Position 2025: RUCK DISCUSSION
- Thread starter KLo30
- Start date
Definitely relies on Pittonet not playing, the difficult thing is actually knowing that, hey @Manikato1 The Blues early draw is mouth watering too, should help scoring for TDK around the ground where he excels.
Combine that with Xerri's average of 103 against opponents between rounds 2-7 then there's a case, in my mind anyway.
Combine that with Xerri's average of 103 against opponents between rounds 2-7 then there's a case, in my mind anyway.
Your last point is a good and potentially very important one when looking at rucks:
- Presumably teams are more likely to play a maturing ruck like TDK as sole ruck when they come up against weaker opponents. Pittonet is more likely to have been selected (instead or as well as TDK) against established, high quality rucks. The sample may be inherently skewed.
- In the second half of the season, quality rucks who are fit often smash first choice rucks who are beaten up after a long season, and/or the second or third stringers who come in to replace them after they break down.
- Presumably teams are more likely to play a maturing ruck like TDK as sole ruck when they come up against weaker opponents. Pittonet is more likely to have been selected (instead or as well as TDK) against established, high quality rucks. The sample may be inherently skewed.
- In the second half of the season, quality rucks who are fit often smash first choice rucks who are beaten up after a long season, and/or the second or third stringers who come in to replace them after they break down.
- Joined
- 7 Sep 2020
- Messages
- 13,236
- Likes
- 46,560
- Joined
- 18 Feb 2019
- Messages
- 1,377
- Likes
- 5,795
- AFL Club
- Carlton
That is the problem with TDK. I believe Carlton prefers TDK as the sole ruck and could easily start the season in that role and score very well. But not sure he can run out a full season and Pittonet is still a solid ruckman, can see Pittonet come in to lessen the load on TDK, especially against the bigger rucks and with a fairly easy draw this year even rested late in the year.
TDK is definitely a starting option as his scoring can be huge as solo ruck, but i fully expect a trade will be needed later in the year when he starts to tire and Pittonet becomes an issue. Expect Pittonet to still play 25% of the season.
TDK is definitely a starting option as his scoring can be huge as solo ruck, but i fully expect a trade will be needed later in the year when he starts to tire and Pittonet becomes an issue. Expect Pittonet to still play 25% of the season.
Last edited:
N Bryan (ESS) and S De Koning (GEE), limited chatter about each (maybe for good reason). From what limited I’ve read Bryan has been sharing with Draper in match sim’s and Conway is injured and De Koning is training in ruck this preseason. Could be 2 decent mid pricer ruck options?
Any Essendon and/or Geelong fans can shed some light on each?
Any Essendon and/or Geelong fans can shed some light on each?
Bryan is the future but ruck share roles are SC poison!
Personally I think the rucks are too important to get creative and take those kinds of risks. If SDK was the only ruck option he’s maybe useful as a defender position, but I think the premiums and mid price options are already too good to need that level of speculation.
Personally I think the rucks are too important to get creative and take those kinds of risks. If SDK was the only ruck option he’s maybe useful as a defender position, but I think the premiums and mid price options are already too good to need that level of speculation.
SDK is DEF only and definitely worth a look if he's rucking full time. Would be a temporary play only if it's not long term and given how insanely bad he was last year in the role it's really hard to see it as a long term think. Could definitely score well in the role though for fantasy purposes.
I like Bryan as a player but with Goldy and Draper looming under a coach who has always prioritised win now at all costs over the future I find it hard to pick him either. Needs that clear runway for mine because he's always one poor game in a loss from the reserves under Scott who will absolutely play who he thinks gives him a chance to win a few games now.
I like Bryan as a player but with Goldy and Draper looming under a coach who has always prioritised win now at all costs over the future I find it hard to pick him either. Needs that clear runway for mine because he's always one poor game in a loss from the reserves under Scott who will absolutely play who he thinks gives him a chance to win a few games now.
Well, the Darcy news has put a little spanner in the works, was trying to fade Xerri because of his tough matchups and go against the crowd a little.
Looked at SDK because of his early start but Pittonet saying what he did stymied that option. Darcy's first 5 weeks are also juicy, so he was brought in. I'm not sure why the screw has been used, whether it's to help with syndesmosis or strengthen the ankle because of ligament damage, guess the timeline has been put back because the joint needs more time to strengthen once the screw is removed. It's not a soft tissue injury at least, but if he's not playing round 1 he's a 'no go'.
The $100k that was released by having him in the team now has to be found to replace him with Xerri, probably happier with that as I think it helps avoiding the ruck trade merry-go-round.
Looked at SDK because of his early start but Pittonet saying what he did stymied that option. Darcy's first 5 weeks are also juicy, so he was brought in. I'm not sure why the screw has been used, whether it's to help with syndesmosis or strengthen the ankle because of ligament damage, guess the timeline has been put back because the joint needs more time to strengthen once the screw is removed. It's not a soft tissue injury at least, but if he's not playing round 1 he's a 'no go'.
The $100k that was released by having him in the team now has to be found to replace him with Xerri, probably happier with that as I think it helps avoiding the ruck trade merry-go-round.