Opinion Player X vs Player Y
- Thread starter yakka
- Start date
Thanks all for your responses. Funnily enough i was very sure which i'd be going with but alot of the responses went against my first thoughts so will put some more thought into it.
As lakb mentioned Rance whilst averaging 96 has only tonned up once in his last 7 games (ave 89) so he's as concerning as McVeigh i suppose...maybe not to Yeo's level but as stephen said, role change and lots of home games could see him string some big games together.
Hanners reads like a super-premo but has been down somewhat recently, averaging 105 his last 5 and less than 100 his last 3. Not sure if there's a reason why but he's numbers have still been pretty good?
Fwiw i was pretty confident i'd be going with Priddis/Simpson for similar reasons to meataxe. Now i might just have to fiddle with the combos a bit more to see what i can come up with. Sloane looks like a good option so one i could throw in as well.
As lakb mentioned Rance whilst averaging 96 has only tonned up once in his last 7 games (ave 89) so he's as concerning as McVeigh i suppose...maybe not to Yeo's level but as stephen said, role change and lots of home games could see him string some big games together.
Hanners reads like a super-premo but has been down somewhat recently, averaging 105 his last 5 and less than 100 his last 3. Not sure if there's a reason why but he's numbers have still been pretty good?
Fwiw i was pretty confident i'd be going with Priddis/Simpson for similar reasons to meataxe. Now i might just have to fiddle with the combos a bit more to see what i can come up with. Sloane looks like a good option so one i could throw in as well.
- Joined
- 26 Feb 2014
- Messages
- 3,147
- Likes
- 3,311
- AFL Club
- Hawthorn
Hanners for me. JPK is a beast no doubting that however when parker and mitchell were doing well JPK did not. When Mitchell dropped JPK and Parker did well. When Parker dropped JPK Mitchell did well. So there is a plus there for JPK for sure, however hanners did not drop at all through that whole period. He appears not only to be safer, but very reliable.
Thats exactly how I was thinking , Hanners obviously being the safe pick but I see JPK having a much higher ceiling if he can hold his spot at clearances, I think I will go with Hanners just priced very well at the moment and almost risk free at that price, Parker at his price is also an option but he's in way too many teams in the top 100 need something different
