Re: Melbourne - It's very easy to make a different call in hindsight, but it just seems like they made the wrong decision with the players they delisted during their cleanout last year. Rather than taking the hard road and delisting (or putting on notice) obviously talented players that refuse to buy in like Sylvia and Watts to name a few, they seemed to choose choose the less talented players that had a crack like your Petterds. I guess they banked on bringing in players like Byrnes and Dawes from a successful culture to try and turn the mindset around from the inside out of the more talented playing list that they retained.
But because these players that they brought in are inherently less talented that the current group, they will never win respect, despite their achievements, because the initial group will be looking at them thinking "i'm a better player than you, if i was in that team (collingwoood or Geelong) i would have won premierships too.."
So what they are left with is a bunch of battlers from other clubs and the same disenterested, yet talented players with poor work ethic.
That approach was worth a punt, but it clearly hasn't worked. I'm not saying that Melbourne made the wrong decision with how they approached the clean out, because if i was in charge i would have taken the same road. But it hasn't worked and now, they have to identify the players that are perpetuating this culture of "cruising", keep the hard workers and cut their losses with players that don't buy in, no matter who they are.
My 2 cents.