2015: Rate My Team - Part II (SC Gold Team Picker Edition)

[IDIG]

Now that the SC Gold team picker is up and running, let's see em!

Please feel free to discuss your team and use the format:

D: D1, D2, D3, D4, D5, D6 (D7, D8)
M: M1, M2, M3, M4, M5, M6, M7, M8 (M9, M10, M11)
R: R1, R2 (R3)
F: F1, F2, F3, F4, F5, F6 (F7, F8)

 

[Gleeso]

First quick draft:

DEF: B. Smith - M. Hibberd - P. Seedsman - B. Waters - B. Jacobs - Z. Jones - (H. Goddard - A. Browne [T. Fields if upgraded])
MID: N. Fyfe - J. P. Kennedy - P. Dangerfield - O. Wines - L. Neale - M. Crouch - B. Acres - N. Freeman - (B. Hartung - B. Boekhorst - J. Laverde)
RUC: T. Goldstein - T. Bellchambers - (R. Lobb)
FWD: L. Franklin - D. Martin - H. Bennell - D. Smith - T. Membrey - J. Hogan - (J. Steele - C. Daniel)

Absolutely NOTHING to work with down back!

 

[Sandyboy]

OK, I'll be a guinea pig. Just opened up Supercoach gold teampicker, and as I always do each year looked for value. So here it is:

DEF: A. Walker, J. Newnes, D. Rampe, P. Seedsmand, B. Whitecross (fingers crossed Whitey gets up this year), Rookie 1, Rookie 2.

MIDS: Ablett, A. Treloar, D. Swan, D. Rich, N. Van Berlo (not sure why?), B. Hill, J. O'Rourke, 4 Rookies.

RUC: Bellchambers, Goldstein, Rookie RUC/FWD

FWD: Delidio, Ryder, Bennell, Christensen, Bonti, Walters, Hogan, Rookie.

An interesting first draft, will see what it is like after draft 1,000,000?????

 

[IDIG]

Don't think i've seen two teams posted that were so different. I love it.

I reckon this might be the year we see less identical teams with so many tough decisions to be made in each position. Especially with which top end midfielders we invest in and how many premo fwds we start with.

 

[Eagling]

Alright, let's see what I can do on the first go through.

$91, 900 remaining.

DEF: Malceski, Simpson, Shaw, Thompson, Seedsman, Moore (Scharenberg, Goddard)

MID: Ablett, Pendlebury, Fyfe, Selwood, Ward, Heeney, Laverde, Freeman (Dumont, Krakeour, Saad)

RUC: Kreuzer, Leuenberger (Cox)

FWD: Deledio, Swan, Bellchambers, Beams, Vardy, Clark (Karnezis, Hogan)

 

[Feerits Elf]

^ Scharenberg is injured

 

[jo_el]

Defenders:
Michael Hibberd [ESS] ($491,500)
Corey Enright [GEE] ($478,400)
Paul Seedsman [COL] ($363,100)
Gary Rohan [SYD] ($272,100)
Beau Waters [WCE] ($267,200)
Darcy Byrne-Jones [PTA] ($123,900)
Hugh Goddard [STK] [FWD] ($122,300)
Brayden Maynard [COL] [MID] ($117,300)

Midfielders:
Gary Ablett [GCS] ($734,600)
Scott Pendlebury [COL] ($668,800)
Joel Selwood [GEE] ($649,900)
Dane Swan [COL] [FWD] ($464,500)
Christian Petracca [MEL] [FWD] ($217,300)
Isaac Heeney [SYD] ($137,300)
Blaine Boekhorst [CAR] ($132,300)
Aaron Vandenberg [MEL] ($127,900)
Rory Sloane [ADE] ($616,900)
Jayden Laverde [ESS] [FWD] ($127,300)
Nathan Freeman [COL] ($123,900)

Rucks:
Nic Naitanui [WCE] ($488,300)
Matthew Kreuzer [CAR] ($370,900)
Jonathon Griffin [FRE] ($242,300)

Forwards:
Brendon Goddard [ESS] [MID] ($548,800)
Lance Franklin [SYD] ($537,200)
Dustin Martin [RIC] [MID] ($534,900)
Tom Mitchell [SYD] [MID] ($405,600)
Paddy McCartin [STK] ($222,300)
Mitch Clark [GEE] ($155,200)
Jesse Hogan [MEL] ($130,400)
Caleb Daniel [WBD] ($117,300)

 

[Eagling]

^ Scharenberg is injured

That's what I get for not paying attention over the last three months.

