Round 1: Teams and In Game Discussion
- Thread starter IDIG
- Start date
Interesting discussion on those with E on McIntosh, I'm in the same situation.
Not sure if I will change my team to bring in a floating donut yet, particularly as I also have Lids to deal with.
Anyway, while disappointed with my players tonight, have to remember its just one game. Some interesting decisions to make by Saturday.
Not sure if I will change my team to bring in a floating donut yet, particularly as I also have Lids to deal with.
Anyway, while disappointed with my players tonight, have to remember its just one game. Some interesting decisions to make by Saturday.
Yep, please see edit before your post 
Anyway, we'll wait and see... probably another year where he hovers around the top 10 - 15 forwards. If he escapes the tag and is allowed to run free then he can do well, but too often he'll be locked out of games unable to break tags. Doesn't seem to have the strength of character to rise to the next level I don't think, might be proven wrong, just my impression of him from his off-field actions, talks and interviews. We'll revisit his scores in a few weeks
Anyway, we'll wait and see... probably another year where he hovers around the top 10 - 15 forwards. If he escapes the tag and is allowed to run free then he can do well, but too often he'll be locked out of games unable to break tags. Doesn't seem to have the strength of character to rise to the next level I don't think, might be proven wrong, just my impression of him from his off-field actions, talks and interviews. We'll revisit his scores in a few weeks
- Joined
- 13 Nov 2014
- Messages
- 369
- Likes
- 529
- AFL Club
- Port Adelaide
How about this - biggest bonehead mixed with dumbass luck.
In my haste to get away for the weekend, I forgot to check my friggin capt selection and turns out I had the C on McIntosh.
Had no right to dodge that bullet.
In my haste to get away for the weekend, I forgot to check my friggin capt selection and turns out I had the C on McIntosh.
Had no right to dodge that bullet.
Nice work on McIntosh...LOL
- Joined
- 23 Mar 2012
- Messages
- 19,855
- Likes
- 929
- AFL Club
- Carlton
He will be but not playing round one was a bit tricky to still keep him in your SC team.
I had him in the night before Geelong played Carlton in last NAB Cup game. It was my first genuine look at what rookies looked him being there for round one that weekend. After the game was very happy to have good intentions of keeping him as there did not appear too many defense rookies showing up but once he was not named for round one I was not willing to keep. If he plays at a time that does not help me in SC then not much point. But he will play for Carlton in games this season for sure. Malthouse is only one who really knows when.
I had him in the night before Geelong played Carlton in last NAB Cup game. It was my first genuine look at what rookies looked him being there for round one that weekend. After the game was very happy to have good intentions of keeping him as there did not appear too many defense rookies showing up but once he was not named for round one I was not willing to keep. If he plays at a time that does not help me in SC then not much point. But he will play for Carlton in games this season for sure. Malthouse is only one who really knows when.