Opinion Player X vs Player Y

[teatai]

Pittard v Howe (dpp)

 

[dicksilverman]

Howe probably

 

[Eagling]

Neale v Bontempelli for me.

I'm really struggling to split the two.

One possible tiebreaker I'm considering is to check the potential for VC/C loopholes.

Round 17: Neale v Geelong, Bontempelli v Gold Coast. Advantage Bontempelli

Round 18: Neale v Gold Coast, Bontempelli v St Kilda. Advantage Neale by virtue of Dangerfield playing at the same time.

Round 19: Bontempelli v Geelong, Neale v Sydney. Advantage Neale

Round 20: Bontempelli v North Melbourne, Neale v West Coast. Tie.

Round 21: Bontempelli v Collingwood, Neale v Adelaide. Slight advantage Neale as I have Pendlebury as an option, but no Crows.

Round 22: Neale v GWS, Bontempelli v Essendon. Advantage Neale as Dangerfield overlaps with Bontempelli.

Round 23: Neale v Bontempelli. Tie

It seems like Neale is the better option based on VC/C potential. I must admit that I would be more inclined to be certain on Neale if he wasn't playing for Ross Lyon.

 

[blue dreamer]

Don't know if this is the right thread for this but it isn't worth a new one of it's own.

How do we think Lycett will go against Gawn, would it be better to play Kerridge on the field?

In x v y parlance Lycett v Kerridge for this week only.

 

[KLo30]

Don't know if this is the right thread for this but it isn't worth a new one of it's own.

How do we think Lycett will go against Gawn, would it be better to play Kerridge on the field?

In x v y parlance Lycett v Kerridge for this week only.

Kerridge ahead of Lycett without evening looking at who Carlton play. Though Lycett did reasonably well against Goldstein at home.

 

[30BucketsofRo]

Got 477,200 to spend on a forward.

Franklin vs Lynch vs Riewoltd or any other decent target?

Conversely, could also wait for Dahl to come whack or Howe to drop in price?

 

[urqa23]

Zorko Vs Zerrett?

 

[30BucketsofRo]

Zorko Vs Zerrett?

Lot of love for both the Z's but Zerrett at the minute with Brisbane looking flat as a tack

 

[blue dreamer]

Don't know if this is the right thread for this but it isn't worth a new one of it's own.

How do we think Lycett will go against Gawn, would it be better to play Kerridge on the field?

In x v y parlance Lycett v Kerridge for this week only.

Kerridge ahead of Lycett without evening looking at who Carlton play. Though Lycett did reasonably well against Goldstein at home.

Thanks Klo, I think I am leaning that way too but usually try to stick with my premos where possible.

 

[IDIG]

Got 477,200 to spend on a forward.

Franklin vs Lynch vs Riewoltd or any other decent target?

Conversely, could also wait for Dahl to come whack or Howe to drop in price?

Similar position as yourself. I'd probably go buddy if I were you but it's a bit boring I know.

I'm also considering Westhoff and as crazy as it sounds Rioli. I'm hoping lids gets up but pretty unlikely it seems.

 

[The MC]

Josh J Kennedy v Toby Greene

To play this week and likely be loopholed for the remainder of the year where possible.

 

[Ben's Beasts]

Josh J Kennedy v Toby Greene

To play this week and likely be loopholed for the remainder of the year where possible.

I think JJK will kick a bag against the Dees (unfortunately). So I would go with him this week.

Aside from the Eagles win against Port, JJK has only gone big in massive wins so I reckon you should go with JJK in games where the Eagles should dominate and go with Greene in games that the eagles are less likely to dominate.

 

[Steuby]

Battle of KPF for the rest of the year:

JJK VS Franklin VS Gunston VS T.Lynch (GCS) VS NROO

 

[craig freer]

Battle of KPF for the rest of the year:

JJK VS Franklin VS Gunston VS T.Lynch (GCS) VS NROO

Gunston for me.

 

[Johnsy44]

Greene vs Betts vs Lyons

 

[Goodie's Guns]

Greene vs Betts vs Lyons

Greene for me, although not convinced with any of them to be honest.

 

[Johnsy44]

Greene for me, although not convinced with any of them to be honest.

Issue is I only have 444k...

 

[Goodie's Guns]

Issue is I only have 444k...

Yeah presumed as much lol. Plenty struggling for coin at this stage.

I think I'd be more confident in Greene going between 80-130 each week than any of the other options.

 

[Johnsy44]

Yeah presumed as much lol. Plenty struggling for coin at this stage.

I think I'd be more confident in Greene going between 80-130 each week than any of the other options.

Thanks mate, will most likely go with him. Also considering Devon Smith as a huge pod at only 0.2%

 

[Johnsy44]

For my last trade...
Greene vs Devon Smith