I recall collingwood vs gold coast 2012, Pendlebury was my captain, had 19 possessions(10contested) 1 goal 72% DE or something by half time before being subbed. I had the subscription back then, and it showed that he scored 65, but he got scaled to 95, which is a good thing for me... But to be fair, the scaling was wayyyyy too much. Maybe the score allocater had pendlebury as his captain as well?
Nope... page 2 of Prospectus mentions that exact match and explains it
a good example of this in Round 10 last season when Scott Pendlebury was substituted half time with a knee injury against Gold Coast
they go on to explain he was on 76 ranking points at half time and took no further part in the match. Due to Colllingwood leading at half time by 45 points and winning by 97 points they write "proving the closest and most important part of the game was the first quarter"... once the game was over the first
half was re-scaled to reflect the blow out. 2010 of the possible 3300 ranking points allocated in the first half rather than 1650 split between each halves.
"Pendlebury did all his work when the game was close".... He was given 4.7% of the available points in first half , which before scaling was apparently76 ranking points and after match scaling 94 points. (his game was re-valued post match by 0.1%)
ESSENDON V MELBOURNE (QUARTER TIME SCORES).
ESSENDON.
2 Tom Bellchambers 44
11 David Zaharakis 41
21 Dyson Heppell 40
4 Jobe Watson 39
5 Brent Stanton 33
9 Brendon Goddard 29
18 Michael Hurley 28
31 Dustin Fletcher 27
40 Ben Howlett 26
12 Stewart Crameri 24
29 Alwyn Davey 20
17 Jake Melksham 20
46 Mark Baguley 20
23 David Myers 19
30 Patrick Ryder 18
39 Heath Hocking 13
22 Jake Carlisle 12
1 Michael Hibberd 11
26 Cale Hooker 7
15 Courtenay Dempsey 6
20 Jackson Merrett 0
38 Nick Kommer 0
MELBOURNE.
38 Jeremy Howe 38
8 James Frawley 35
31 Jack Grimes 30
36 Aaron Davey 25
25 Tom McDonald 25
20 Colin Garland 24
40 Mark Jamar 22
46 Dean Terlich 17
4 Jack Watts 17
11 Mitch Clark 14
27 Tom Gillies 13
7 Jack Viney 12
45 Matt Jones 11
9 Jack Trengove 10
30 James Sellar 10
12 Colin Sylvia 9
26 Daniel Nicholson 9
2 Nathan Jones 8
17 Sam Blease 6
5 Jimmy Toumpas 4
10 Shannon Byrnes 3
15 David Rodan 0
ESSENDON V MELBOURNE (HALF TIME SCORES).
ESSENDON.
21 Dyson Heppell 86
4 Jobe Watson 82
2 Tom Bellchambers 82
11 David Zaharakis 65
12 Stewart Crameri 65
9 Brendon Goddard 61
5 Brent Stanton 56
40 Ben Howlett 55
31 Dustin Fletcher 48
17 Jake Melksham 48
18 Michael Hurley 46
46 Mark Baguley 42
30 Patrick Ryder 39
23 David Myers 37
22 Jake Carlisle 34
29 Alwyn Davey 33
1 Michael Hibberd 28
39 Heath Hocking 27
15 Courtenay Dempsey 22
20 Jackson Merrett 17
26 Cale Hooker 10
38 Nick Kommer 0
MELBOURNE.
38 Jeremy Howe 67
8 James Frawley 63
20 Colin Garland 54
31 Jack Grimes 52
36 Aaron Davey 49
4 Jack Watts 41
25 Tom McDonald 34
40 Mark Jamar 33
11 Mitch Clark 33
27 Tom Gillies 29
2 Nathan Jones 28
45 Matt Jones 26
46 Dean Terlich 25
30 James Sellar 23
26 Daniel Nicholson 22
10 Shannon Byrnes 20
9 Jack Trengove 16
12 Colin Sylvia 15
7 Jack Viney 15
5 Jimmy Toumpas 7
17 Sam Blease 7
15 David Rodan 0
.****.. not much for Viney tonight i bet... scaling will probably mean players that scored better in first quarter and a bit will be weighted more towards points allocated
THREE QUARTER TIME
ESS 20.11.131 v MELB 5.5.35
Essendon:
4 Jobe Watson 132
12 Stewart Crameri 118
21 Dyson Heppell 110
2 Tom Bellchambers 100
11 David Zaharakis 95 (Subbed off)
5 Brent Stanton 93
9 Brendon Goddard 91
40 Ben Howlett 90
17 Jake Melksham 76
18 Michael Hurley 68
23 David Myers 67
46 Mark Baguley 64
31 Dustin Fletcher 60
30 Patrick Ryder 57
29 Alwyn Davey 54
1 Michael Hibberd 53
39 Heath Hocking 43
22 Jake Carlisle 43
15 Courtenay Dempsey 41
20 Jackson Merrett 34
26 Cale Hooker 26
38 Nick Kommer 4 (Subbed on)
Melbourne:
38 Jeremy Howe 94
8 James Frawley 90
20 Colin Garland 71
2 Nathan Jones 64
31 Jack Grimes 63
36 Aaron Davey 58
4 Jack Watts 49 (Subbed off)
25 Tom McDonald 45
45 Matt Jones 44
46 Dean Terlich 42
40 Mark Jamar 42
26 Daniel Nicholson 41
11 Mitch Clark 38
27 Tom Gillies 38
10 Shannon Byrnes 32
7 Jack Viney 29
9 Jack Trengove 28
30 James Sellar 26
12 Colin Sylvia 20
5 Jimmy Toumpas 14
17 Sam Blease 11
15 David Rodan 5 (Subbed on)
Before scaling, Ess have 16 players over 80 points, Melb 4!
The obvious question is, how did Melb get 4?!
Melbourne 1 goal 1 point after half time!
Ess 18 of the last 19 goals!
Which WCE players can we bring in next week. Guaranteed 100+!
I was tempted tonight to trade Maccaffer out, then swap Rowe to forward line and trade Callum Sinclair in as another rookie RUC/FWD from West Coast before tomorrow's games. Did not do it but did cross my mind as sounds like Lycett is not up to it for Eagles and with Quenton Lynch no longer an Eagle and Nick Nat on sidelines you never know Sinclair get a run for Eagles for a bit and gives me some extra options. I need to trade Toumpas and Karnezis next week which leaves me stuck with needing to keep faith in Watts up forward for now :-(
As for Essendon v Dees game this should be a great game to study the scaling.
The game was a blowout so you would think the 2nd half they reduce in weighting for the match. So the Demon players that had some impact at all in 1st half of rankings points are the ones to get a half decent score. I got Frawley, Howe, Garland, Grimes and Nathan Jones as only ones that were ranked on 80 points or more at end of match.
Frawley scores went 35, 63 and 90 at each quarter breaks
Howe 38, 67 & 94
Garland 24, 54 & 71
Grimes 30, 52 & 63
N Jones 8, 28 & 64
Interesting Zaharakis was subbed at 3/4 time and was on 95 at the time. He ended up after scaling after match of 103
Watts got subbed when on 49.. He ended up on 53...
Tells me the earlier parts of match before complete blowout and junk time city got in vogue was, when they scaled it to be worth more than originally done quarter by quarter.
I'll have to re-visit this more when I got a bit more time next week but very interesting how it works.
I sense you could come up with some interesting stats around all this Rowsus