 

[yakka]

YAKKA'S V1

Defenders
Hodge, L $492,000 (mid)
Hibberd, M $491,500
Newnes, J $436,800 (mid)
Waters, B $267,200
Jones, Z $182,800
Mayes, S $369,100 (mid)
Goddard, H $122,300 (fwd)
McKenzie, D$117,300 (mid)

Midfielders
Fyfe, N $657,600
Watson, J $574,800
Heppell, D $571,800
Dangerfield, P $567,600
Mitchell, S $490,000
Hartung, B $195,800
Heeney, I $137,300
Vandenberg, A $127,9000
Laverde, J $127,300 (fwd)
Freeman, N$123,900
Lambert, K $102,400 (fwd)

Rucks
Naitanui, N $488,300
Bellchambers, T $302,500 (fwd)
Wright, P $187,300 (fwd)

Forwards
Bartel, J $549,000
Goddard, B $548,800 (mid)
Bennell, H $514,600 (mid)
Swan, D $464,500 (mid)
Garlett, J $259,200
Salem, C $185,000
Moore, D $182,300 (Def)
Saad, A $151,100

257,200 remaining
Just a rough 1st draft..

 

[Drew]

First crack...

Mid: Pendles, Selwood, Sloane, Wines, Crouch, Crouch, Greenwood, Van Berlo, Laverde, Freeman, Stretch
Fwd: Ryder, Swan, Pav, Bontempelli, Clark, Hogan, Petracca, Krakouer
Def: Birchall, Lumumba, Cheney, Lever, Durdin, Maynard, Moore, Marchbank
Ruck: Kreuzer, Luenburger, Cox

$203k remaining.

 

[BC]

Back: Smith, Birchall, Waters, N. Brown, Lever, Barras ( Fuller, Kolodjashnij)

Mid: Ablett, Pendles, Fyfe, Selwood, Jpk, Freeman, Heeney, Barrat, Dumont (Ballard, Steele)

Ruck: Goldstein, Kreuzer (Griffen)

Fwd: Deledio, D.Smith, Swan, Dahlhaus, Mitchell, Clark (Krakouer, Karnezis)

Backline rookies please supercoach gods.
Rookies are just to fill the gaps.
Thoughts?

 

[Ricky Bobby]

Most people seem to be picking Kreuzer over L'Berger. Is Berger injured or just not rated

 

[Rickwood]

/\ I'd suggest it's the likelihood of being the #1 ruck, vs the Stefan Martin syndrome at the Lions

 

[Junior Wölf]

Defenders
Smith, Brodie $502800 (ADE) 93.5
Hibberd, Michael $491500 (ESS) 91.4
Newnes, Jack (MID) $436800 (STK) 81.3
McGuinness, Josh $117300 (BRL) 0
Rampe, Dane $408800 (SYD) 76
Waters, Beau $267200 (WCE) 0
Goddard, Hugh (FWD) $122300 (STK) 0
Newman, Nicholas $102400 (SYD) 0

Midfielders
Pendlebury, Scott $668800 (COL) 124.4
Fyfe, Nat $657600 (FRE) 122.3
Selwood, Joel $649900 (GEE) 120.9
Laverde, Jayden (FWD) $127300 (ESS) 0
Ward, Callan $606000 (GWS) 112.8
Steven, Jack $455900 (STK) 84.8
Boekhorst, Blaine $123300 (CAR) 0
Freeman, Nathan $123900 (COL) 0
Heeney, Isaac $137300 (SYD) 0
Smith, Clem $117300 (CAR) 0
Vandenberg, Aaron $127900 (MEL) 0

Rucks
Naitanui, Nic $488300 (WCE) 90.8
Bellchambers, Tom $302500 (ESS) 56.3
Nankervis, Toby $123900 (SYD) 0

Forwards
Franklin, Lance $537200 (SYD) 99.9
Martin, Dustin (MID) $534900 (RIC) 99.5
Bennell, Harley (MID) $514600 (GCS) 95.7
Hogan, Jesse $130400 (MEL) 0
Swan, Dane (MID) $464500 (COL) 86.4
Mitchell, Tom (MID) $405600 (SYD) 83.8
Karnezis, Patrick $133500 (COL) 0
Lambert, Kane (MID) $102400 (RIC) 0

