Discussion Rookie Roulette!

[Nathan]

Field 2 out of Butters Stack Ross Gibbons

No thank you

 

[Bomber18]

McStay or Hipwood looks to be his likely matchup, game will be during the day so no threat of drew to make marking difficult.

When BRI have been playing well this season, they tend to look for short leading targets when going forward rather than bombing the ball. This will really depend on how close the game is after HT. If BRIS takes control early and are comfortable then we'll likely see his score in that lower bracket. I'm predicting an easy win for BRI so going to say something between 55-60 for Collins.

Interesting thoughts. Trading Collins this round doesn’t seem like the worst move if he’s only going to score a 60 odd.

I might just bench Collins.... Hore seems hard to not put on field after his last two games.

 

[quite ironic]

Pick 3 to field:

Duursma, Collins, Scrimshaw, Hore, Clark.

I’ve ruled out Clark unless someone convinces me otherwise.

Who should I bench of the other 4?

I was thinking of Hore, Collins, Scrimshaw and benching Duursma this week but not sure.

 

[Jim's Dim Sims]

Pick 3 to field:

Duursma, Collins, Scrimshaw, Hore, Clark.

I’ve ruled out Clark unless someone convinces me otherwise.

Who should I bench of the other 4?

I was thinking of Hore, Collins, Scrimshaw and benching Duursma this week but not sure.

I would go Hore, Scrimshaw and flip a coin between Collins/Duursma.

 

[quite ironic]

I would go Hore, Scrimshaw and flip a coin between Collins/Duursma.

Haha exactly what I was thinking! Can’t seem to split those two.

Duursma potentially in a win and Collins in a loss enough to swing one way?

 

[Jim's Dim Sims]

Haha exactly what I was thinking! Can’t seem to split those two.

Duursma potentially in a win and Collins in a loss enough to swing one way?

Seems sound enough to me. Averaging 5 more in any case.

 

[Eagling]

I've got Scrimshaw/Duursma D6/7 and if both play I'll E Duursma as he'll act as cover if any premiums miss, and if they do and you have an appropriate D8 you can loophole with Duursma.

 

[quite ironic]

I've got Scrimshaw/Duursma D6/7 and if both play I'll E Duursma as he'll act as cover if any premiums miss, and if they do and you have an appropriate D8 you can loophole with Duursma.

I like that idea with Duursma for Collins, hope Clark is dropped then get a free look at Duursma into Collins

 

[Diabolical]

Bines is more consistent, but Darling has a better ceiling

Relton Roberts never scored as low as Darling did last week in his entire career.

 

[PC]

Relton Roberts never scored as low as Darling did last week in his entire career.

Relton had a fairly short career it must be said...

 

[quite ironic]

Bringing Drew into M8 for Constable now with Setterfield down to F6 to get Baker’s score.


Anyone talk me into Constable over Drew?

 

[pizza safety]

Bringing Drew into M8 for Constable now with Setterfield down to F6 to get Baker’s score.


Anyone talk me into Constable over Drew?

Might do the same with Butters

 

[OzRulesFootball]

Had E on Baker after I traded Sam Collins to him. Setters on field.... Tick
Ok, now Bailey Scott gets his emergency loophole chance in the mids. His last chance basically.

In defence all of Duursma, Scrimshaw and Clark will be on field and hope to make an upgrade next week to reduce rookies on field there.

 

[Juzzo]

2 to field:
Collins
Scrimmer
Ridler
Clark

Leaning towards Collins and Scrimmer, not sure why really.

 

[PC]

2 to field:
Collins
Scrimmer
Ridler
Clark

Leaning towards Collins and Scrimmer, not sure why really.

Collins and Scrim for me

 

[Mr_Arrogance]

2 to field:
Collins
Scrimmer
Ridler
Clark

Leaning towards Collins and Scrimmer, not sure why really.

i would take clark out of the convo, put scrimshaw top of the list for good chance at 70, then toss a coin between collins/ridley. collins has good chance at decent score but could also throw up a stinker

 

[XabiFernando]

Scott on field as C to take Grundy's score, also means I'm taking Stack's 72.

Who does Scott replace? Cousins or Constable?

 

[Ormos]

Scott on field as C to take Grundy's score, also means I'm taking Stack's 72.

Who does Scott replace? Cousins or Constable?

cousins

 

[Eagling]

Stack's 72 v Constable.

Constable has beaten 72 3/4 times...

 

[OzRulesFootball]

72 is borderline roll the dice on other rookie in the mids line.
If a forward or defence rookie you almost certainly take. Midfield not 100% sold on as you got to expect mids to score better even as rookies than other lines. Constable I'd back in to get more. Cousins I watched less of but Eagling post suggests you might leave Stack on bench. Borderline decision I guess.