Opinion Rate My AFL SuperCoach Team
- Thread starter Ironhawk
- Start date
- Joined
- 15 Oct 2018
- Messages
- 3,912
- Likes
- 12,177
- AFL Club
- Essendon
First Post Marsh team
Thoughts welcome...Roberton I'm not 100% sold on but I feel like you may as well pay up for him given that Noble and Cumming are both unproven. Gone cheap as anything in the forward line out of necessity given how awful the rookies are. There's still a question mark over whether some of these are out there R1 but not much more can be done yet.
Thoughts welcome...Roberton I'm not 100% sold on but I feel like you may as well pay up for him given that Noble and Cumming are both unproven. Gone cheap as anything in the forward line out of necessity given how awful the rookies are. There's still a question mark over whether some of these are out there R1 but not much more can be done yet.
- Joined
- 24 Feb 2015
- Messages
- 6,697
- Likes
- 30,160
- AFL Club
- Sydney
This is probably the best Gawn side I have seen, you have squeezed every dollar possible to get 14 keepers + Roberton. I see Steven has sneaked in, potentially for the first time all preseason? Looks like everyone is now jumping on board.
If we don’t end up getting Budarick, I presume your move would be Roberton down to Noble and then maybe pushing Budarick to a Davis/Crocker.
What’s your plan if Robertson/Sharp/Mahony don’t play? Starting two donuts there or chopping TLynch down and maybe getting Anderson?
Also you will be reliant on one of TWatson/BWilliams playing, I guess if they don’t you will need to chop a premium to take one of those up to say ZGuthrie/Noble or start BWilliams type as a donut.
If we don’t end up getting Budarick, I presume your move would be Roberton down to Noble and then maybe pushing Budarick to a Davis/Crocker.
What’s your plan if Robertson/Sharp/Mahony don’t play? Starting two donuts there or chopping TLynch down and maybe getting Anderson?
Also you will be reliant on one of TWatson/BWilliams playing, I guess if they don’t you will need to chop a premium to take one of those up to say ZGuthrie/Noble or start BWilliams type as a donut.
Just wiped the last 4 weeks out of mind and gone back to basics :-
1. Build your Rucks
Grundy , Gawn / Comden
2. Follow the rookies (realistically)
3. Don't punt on $ 250-$300 players suddenly becoming superstars
so this is it (maybe)
F: WHITFIELD * , D MARTIN * , TJ LYNCH , STEVEN * , Rankine , C Taylor / M King , Mahony *
M: MACRAE , CRIPPS , J KELLY , DUNKLEY , BONTEMPELLI , D SMITH * , Rowell , Anderson / Green , Pickett , Budarick *
R: GRUNDY , GAWN / Comben *
D: DOCHERTY , Z Guthrie , BZT , McAsey , Starcevich * , Williamson / Brander * , Williams *
It is such a work of art , I am almost in tears revealing it to you all ?
Simplicity at it's best
D: 0-1-7
M: 5-1-5
R: 2-0-1
F: 2-2-4
$ 200,800.00 in the bank for adjustments
Good luck all
EDIT
Dusty will be the one I am happy to leave out if another rookie priced must have midfielder is named for Round 1 and I need to shore up my defence , plenty of flexibility and options
1. Build your Rucks
Grundy , Gawn / Comden
2. Follow the rookies (realistically)
3. Don't punt on $ 250-$300 players suddenly becoming superstars
so this is it (maybe)
F: WHITFIELD * , D MARTIN * , TJ LYNCH , STEVEN * , Rankine , C Taylor / M King , Mahony *
M: MACRAE , CRIPPS , J KELLY , DUNKLEY , BONTEMPELLI , D SMITH * , Rowell , Anderson / Green , Pickett , Budarick *
R: GRUNDY , GAWN / Comben *
D: DOCHERTY , Z Guthrie , BZT , McAsey , Starcevich * , Williamson / Brander * , Williams *
It is such a work of art , I am almost in tears revealing it to you all ?
