Opinion Player X vs Player Y
- Thread starter yakka
- Start date
- Joined
- 21 May 2012
- Messages
- 22,312
- Likes
- 31,158
- AFL Club
- Hawthorn
Might be a difference in approach here 
When I see a player eight years in who has had the best year of their career, that makes me not want to pick them.
Harvey has also played more games than Rioli in 7 of the last 8 years, and is cheaper.
When I see a player eight years in who has had the best year of their career, that makes me not want to pick them.Harvey has also played more games than Rioli in 7 of the last 8 years, and is cheaper.
- Joined
- 19 Jun 2012
- Messages
- 8,560
- Likes
- 11,561
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
- Joined
- 8 Jan 2014
- Messages
- 6,968
- Likes
- 11,084
- AFL Club
- Melbourne
Might be a difference in approach here When I see a player eight years in who has had the best year of their career, that makes me not want to pick them.
Harvey has also played more games than Rioli in 7 of the last 8 years, and is cheaper.
When I see a player eight years in who has had the best year of their career, that makes me not want to pick them.Harvey has also played more games than Rioli in 7 of the last 8 years, and is cheaper.
The main reason I wouldn't want to pick a ninth year player who has just had a career best year is their price. I don't want to be choosing players priced at what is likely to be their max output, especially if they have played long enough for their "level" to have been set already. I wouldn't go anywhere near someone like Armitage, for example.
Rioli is actually priced seven points below his career best, and has beaten his 2015 average three times, and essentially matched it once. On this basis, price is not a strong argument against picking him (in absolute terms - Harvey and others are still lower-priced/may be more attractively priced). I assumed from Goodie's comments that Rioli had had his best SC year in 2015. Given that he hasn't, it might be worth thinking about whether he is now in a less SC-friendly role, given that he may have had his best (footy) year but not bested his previous SC highs. Something to consider for anyone looking at picking him.
- Joined
- 6 Jan 2013
- Messages
- 19,073
- Likes
- 80,337
- AFL Club
- Melbourne
- Joined
- 26 Feb 2014
- Messages
- 3,147
- Likes
- 3,311
- AFL Club
- Hawthorn
As a Hawk, I probably wouldn't go with Cyril - not because of his injuries, but because his scoring last year was down and it was his best year in terms of consistency. When I say down, in the games in which we say he played well - he didn't score that high. I just think that as he is playing more as a forward, he will see less of the ball and won't be a high SC scorer. Example... look at the Grand Final. Had a ripper of a game and just scored over 100...
I wouldn't go Harvey either to be honest - I'd prefer Mitch Robinson <--- scary i know... but tackling and contested ball work is great in this game.
I wouldn't go Harvey either to be honest - I'd prefer Mitch Robinson <--- scary i know... but tackling and contested ball work is great in this game.
My feeling is they have decided running Cyril in the mids too much is too much of an injury risk and so his ceiling becomes what he scored last year. That doesn't make him a bad pick I'm just not seeing much upside there.
Greene is similarly priced are people looking at him as will of those 3 or only taking one?
Greene is similarly priced are people looking at him as will of those 3 or only taking one?
- Joined
- 8 Jan 2014
- Messages
- 6,968
- Likes
- 11,084
- AFL Club
- Melbourne
Crouch v JOM
Most teams seem to be selecting Crouch in this equation and I presume it is because he seems to be more advanced with his recovery (although this is only a guess).
Who would you pick based on current fitness reports and then who would you pick if both were fully recovered and ready for Round 1?
Most teams seem to be selecting Crouch in this equation and I presume it is because he seems to be more advanced with his recovery (although this is only a guess).
Who would you pick based on current fitness reports and then who would you pick if both were fully recovered and ready for Round 1?