Discussion Rookie Discussion

[Bomber18]

doubt it would be 6-7 games unfortunately most Carlton people seem to think he won't be rushed

I see, that's definitely a bit of a concern then on going too light up forward - thanks for that.

 

[jarrad_]

yes it is quite a shame but thankfully I have moved on (for now)

 

[Ben's Beasts]

Not sure if he’s been mentioned already but Logue from the Dockers sounds like he could be a viable pick in DEF.

Tad expensive at $164,300 but could be worth it.

https://www.perthnow.com.au/sport/f...ZaCpKkld7ipoHUFZx4Jo0E0jX0gOHSRdeh8gr-g5qL-8U

 

[The Experiment]

Not sure if he’s been mentioned already but Logue from the Dockers sounds like he could be a viable pick in DEF.

Tad expensive at $164,300 but could be worth it.

https://www.perthnow.com.au/sport/f...ZaCpKkld7ipoHUFZx4Jo0E0jX0gOHSRdeh8gr-g5qL-8U

Will play if fit...scoring potential the big question.

Serious athlete, question has been around his game sense / ability to read the game. Training watches seem to think he has sorted that out and consistently holds his own against the big bodied forwards, but obviously we won't know until the real thing rolls round. With Hamling and Pearce as the keys, he will be free to play that 3rd tall/intercepting role...will be in my starting line up

 

[Herbie66]

Rozee * , Collins , Logue , Quaynor , Duursma * , Wilkie , Burgess * , McKay , Hore , + 1

maybe I should try my all rookie defence again ?

or 1-1-6

Corbett doesn't look viable for Rd 1 so leaves Setterfield , Drew ,Petrucelle , Cavarra , Parker , FD up forward

update today

add

Jones
Moore , Schultz , couple of Crows but not sure if there is a spot , Wilkinson + FD

to the watch list

hoping 3-0-5 for both lines is viable

 

[TopBillings]

update today

add

Jones
Moore , Schultz , couple of Crows but not sure if there is a spot

to the watch list

hoping 3-0-5 for both lines is viable

Jordan Clark

 

[Herbie66]

Jordan Clark

haven't seen anything of note so far

 

[WO FAT]

haven't seen anything of note so far

NEW FACES: First-round draft pick from 2018 Jordan Clark hasn’t missed a beat in the pre-season and will play JLT. VFL tackling machine Tom Atkins will also get a crack in the midfield, as will high-possession winner Charlie Constable and ruckman Darcy Fort.

 

[TopBillings]

haven't seen anything of note so far

Most of BF Geelong board have him best 22 already
https://www.geelongadvertiser.com.a...s/news-story/b58b6624f3b3a28bb22d88a5de7d27e9

 

[Herbie66]

NEW FACES: First-round draft pick from 2018 Jordan Clark hasn’t missed a beat in the pre-season and will play JLT. VFL tackling machine Tom Atkins will also get a crack in the midfield, as will high-possession winner Charlie Constable and ruckman Darcy Fort.

Cheers for that

is he above Atkins , Constable , Dahlhaus , Rohan ?

 

[Herbie66]

Most of BF Geelong board have him best 22 already
https://www.geelongadvertiser.com.a...s/news-story/b58b6624f3b3a28bb22d88a5de7d27e9

what does Scott and match committee think though ?

would think they got Dahl & Rohan for a reason , Atkins + Constable

 

[WO FAT]

Cheers for that

is he above Atkins , Constable , Dahlhaus , Rohan ?

The Cats board has him in best 22 apparently...TopBillings left a link...cheers

 

[WO FAT]

what does Scott and match committee think though ?

would think they got Dahl & Rohan for a reason , Atkins + Constable

Do any of those mentioned play HBF

 

[TopBillings]

Do any of those mentioned play HBF

Nope

Rohan is a spud

 

[Herbie66]

Do any of those mentioned play HBF

shuffle the 22 around to fit everyone in , rarely like for like , talk was Selwood may even play HBF

Rohan certainly has played defence before at Sydney , run and dash could be very useful

 

[Herbie66]

The Cats board has him in best 22 apparently...TopBillings left a link...cheers

As good as the Cats board is they don't actually select the side though.

 

[TopBillings]

Clark will play round 1 imo - Geelong need fresh young talent in ASAP

 

[WO FAT]

Do any of those mentioned play HBF

Nope

Rohan is a spud

That was my point and agree with Rohan

 

[Nathan]

As good as the Cats board is they don't actually select the side though.

Well ye, but why are you doing rookie updates? Guessing the clubs match committees aren’t feeding you the information.

 

[Herbie66]

Well ye, but why are you doing rookie updates? Guessing the clubs match committees aren’t feeding you the information.

just thought I would share some information , if it bothers you don't read it