Discussion Cricket Discussion

Joined
25 Jul 2012
Messages
47,728
Likes
107,811
AFL Club
Collingwood
Brook 4 , 6 , 6 , 2 , 6 off the final over to win the 3rd T20I

West Indies 226/6 (20) Pooran 82 (45)
England 226/3 (19.5) Salt 109* (56) , Brook 31 * (7)

Salt is the 5th player to score a T20I century for England after Hales , Malan , Livingstone & Buttler.

Final over was bowled by DreRuss
 
Joined
25 Jul 2012
Messages
47,728
Likes
107,811
AFL Club
Collingwood
Labuschagne in 2023 (so far)

Tests 12
Innings 23
NO 2
Runs 736
HS 111
Ave 35.04
100 x 1
50 x 3

Not much more than what Warner has been averaging the last 2 years , does the media start asking questions about his form ?

See what the scan results say about his finger.
 

Rowsus

Statistician
Joined
19 Mar 2012
Messages
29,137
Likes
64,919
AFL Club
Melbourne
Why aren't Australia batting with more urgency?
2-3 singles an over in the current situation is ridiculous. Should currently be aiming for 6-8:runs over to speed up the declaration.
An extra 10-15 overs to dismiss them might be the difference!!!
 
Joined
15 Mar 2019
Messages
15,036
Likes
57,928
AFL Club
Hawthorn
Why aren't Australia batting with more urgency?
2-3 singles an over in the current situation is ridiculous. Should currently be aiming for 6-8:runs over to speed up the declaration.
An extra 10-15 overs to dismiss them might be the difference!!!
Last 5 overs have been 10, 6, 1, 7, 7 so they aren't far off it. Just need to keep it up.
 

Rowsus

Statistician
Joined
19 Mar 2012
Messages
29,137
Likes
64,919
AFL Club
Melbourne
Last 5 overs have been 10, 6, 1, 7, 7 so they aren't far off it. Just need to keep it up.
Picked up as soon I thought it. Posted it an over or two after I thought it. Batted a bit slow for too long. Even Marsh was dithering.
Good to see. They really shouldn't have been worrying about losing wickets in this situation.

Khawaja blocking maidens, then 5 dot balls and a single of the sixth ball, which was happening after the 46th over, shows a lack of understanding of what is required, or comes from the Steve Waugh bat for yourself first, and the team second school of thinking!
 

Darkie

Leadership Group
Joined
12 Apr 2014
Messages
25,410
Likes
65,498
AFL Club
Collingwood
Why aren't Australia batting with more urgency?
2-3 singles an over in the current situation is ridiculous. Should currently be aiming for 6-8:runs over to speed up the declaration.
An extra 10-15 overs to dismiss them might be the difference!!!
I was discussing this with someone else over an hour ago.

Australia’s tactics leave a lot to be desired at times.
 

Rowsus

Statistician
Joined
19 Mar 2012
Messages
29,137
Likes
64,919
AFL Club
Melbourne
I was discussing this with someone else over an hour ago.

Australia’s tactics leave a lot to be desired at times.
It really does. They seem to play with a "we got this" attitude over a "let's really put our foot on their throat" approach.
That's the difference between good sides, and great sides.
Think like the West Indies era, or Australia early 2000's.
 
Joined
25 Jul 2012
Messages
47,728
Likes
107,811
AFL Club
Collingwood
Pitch is playing up for their bowlers (don't think 8-11 will bat for us) , can't see them lasting close to 4 sessions to save the game when they bat , unless snooze fest Imam bats for 4 sessions.

101.5 overs they lasted in the 1st Innings.

Modern day thinking seems to be all about time when considering the declaration , so how many overs they want to have at them today , I gather Cummins , Hazlewood & Starc would probably like 8-12 overs each minimum at them today , maybe 30-45 minute burst before tea.

402 Run lead at lunch , just keep them out there as long as they feel necessary , runs are not really relevant anymore.
 
Last edited:

Rowsus

Statistician
Joined
19 Mar 2012
Messages
29,137
Likes
64,919
AFL Club
Melbourne
If they really want to "save" Test Cricket, they need to do something about over rates!!!
25 Overs in that session is disgusting!
Currently the penalty is 5%/over, capped at 50% and 1 WTC point.
Well, some teams could careless about WTC points, so that penalty is pointless.
As to the 5%/over capped at 50%, that too is near meaningless.
The Pakistani players are paid around $6,000/Test Match. They play 5 Test Matches this year, so the maximum they can be fined this Tour for slow Test over rates is $9,000. The average Pakistani Test player is paid around $190,000/year. This doesn't include outside deals, IPL, sponsorships etc.
Does anyone really think they're worried about $9,000 (max) fines or WTC points????
Time to make them play properly, or not play at all. There was an idea floated around 20 years ago. Test players should get paid nothing until the end of the series, and fines should be heavy for continued poor play, like slow over rates. How heavy? I'd suggest fines for ridiculous over rates like todays morning session should be 100% of the tour earning fees. Continue to do it, and give them a 200% fine, and ban them from all paid cricket for 3 months.
People will say you can't do that. I say, they are paid to PLAY Test Cricket, not manipulate the game. Play, play properly, or step aside and let those that will play instead!!!!!
Punishment as a deterrent is only effective if the punishment is truly felt. At the moment, the punishment is like giving a Lamborghini driver a $50 parking ticket!!!!!
 