Simplicity at it's best
D: 0-1-7
M: 5-1-5
R: 2-0-1
F: 2-2-4
$ 200,800.00 in the bank for adjustments
Good luck all
EDIT
Dusty will be the one I am happy to leave out if another rookie priced must have midfielder is named for Round 1 and I need to shore up my defence , plenty of flexibility and options
Last edited:
- Joined
- 11 Feb 2014
- Messages
- 5,329
- Likes
- 28,688
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
Thoughts please anyone ???
B. Sicily , Docherty, Cummings , Thatcher , Young , Starcevich ( Brander , Watson )
M. Cripps , Mitchell , Danger , Bont , Cogs , Rowell , Green , Pickett ( Rivers , Mahony , Buderick )
R. Gawn , Grundy ( Comben )
F. Whitfield , Dusty , Lynch , Steven , Smith , Taylor ( Cameron , Rankine )
Think this is close for me , obviously rookies playing to be decided and not sure on Young in defence but only $5800 left so narrows options
Best of luck to everyone this season
FT
B. Sicily , Docherty, Cummings , Thatcher , Young , Starcevich ( Brander , Watson )
M. Cripps , Mitchell , Danger , Bont , Cogs , Rowell , Green , Pickett ( Rivers , Mahony , Buderick )
R. Gawn , Grundy ( Comben )
F. Whitfield , Dusty , Lynch , Steven , Smith , Taylor ( Cameron , Rankine )
Think this is close for me , obviously rookies playing to be decided and not sure on Young in defence but only $5800 left so narrows options
Best of luck to everyone this season
FT
Looks a mighty fine effort to me , mid bench rookies might be a slight worry but both Budarick & Mahony have DPP ✓
not sure on Cumming's JS myself but Noble , Guthrie & McAsey could be alternatives , monitor Young fitness
Williamson & Williams (WCE) could be options as well
like how you have a premium at D1
just sit and wait for teams to be announced now
Good luck
PS thanks for posting the scores
not sure on Cumming's JS myself but Noble , Guthrie & McAsey could be alternatives , monitor Young fitness
Williamson & Williams (WCE) could be options as well
like how you have a premium at D1
just sit and wait for teams to be announced now
Good luck
PS thanks for posting the scores
- Joined
- 11 Feb 2014
- Messages
- 5,329
- Likes
- 28,688
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
Thanks Herbie ,
just hoping Fan Footy will do that through the normal season after all the talk earlier about the non posting of SC live scores
I've heard Lynden Dunne from the pies is really trying for that defensive spot and i just question imo Nobles JS if both Scharenberg and Dunne come back into that defence along with Crisp , Howe , Mayne , Roughhead etc , he has in his favour i guess that Buckley loves him , just food for thought
just hoping Fan Footy will do that through the normal season after all the talk earlier about the non posting of SC live scores
I've heard Lynden Dunne from the pies is really trying for that defensive spot and i just question imo Nobles JS if both Scharenberg and Dunne come back into that defence along with Crisp , Howe , Mayne , Roughhead etc , he has in his favour i guess that Buckley loves him , just food for thought
I saw a comment on FanFooty that Monty was in a legal dispute with the HS about posting the scores or something so not sure how true that is or not.
Think it is probably Noble's spot to lose , Quaynor has had a interrupted pre-season , Varcoe is still a fair way off.
Suspect Crisp , Howe , Maynard , Moore & Roughead are all locked in.
Scharenberg is certainly another option , normally have 7 defenders so their should be enough room.
Was Phillips playing more defensively last season or not ? suspect he , Mayne , Sidey & WHE will rotate through the arcs
Think it is probably Noble's spot to lose , Quaynor has had a interrupted pre-season , Varcoe is still a fair way off.
Suspect Crisp , Howe , Maynard , Moore & Roughead are all locked in.
Scharenberg is certainly another option , normally have 7 defenders so their should be enough room.
Was Phillips playing more defensively last season or not ? suspect he , Mayne , Sidey & WHE will rotate through the arcs