Opinion Rate My Team
- Thread starter Impromptu
- Start date
D: Laird, Birchall, Rich, Sheridan, Cutler, Weitering (Hartley, Broad)
M: Dangerfield, Priddis, Treloar, Liberatore, Steele, Lyons, Mills, Parish (Polec, Crowley, Macaffer)
R: Martin, Gawn (Cox)
F: Barlow, S.Gray, Stringer, D.Menzel, Wells, Kerridge (B.Kennedy, L.McCarthy)
Have to obviously wait until teams are up for round 1, but most of these have had solid NAB efforts and form is form.
Still a bit iffy on Polec though, and have a few coming back from injury in the squad, but that's the risk I'm happy to take.
Also probably a risk on Sheridan, Cutler, Steele, Lyons and Parish, as I have no idea who they actually are and had to google Hartley.
M: Dangerfield, Priddis, Treloar, Liberatore, Steele, Lyons, Mills, Parish (Polec, Crowley, Macaffer)
R: Martin, Gawn (Cox)
F: Barlow, S.Gray, Stringer, D.Menzel, Wells, Kerridge (B.Kennedy, L.McCarthy)
Have to obviously wait until teams are up for round 1, but most of these have had solid NAB efforts and form is form.
Still a bit iffy on Polec though, and have a few coming back from injury in the squad, but that's the risk I'm happy to take.
Also probably a risk on Sheridan, Cutler, Steele, Lyons and Parish, as I have no idea who they actually are and had to google Hartley.
Last edited:
- Joined
- 28 Feb 2013
- Messages
- 1,292
- Likes
- 268
hi alecee
nice team however i would upgrade your midfield and downgrade your defence. i would downgrade smith to a rookie maybe dea and use that money to upgrade libba. also i would change hibberd to an oliver or bkennedy to strengthen the midfields.
rucks are set and forget i think gawn is in for a big year and i love your forwards.
nice team however i would upgrade your midfield and downgrade your defence. i would downgrade smith to a rookie maybe dea and use that money to upgrade libba. also i would change hibberd to an oliver or bkennedy to strengthen the midfields.
rucks are set and forget i think gawn is in for a big year and i love your forwards.
Backs and Rucks are fine for mine. Team overall is similar to mine in many ways.
I'm unsure all your mid rookies are set to play (immediately), Gresham, Gore, Keays and Hibberd haven't exactly locked themselves in over NAB. Suggest Menadue is probably missing as an obvious one.
Perhaps a little deep in fwds? Don't mind it though, thinking of doing something similar.
I'm unsure all your mid rookies are set to play (immediately), Gresham, Gore, Keays and Hibberd haven't exactly locked themselves in over NAB. Suggest Menadue is probably missing as an obvious one.
Perhaps a little deep in fwds? Don't mind it though, thinking of doing something similar.
Everything's fine with some good PODs, my main issue is you only have 3.3k left and no room for Gresham or Hewett. Keays probably won't get games and Gresham has shown potential to be a decent rookie option. I'd sacrifice one of your premiums somewhere to fit in Gresham over Keays. It's a tough one but maybe Simpson out for someone else and allow some flexibility to fit in Gresham.
Ok guys and gals.
I currently have around a dozen teams written down. This one was done during the first week of the NAB games and forgotten about.
With the NAB games now completed, this team suddenly starts to look a little better.
Seems cookie cutter ish with a few pods thrown in. (risky).
My concern is that it's possibly too mid price heavy. Can it create enough funds to build on. We seem to have limited cheap mid rookies to pick from so we are almost forced to go with the more expensive rookies.
R Laird, J Bartel, G Birchall, B Smith, M Brown, M Adams.
(M Hartley, T Ruggles.)
P Dangerfield, G Ablett, D Shiel, T Rockliff, O Wines, T Liberatore, D Wells, C Mills.
(G Hewett, C Adamson, R Davis.)
T Goldstein, M Gawn. (M King.)
M Barlow, M Robinson, A Hall, D Menzel, B Kennedy, S Kerridge.
(L McCarthy, A Tipungwuti.)
Thoughts - Forward line to risky ?
Thinking Mitch Robinson will get plenty of time in the midfield now due to Beams. A Hall's NAB scores very hard to ignore also.
I currently have around a dozen teams written down. This one was done during the first week of the NAB games and forgotten about.
With the NAB games now completed, this team suddenly starts to look a little better.
Seems cookie cutter ish with a few pods thrown in. (risky).
My concern is that it's possibly too mid price heavy. Can it create enough funds to build on. We seem to have limited cheap mid rookies to pick from so we are almost forced to go with the more expensive rookies.
R Laird, J Bartel, G Birchall, B Smith, M Brown, M Adams.
(M Hartley, T Ruggles.)
P Dangerfield, G Ablett, D Shiel, T Rockliff, O Wines, T Liberatore, D Wells, C Mills.
(G Hewett, C Adamson, R Davis.)
T Goldstein, M Gawn. (M King.)
M Barlow, M Robinson, A Hall, D Menzel, B Kennedy, S Kerridge.
(L McCarthy, A Tipungwuti.)
Thoughts - Forward line to risky ?
Thinking Mitch Robinson will get plenty of time in the midfield now due to Beams. A Hall's NAB scores very hard to ignore also.