 

[Drew]

Defenders
Smith, Brodie $502800 (ADE) 93.5
Hibberd, Michael $491500 (ESS) 91.4
Newnes, Jack (MID) $436800 (STK) 81.3
McGuinness, Josh $117300 (BRL) 0
Rampe, Dane$408800 (SYD) 76
Waters, Beau $267200 (WCE) 0
Goddard, Hugh (FWD) $122300 (STK) 0
Newman, Nicholas $102400 (SYD) 0

Midfielders
Pendlebury, Scott $668800 (COL) 124.4
Fyfe, Nat $657600 (FRE) 122.3
Selwood, Joel $649900 (GEE) 120.9
Laverde, Jayden (FWD) $127300 (ESS) 0
Ward, Callan $606000 (GWS) 112.8
Steven, Jack $455900 (STK) 84.8
Boekhorst, Blaine $123300 (CAR) 0
Freeman, Nathan $123900 (COL) 0
Heeney, Isaac $137300 (SYD) 0
Smith, Clem $117300 (CAR) 0
Vandenberg, Aaron $127900 (MEL) 0

Rucks
Naitanui, Nic $488300 (WCE) 90.8
Bellchambers, Tom $302500 (ESS) 56.3
Nankervis, Toby $123900 (SYD) 0

Forwards
Franklin, Lance $537200 (SYD) 99.9
Martin, Dustin (MID) $534900 (RIC) 99.5
Bennell, Harley (MID) $514600 (GCS) 95.7
Hogan, Jesse $130400 (MEL) 0
Swan, Dane (MID) $464500 (COL) 86.4
Mitchell, Tom (MID) $405600 (SYD) 83.8
Karnezis, Patrick $133500 (COL) 0
Lambert, Kane (MID) $102400 (RIC) 0

Thoughts on Rampe this year?

 

[Junior Wölf]

Thoughts on Rampe this year?

No idea. Just trying to find a Swans player to replace Malceski's half back position. Rampe could fit the bill.

 

[Drew]

No idea. Just trying to find a Swans player to replace Malceski's half back position. Rampe could fit the bill.

Hmm thanks, looking like Defence will be the rubicks cube of SC2015!

 

[Zim^zuM]

Not going to pay too much attention to it, just fiddled slightly to get a feel of the dollars. Having a team set makes it easier to tinker later.

Very first rough draft.

Shaw, Hibberd, Higgins, Savage, Waters, Moore (Delaney, Goddard)

Ablett, Fyfe, Sloane, Ward, Steven, Rich, Cockatoo, C Ellis (Freeman, Laverde, Krakouer)

Goldstein, Kreuzer (Durdin)

Deledio, Goddard, Swan, Membery, Clark, Saad (Hogan, Daniel)

Higgins and Savage :/ The last 4 fwds shows I'm still needing more info about cheap fwds. No from this template though I can start proper research

 

[Junior Wölf]

Hmm thanks, looking like Defence will be the rubicks cube of SC2015!

Yep. But the good thing is that everyone else is in the same boat. The winner of 2015 supercoach will have to nail his "premos" down back and find the real "needle in the haystack". Real risk vs reward this year.

 

[Junior Wölf]

Not going to pay too much attention to it, just fiddled slightly to get a feel of the dollars. Having a team set makes it easier to tinker later.

Very first rough draft.

Shaw, Hibberd, Higgins, Savage, Waters, Moore (Delaney, Goddard)

Ablett, Fyfe, Sloane, Ward, Steven, Rich, Cockatoo, C Ellis (Freeman, Laverde, Krakouer)

Goldstein, Kreuzer (Durdin)

Deledio, Goddard, Swan, Membery, Clark, Saad (Hogan, Daniel)

Higgins and Savage :/ The last 4 fwds shows I'm still needing more info about cheap fwds. No from this template though I can start proper research

I feel you are a bit light in FWD. I myself will be stacking 4 premos and Tommy Mitchell in forward line. I do like the Shane Savage pick down back. Had a better second half of the year. Couldn't watch any games but I think he moved to a running half back. Very tempting with Saints first half of the season.