Opinion 2024: Rookie Roulette
- Thread starter KLo30
- Start date
.
Have 3 loops that have landed in that awkward area for a best 18 round (best 22 would be a no brainer!).
Def: Williams (70) vs Howes or D’Ambrosio
Need to take 2 scores.
Mid & For: Sharp (71), Lazaro (64) vs Roberts, Sanders, Wilson, Clarke, Reid, Dempsey.
Need to take 6 scores.
I’m currently thinking I pass on Williams and chase upside from D’Ambrosio and Howes in defence.
Across the forward and mid lines, thinking I’ll take Sharp’s 70 and bench Clarke, but pass on Lazzaro’s 64.
Current lowest score is McKerchers 74 so Sharp essentially becomes my floor.
Thoughts?
Def: Williams (70) vs Howes or D’Ambrosio
Need to take 2 scores.
Mid & For: Sharp (71), Lazaro (64) vs Roberts, Sanders, Wilson, Clarke, Reid, Dempsey.
Need to take 6 scores.
I’m currently thinking I pass on Williams and chase upside from D’Ambrosio and Howes in defence.
Across the forward and mid lines, thinking I’ll take Sharp’s 70 and bench Clarke, but pass on Lazzaro’s 64.
Current lowest score is McKerchers 74 so Sharp essentially becomes my floor.
Thoughts?
For me it is Williams (70) vs Howes so I'm taking the 70 with D'Ambrosio on field already.
I'm taking Lazzaro (64) over Windsor in the forwards.
For mids I'm taking Sharp (71) over Wilson, with Roberts, Reid, McKercher (74), Sanders and Clark all on field.
Think those 70's are all solid enough, Lazzaro score over Windsor is sound and in the hand so I'll take them.
For you I'd run with Sharp, Roberts, Sanders, Clark, Reid and Dempsey over Wilson and Lazzaro.
Things to consider is will Sanders be impacted by return of Macrae and will he be sub/subbed?
Clark without Dangerfield, should be a positive?
Roberts only 1 kick-in the last 2 weeks hasn't negatively effected his scores, Lloyd took 6 last week so his wing role has shifted from the first 2 weeks?
Thought Reid was better than the 63 he got last week, so I'd run with him.
I'm taking Lazzaro (64) over Windsor in the forwards.
For mids I'm taking Sharp (71) over Wilson, with Roberts, Reid, McKercher (74), Sanders and Clark all on field.
Think those 70's are all solid enough, Lazzaro score over Windsor is sound and in the hand so I'll take them.
For you I'd run with Sharp, Roberts, Sanders, Clark, Reid and Dempsey over Wilson and Lazzaro.
Things to consider is will Sanders be impacted by return of Macrae and will he be sub/subbed?
Clark without Dangerfield, should be a positive?
Roberts only 1 kick-in the last 2 weeks hasn't negatively effected his scores, Lloyd took 6 last week so his wing role has shifted from the first 2 weeks?
Thought Reid was better than the 63 he got last week, so I'd run with him.
I think in a best 22 scenario, I would take Williams over Howes, but start D'Ambrosio. In a best 18 I think it's not so clear, but would probably just take the 70 over Howes.
I agree with taking Sharp and would bench Clark, I think that means taking Sanders, Roberts and Wilson
If it's 64 v starting Reid and Dempsey, I would probably start both over the 64.
Pretty much what @wolfbunny said.
I agree with taking Sharp and would bench Clark, I think that means taking Sanders, Roberts and Wilson
If it's 64 v starting Reid and Dempsey, I would probably start both over the 64.
Pretty much what @wolfbunny said.