Joined
25 Jul 2012
Messages
47,728
Likes
107,811
AFL Club
Collingwood
If they really want to "save" Test Cricket, they need to do something about over rates!!!
25 Overs in that session is disgusting!
Currently the penalty is 5%/over, capped at 50% and 1 WTC point.
Well, some teams could careless about WTC points, so that penalty is pointless.
As to the 5%/over capped at 50%, that too is near meaningless.
The Pakistani players are paid around $6,000/Test Match. They play 5 Test Matches this year, so the maximum they can be fined this Tour for slow Test over rates is $9,000. The average Pakistani Test player is paid around $190,000/year. This doesn't include outside deals, IPL, sponsorships etc.
Does anyone really think they're worried about $9,000 (max) fines or WTC points????
Time to make them play properly, or not play at all. There was an idea floated around 20 years ago. Test players should get paid nothing until the end of the series, and fines should be heavy for continued poor play, like slow over rates. How heavy? I'd suggest fines for ridiculous over rates like todays morning session should be 100% of the tour earning fees. Continue to do it, and give them a 200% fine, and ban them from all paid cricket for 3 months.
People will say you can't do that. I say, they are paid to PLAY Test Cricket, not manipulate the game. Play, play properly, or step aside and let those that will play instead!!!!!
Punishment as a deterrent is only effective if the punishment is truly felt. At the moment, the punishment is like giving a Lamborghini driver a $50 parking ticket!!!!!
Is your $ 190,000.00 including match payments ?

Under their new contract deal Category C (2 players) & D players (15 players) are paid USD 2650.00 to USD 5300.00 approximately per month

Category B get USD 10,600.00 approximately per month (only 6 players)

Babar , Rizwan & Shaheen are the only Category A players on USD 15,900.00 approximately per month.

Source : CricInfo article August 8th

PCB media release 27 September actually highlights how much they all increased
 
Last edited:

Rowsus

Statistician
Joined
19 Mar 2012
Messages
29,137
Likes
64,919
AFL Club
Melbourne
And that is the exclamation mark on what I was saying.
We batted for 5.2 overs after lunch.
How about instead of losing 8 overs (2 for change of innings), you aim for a lunch declaration?
Will we still win? 97% yes. Could those 8 overs make a difference at the end of the match. Unlikely, but still possibly!!!!!
Dot the i's, cross the t's ....... it what the best sides do!!!!!
 
Joined
25 Jul 2012
Messages
47,728
Likes
107,811
AFL Club
Collingwood
Pitch is playing up for their bowlers (don't think 8-11 will bat for us) , can't see them lasting close to 4 sessions to save the game when they bat , unless snooze fest Imam bats for 4 sessions.

101.5 overs they lasted in the 1st Innings.

Modern day thinking seems to be all about time when considering the declaration , so how many overs they want to have at them today , I gather Cummins , Hazlewood & Starc would probably like 8-12 overs each minimum at them today , maybe 30-45 minute burst before tea.

402 Run lead at lunch , just keep them out there as long as they feel necessary , runs are not really relevant anymore.
Looks like I won't be captain , declared to soon Patty.
 
Joined
25 Jul 2012
Messages
47,728
Likes
107,811
AFL Club
Collingwood
And that is the exclamation mark on what I was saying.
We batted for 5.2 overs after lunch.
How about instead of losing 8 overs (2 for change of innings), you aim for a lunch declaration?
Will we still win? 97% yes. Could those 8 overs make a difference at the end of the match. Unlikely, but still possibly!!!!!
Dot the i's, cross the t's ....... it what the best sides do!!!!!
But we won the WTC , surely that means we are the best side 😉

Don't think the weather is a factor , they are not getting the runs , might even run through them today.

Maybe they need a bonus point system for winning in a certain time
 
Last edited:

Rowsus

Statistician
Joined
19 Mar 2012
Messages
29,137
Likes
64,919
AFL Club
Melbourne
Is your $ 190,000.00 including match payments ?

Under their new contract deal Category C & D players are paid USD 2650.00 to USD 5300.00 approximately per month

Category B get USD 10,600.00 approximately per month (only 6 players)

Babar , Rizwan & Shaheen are the only Category A players on USD 15,900.00 approximately per month.
Hard to know exactly what % of their annual salary is Test Match fees.

10,600 x 12 = $127,000 + 7 x $6,000 = $169,000 (ave 7.5 Tests/year the past 10 years)

When players have so many other sources of income outside of Test Cricket, $9,000 and a WTC point means nothing to them!!!!
 
Joined
25 Jul 2012
Messages
47,728
Likes
107,811
AFL Club
Collingwood
Hard to know exactly what % of their annual salary is Test Match fees.

10,600 x 12 = $127,000 + 7 x $6,000 = $169,000 (ave 7.5 Tests/year the past 10 years)

When players have so many other sources of income outside of Test Cricket, $9,000 and a WTC point means nothing to them!!!!
Interesting that the only one of the 6 category B players only Imam is here , Naseem injured.

144% increase in the Contract , 50% increase in Test match payment.

Certainly agree though over rates in all forms of cricket remain a problem.

Fines don't work , suspending the captain's hasn't worked maybe they need to start deducting runs (significant) from the score.

Pakistan cricketers might be (still) making a lot of money elsewhere from other sources 🤔.

I think they are now only allowed to play in 2 (possibly)-3 outside T10/T20 Leagues , obviously not the IPL
 
Top