Discussion Rookie Discussion

Joined
8 Oct 2018
Messages
10,254
Likes
36,906
AFL Club
Port Adelaide
so based on what @Bomber18 just posted , more than enough rookies (24)

Noble , Ash * , BZT , McAsey , Starcevich * , Brander * , Williams *

Rowell , Anderson , Serong , Green , Pickett

Jackson

Townsend , Schultz , ZGL , CCJ * , Kropenyeri-Pickett , Georgiades , Davis , King , Rankine , Sturt , Taylor

shouldn't be too hard to create a side using these , wait for Wednesday to confirm Carlton & Richmond teams.

Hopefully clubs announce their debutants early in the week
Looking at those listed that I might be interested in brings that down from 24 down to 16 ...

- DEF .... 6 of them
- MID .... all 5 of them
- Ruck ... none of them
- FWD ... 3 of them

Taking away those with a * drops it to 2 / 5 / 0 / 3 etc and I'm left with 11 ...
 
Last edited:
Joined
25 Jul 2012
Messages
47,728
Likes
107,810
AFL Club
Collingwood
Looking at those listed that I might be interested in brings thtat down from 24 down to 16 ...

- DEF .... 6 of them
- MID .... all 5 of them
- Ruck ... none of them
- FWD ... 3 of them

Taking away those with a * drops it to 2 / 5 / 0 / 4 etc and I'm left with 11 ...
I don't mind all the defender options aside from McAsey (JS) , Ash could depend on whether Williams is not named.

Mids we may not have much choice , although probably need to study Freo's injury list a lot more.

I won't need Jackson.

As I thought the forwards will probably give us the most , happy to take 4 x $ 123,900.00

Will probably end up taking Budarick and/or Mahony.

Looked liked quite a few were named as Emergencies so we may end up having more or less
 

Ben's Beasts

Leadership Group
Joined
6 Jan 2013
Messages
19,072
Likes
80,335
AFL Club
Melbourne
No mention of North’s Mahony in those expected teams for round 1, not even an emergency. He’s been talked up multiple times internally during the pre-season and averaged 71% TOG over both JLT matches so expecting he gets named round 1.

Will be a slow burn but at $117,300 he’s a cheap option for the mid bench.
 
Joined
8 Oct 2018
Messages
10,254
Likes
36,906
AFL Club
Port Adelaide
No mention of North’s Mahony in those expected teams for round 1, not even an emergency. He’s been talked up multiple times internally during the pre-season and averaged 71% TOG over both JLT matches so expecting he gets named round 1.

Will be a slow burn but at $117,300 he’s a cheap option for the mid bench.
Don't see a spot for him personally unless an injury frees up a spot .... got my eye on Sharp / Budarik as potential other options later on in the season as well ...
 
Joined
25 Jul 2012
Messages
47,728
Likes
107,810
AFL Club
Collingwood
IF - as posted above was the case regarding rookies likely to play round one, I'd more than likely be forced to play Naismith I think just to fit all the higher priced guys in. Well and truly outside of my comfort zome here.
can't see the issue personally , seems fairly easy to start 13 + Roberton which most of the RMT teams were

still have Gawn , Grundy , 5 Super mids + Whitfield

Laird or Sicily + 4 under pricers who will go at 90+

you might need to look at Grundy , Jacobs , Naismith as a alternative ruck option ?

just got to follow the rookies where they are named
 
Joined
8 Oct 2018
Messages
10,254
Likes
36,906
AFL Club
Port Adelaide
can't see the issue personally , seems fairly easy to start 13 + Roberton which most of the RMT teams were

still have Gawn , Grundy , 5 Super mids + Whitfield

Laird or Sicily + 4 under pricers who will go at 90+

you might need to look at Grundy , Jacobs , Naismith as a alternative ruck option ?

just got to follow the rookies where they are named
Following round 1 named rookies is a fine initial starting outlook .. still got bad memories from that last year though ... Balta !!

- JS and cash generation though is more the key to me though ....
- Need up to 6 early consecutive games of reasonable scoring to me ...
 

THCLT

BBL|05 Winner
Joined
13 Sep 2014
Messages
18,593
Likes
118,245
AFL Club
North Melb.
All hypothetical from the AFL website, but maybe this format will help coaches to finetune their Rookies setup before teams are announced.

Named in the 22
D: Noble, Ash, BZT, Mcasey, Starcevich, Brander, Williams
M: Rowell, Anderson, Serong, Green, Pickett
R: CCJ, Jackson
F: KKPickett, Georgiades, Taylor, Davis, Rankine, King, Sturt

Listed as Emergencies
D: Williamson, Watson
M: Stephens, T Brown, RCD, Robertson
R: Cameron
F: Bonar, Sparrow, Frampton, Crocker, Weightman, Budarick
 
Joined
25 Jul 2012
Messages
47,728
Likes
107,810
AFL Club
Collingwood
Following round 1 named rookies is a fine initial starting outlook .. still got bad memories from that last year though ... Balta !!

- JS and cash generation though is more the key to me though ....
- Need up to 6 early consecutive games of reasonable scoring to me ...
Think it's a bonus if they are named Round 1 , who knows for certain if they are going to last 6-8 games in a row ?

Didn't Balta end up making over $ 150 k ?

Yes I started Parker , Scott , Setterfield and some other dud.

Plenty of other options in that $ 200-300k bracket to start that probably will all need to be upgraded though.

Certainly looks like there will be enough rookies to start but as for their scoring potential and JS then hopefully they play well enough to stay in the team.

I can't see the point in starting players that are not even named though on the bench just because they fit into the < or = $ 123,900.00 mark and then "hope" they play , hopefully these players present in Round 7-8 as downgrade targets

See what official teamsheets bring I guess
 
Joined
25 Jul 2012
Messages
47,728
Likes
107,810
AFL Club
Collingwood
All hypothetical from the AFL website, but maybe this format will help coaches to finetune their Rookies setup before teams are announced.

Named in the 22
D: Noble, Ash, BZT, Mcasey, Starcevich, Brander, Williams
M: Rowell, Anderson, Serong, Green, Pickett
R: CCJ, Jackson
F: KKPickett, Georgiades, Taylor, Davis, Rankine, King, Sturt

Listed as Emergencies
D: Williamson, Watson
M: Stephens, T Brown, RCD, Robertson
R: Cameron
F: Bonar, Sparrow, Frampton, Crocker, Weightman, Budarick
4 less than what I previously posted ?
 
Top