Discussion 2024: NRL Supercoach Discussion

[tso]

 

[Dravid]

 

[Jobsdone23]

Lomax or kiraz ?

 

[Old Boomer]

Lomax or kiraz ?

Kiraz for me

 

[Dravid]

Lomax or kiraz ?

Kiraz for me

I'm looking to bring in Lomax this week (admittedly I've had Kiraz from round 1).

 

[T43597]

Favourable teams. 19 green dots, Curran & Lawton benched as 18th & 19th players. Cleary VC, Turbo C

 

[Woosie]

Lomax or kiraz ?

That's tough. I have both.

Dragons do have to play well to make the top 8. Bulldogs are already in.
I think Lomax will need to get his hands on the ball more, and be instructed to do it.

Bulldogs will be wanting to make the top 4. Kiraz will be a big part of that.

I think I would lean Lomax.

 

[Gazza's Treats]

Really stuffed my plan of playing Henry with JFH coming in and smith shifting to 2RF.... now I got to play Katoa

 

[Cheerio]

Really stuffed my plan of playing Henry with JFH coming in and smith shifting to 2RF.... now I got to play Katoa

It's one of those weeks where it's hard to gauge sit vs starts. Playing Katoa & Marzhew. Sitting Isaako & J Hughes

 

[Gazza's Treats]

It's one of those weeks where it's hard to gauge sit vs starts. Playing Katoa & Marzhew. Sitting Isaako & J Hughes

SC Gods had a plan so I didn't play Henry maybe

 

[nmh94]

It's one of those weeks where it's hard to gauge sit vs starts. Playing Katoa & Marzhew. Sitting Isaako & J Hughes

Yep a very hard week to select the 17. I have sat J Hughes and Koloamatangi. Wishing I picked Hughes atm!

 

[Gazza's Treats]

Interest Cleary on 0 in RDT but 25 in SC still 7 minutes to go in the first half

 

[tso]

View attachment 76705
View attachment 76706

Interest Cleary on 0 in RDT but 25 in SC still 7 minutes to go in the first half

On 8 now. Was -8 RDT

 

[Gazza's Treats]

On 8 now. Was -8 RDT

29 in SC 6 in RDT but still scorers rate his involvement different

 

[Broar]

That Panthers penalty just before halftime is an interesting call for me.

The Panthers challenge something are shown to be incorrect, mid challenge half the team yell at the ref about the o***ide so the video ref looks at it.

The second thing is I don't think I've ever seen a team penalised for being o***ide at the 20tap. The ref always calls them back and let them tap again. (Although a break in play might change things I guess)

Lastly several Panthers players are o***ide at the tap as well.

Not sure I like that call thinking about all those things.

 

[Connoisseur]

29 in SC 6 in RDT but still scorers rate his involvement different

Supercoach scoring system:


Sportsdeck scoring system:



Try contribution not in Sportsdeck, Goals worth double in SC, missed tackle worth triple in Sportsdeck, forced dropout not in sportsdeck, line break assist worth double in SC, hitups not included in Sportsdeck.

 

[Spots]

Seriously NRL it’s a simple game, I don’t understand how so many decisions get made that are completely opposite to what the commentators and viewers see. Storm have been screwed over tonight, that send off was BS as was the call on the Papenhauzen kick

 

[Gazza's Treats]

Supercoach scoring system:
View attachment 76707

Sportsdeck scoring system:

View attachment 76708

Try contribution not in Sportsdeck, Goals worth double in SC, missed tackle worth triple in Sportsdeck, forced dropout not in sportsdeck, line break assist worth double in SC, hitups not included in Sportsdeck.

Thxs Mate... I do know somewhat but still don't agree on the scoring system... keeping in mind probably 160k Coaches do agree it has it's floors....

 

[Broar]

I think thats the fourth or fifth time that the Panthers have taken out an opposing teams outside back with foul play this season, yet still no sin bin.

 

[Old Boomer]

You are just not allowed to bin a Penrith player.....it's as simple as that