Walsh blowing that out of the water. He might outscore it by a bit, but you would expect he gets 130 or so max, and could just as easily score below 107. I'll predict 117 (I might have him in my own team and this is possibly wishful thinking).

 

[GrainFedBeef]

Yeah, don't see Walsh blowing that out of the water. He might outscore it by a bit, but you would expect he gets 130 or so max, and could just as easily score below 107. I'll predict 117 (I might have him in my own team and this is possibly wishful thinking).

119, nearly hole in one!

If trading Johnson and Seamus Mitchell, which combo?

Sicily and Mills - some tougher games for Sicily maybe with Pies who dont easily give up to defenders, Mills some sort of low injury/role risk

vs

Doc and Walsh - Walsh looks good, CBA's, Doc doing well lately maybe a revert to mean risk

vs

Ryan and Steele - Ryan solid defender who excels in losses, Steele, is he back?

Thought welcome'd

 

[Ironhawk]

119, nearly hole in one!

If trading Johnson and Seamus Mitchell, which combo?

Sicily and Mills - some tougher games for Sicily maybe with Pies who dont easily give up to defenders, Mills some sort of low injury/role risk

vs

Doc and Walsh - Walsh looks good, CBA's, Doc doing well lately maybe a revert to mean risk

vs

Ryan and Steele - Ryan solid defender who excels in losses, Steele, is he back?

Thought welcome'd

Can't trust Steele personally after how he went in my team, but expect that might be the highest scoring combo if he is fit. I'd pick the first combo if I was trading any in.

 

[Termin8er789]

Petracca Vs Sicily

 

[Ironhawk]

Petracca Vs Sicily

Different lines makes it a bit hard to compare, but I would expect Trac scores a little bit higher, especially with no Oliver.

 

[PC]

Need a mid for less than $514k.

Mills v Steele v someone else? (Blicavs??)

 

[Nothing]

Need a mid for less than $514k.

Mills v Steele v someone else? (Blicavs??)

Cripps?
Dusty if you can cover the inevitable week off at some point. WC this week in Perth might be that week
Angus Brayshaw with Petracca fwd and Oliver out for many weeks?
Blicavs is slightly more than your price.

From Mills and Steele, I like Mills more.

 

[Ironhawk]

Need a mid for less than $514k.

Mills v Steele v someone else? (Blicavs??)

Agree Cripps is not a bad call, seems to score better in their wins though, so it depends how many wins you see the Blues getting.

Josh Daicos is not a bad pick, not quite at his brother's level, but I know from MPM he has been going well lately.

Prefer Mills to Steele, mainly due to being burned by Steele multiple weeks in a row. He has been reasonable since trading him out though, as always happens. Might be a down week for Mills with Lloyd out this round, but think he comes out slightly ahead of Steele from here across the season.

 

[PC]

Cripps?
Dusty if you can cover the inevitable week off at some point. WC this week in Perth might be that week
Angus Brayshaw with Petracca fwd and Oliver out for many weeks?
Blicavs is slightly more than your price.

From Mills and Steele, I like Mills more.

Agree Cripps is not a bad call, seems to score better in their wins though, so it depends how many wins you see the Blues getting.

Josh Daicos is not a bad pick, not quite at his brother's level, but I know from MPM he has been going well lately.

Prefer Mills to Steele, mainly due to being burned by Steele multiple weeks in a row. He has been reasonable since trading him out though, as always happens. Might be a down week for Mills with Lloyd out this round, but think he comes out slightly ahead of Steele from here across the season.

Thanks. I am concerned about injuries. Are we convinced that Steele and Mills are right again? Surely Cripps is carrying something?

 

[Ironhawk]

Thanks. I am concerned about injuries. Are we convinced that Steele and Mills are right again? Surely Cripps is carrying something?

No. But you need to pick someone.

Cripps has carried the team for years, should be used to it by now.

 

[toxic]

I'm stuck

And it's doing my head in

Have 3 combos

Sicily and Mills

Walsh and Butters

Docherty and Bolton

Someone decide for me please

 

[Ironhawk]

I'm stuck

And it's doing my head in

Have 3 combos

Sicily and Mills

Walsh and Butters

Docherty and Bolton

Someone decide for me please

I'll back in Sicily and Mills. Hoping that holding him through his suspension pays off, as a lot won't be able to bring him back in now. Mills is a minor concern there, but as mentioned in a previous post, I think he'll go OK once Lloyd is back, if they don't cop more injuries.

 

[WindyHillWizard]

I'm stuck

And it's doing my head in

Have 3 combos

Sicily and Mills

Walsh and Butters

Docherty and Bolton

Someone decide for me please

Sicily and Mills.

 

[donnybuang]

I'm stuck

And it's doing my head in

Have 3 combos

Sicily and Mills

Walsh and Butters

Docherty and Bolton

Someone decide for me please

Walsh and Butters

 

[dicksilverman]

Anderson vs Butters vs Walsh or any mid under $600k?

 

[Nothing]

Walsh and Butters

I'm with you, I prefer these two.

 

[HimothyTaranto]

Anderson vs Butters vs Walsh or any mid under $600k?

Walsh if his CBA's keep up. Butters was riding high but has been disappointing the last 3 rounds. Anderson is a smokey who could average 110.

 

[Ironhawk]

Anderson vs Butters vs Walsh or any mid under $600k?

Anderson of those 3, but there is possibly a new coach factor.

Of those not mentioned, Parish seems the best bet. Would rank him ahead of Anderson.

 

[dicksilverman]

Anderson of those 3, but there is possibly a new coach factor.

Of those not mentioned, Parish seems the best bet. Would rank him ahead of Anderson.

Thanks Ironhawk, brought Parish in last week.

 

[Courtesans]

Keays v Finlayson